Efficacy of Resin Infiltration of Proximal Caries

NCT ID: NCT04092296

Last Updated: 2019-09-17

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: UNKNOWN
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 37 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2018-08-10
• Study Completion Date: 2021-08-10

Brief Summary

The aim of the present study was to assess the clinical efficacy of resin infiltration of interproximal caries lesions using a novel measure method-----DIAGNOcam. This study is conducted on adults (15-40y）with the aim of comparing the therapeutic effects of infiltrating caries lesions and fluoride remineralization treatment after 1, 2, and 3 yrs. The outcome (lesion progression) is evaluated by DIAGNOcam and radiographic techniques.And we would compare the sensitivity of monitoring progression of caries between DIAGNOcam and bitewing radiography.

Detailed Description

On the baseline,At a screening visit, eligibility of interested participants is checked with DIAGNOcam by a researcher(WF),in addition,a pair of standardized conventional bitewing radiographs is taken using a film holder Kwik-Bite by a very experienced dental assistant .

two reviewers(SC、XYJ) who are trained the scoring systems score the DIAGNOcam and bitewing image independently,disagreements are solved by consensus and a final DIAGNOcam and bitewing score are given.Participants who have two E2 lesions are picked to join the first set up.

A.DIAGNOcam image scoring system:

E1:Dark shadow confined to the out half of the enamel E2:Dark shadow confined to the inner half of the enamel D1:Dark shadow reach dentin ,dentin caries penetrating the enamel-dentin junction linerly D2:Deep dentin are involved

B .bitewing radiograph scoring system:

E1 = radiolucency in the out half of the enamel; E2 = radiolucency extending to the enamel dentine junction; D1= radiolucency into dentine but limited to the outer third; D2 = radiolucency into middle or middle third of the dentine; D3 = radiolucency into middle or inner third of the dentine; 2.3 Caries risk and periodontal condition assessment On the baseline ,we use the dmft/s to asess the caries risk.In addition,Occurrence of plaque is scored as 0 = no visible plaque or 1 = visible plaque; the status of the gingiva is scored as 0 = sound, 1 = redness, with no bleeding after probing, 2 = bleeding after probing, and 3 = heavily inflamed.

2.4 Allocation From each pair, 1 lesion is allocated to the "test" and 1 to the "control" group using random number table and sealed in opaque envelope to prevent the allocation being known in advance of, or during, enrolment 2.5 Treatment INTERVENTION 1:Resin infiltration:Treatment is performed by a single trained investigator (WF) at the Wuhan University stomatological Hospital . A rubber dam is applied to achieve dry working conditions. In the test group, allocated teeth are slightly separated by plastic wedges (Wedge Wands, small or medium; Garrison, Übach-Palenberg, Germany) that have been flattened by a scalpel to leave space below the contact point. A piece of polyurethane foil is placed in the contact area with a plastic holder to protect the adjacent tooth. A 15% HCl etching gel (Icon product, DMG, Hamburg,Germany) is applied by syringe in the area below the contact point for 120 sec. Subsequently, the gel is washed off with air-water-spray for 30 sec. The lesion is desiccated by air-blowing for 30 sec, application of ethanol for 30 sec, and air- blow ing again for 30 sec. An infiltrant (Icon product,DMG) is applied with another plastic holder,in this time the investigator need to shut off the light.. After 3 min of penetration time, excess material is removed by air blowing and flossing, and the resin is light-cured for 1 min from the buccal, occlusal, and oral aspects. The infiltration step is repeated once with a penetration time of 1 min to infiltrate remaining porosities.

To avoid behavioral changes of participants with regard to oral hygiene, we will not inform them about the treatment allocation of their teeth. To ensure blinding, we perform a placebo treatment on control teeth: Instead of HCl-gel and infiltrant, water is used. Fluoridation, oral hygiene, and dietary instructions are given to the patients.

After the application of the infiltrant,and restoration,we will check with DIAGNOcam and Bitewing radiography again,because we have no idea about the characteristics of the DIAGNOcam image after resin infiltration.

2.6 Follow-up Examination Every three months since then, participants will be re-called for follow-up examination. DIAGNOcam and bitewing examinations are operated by the same investigator(WF) and the same experienced dental assistant .

Clinical examination and caries risk assessment are performed by one clinical investigator (YCC), who is blinded with regard to treatment group allocation of teeth.

The primary outcome is the progression of lesion depth, assessed by pair-wise comparison DIAGNOcam and pair-wise comparison of the bitewing radiographs .

Secondary outcome

1. Patients will be interviewed for possible unwanted side-effects.

2. Participant and operator perception, as measured by standardised/validated questionnaires

3. The sensitivity of DIAGNOcam and bitewing radiography in monitoring caries' progression.

Additional follow-up examinations are planned 24 and 36 months after intervention.

If a lesion of any group progresses during the follow-up period radiographically to the D2 or D3 stage, restorative treatment will be performed.

In order to allow for reproducible DIAGNOcam geometry, the handled camera keeps vertical to the tooth long axis.

DIAGNOcam images as well as bitewing radiographs will be assessed by two reviewers(SC,XYJ) independently (inter-examiner reliability was assessed), both of whom are blinded with regard to treatment group allocation. Both assessors attend a training and calibration session one day prior to examination. By anonymising the radiographs, masking the stage of treatment (i.e. baseline or follow-up) or both to ensure adequate blinding of assessors.First, the DIAGNOcam and radiographic stage (E1-D3) of lesions at baseline and follow-up examination was assessed. Subsequently, examiners read the DIAGNOcam images and radiographs pairwise and judged whether lesions showed progression, regression, or were stable. In cases of different interpretation between examiners, a consensus rank was agreed. To assess intra-observer reliability, we repeated the readings after 4 wks.

3.Statistical Analysis Inter- as well as intra-observer reliability was assessed by kappa statistics. We used the X2test to analyze differences between treatment and control groups with regard to lesion progression (pair-wise comparison using DIAGNOcam and bitewing).

Conditions

Caries; Initial

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: PREVENTION
• Blinding Strategy: TRIPLE

Study Groups

resin infiltration

resin infiltrant (Icon product, DMG, Hamburg,Germany)

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

resin infiltration

Intervention Type: OTHER

using infiltrant resin intervene proximal caries

remineralization

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

remineralization

Intervention Type: OTHER

using fluoride to remineralize proximal caries

sham

Intervention Type: OTHER

replace resin with water

Interventions

resin infiltration

using infiltrant resin intervene proximal caries

Intervention Type: OTHER

remineralization

using fluoride to remineralize proximal caries

Intervention Type: OTHER

sham

replace resin with water

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

individuals who want to participate in the study ,the presence of 2 or more non-cavitated interproximal caries lesions with dark shadow involved in the enamel on the DIAGNOcam image -

Exclusion Criteria

• patient who diagnosed with dentinogenesis imperfecta

• Minimum Eligible Age: 15 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 40 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Wuhan University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Fei Wang

graduate student

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

liuyan meng, dovtor

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Hospital of Stomatology, Wuhan University

Locations

Wuhan university

Wuhan, Hubei, China

Site Status: RECRUITING

Countries

China

Central Contacts

fei wang

Role: CONTACT

121565382@qq.com

15927529467

Facility Contacts

fei wang, graduate

Role: primary

121565382@qq.com

15927529467

liuyan meng, doctor

Role: backup

mengliuyan@whu.edu.cn

15827652404

Other Identifiers

20180103

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id