A Study Using Fractional Carbon Dioxide and Long Pulsed Neodymium-yttrium Aluminum Garnet Lasers in Treatment of Keloids

NCT ID: NCT03460431

Last Updated: 2018-03-09

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 30 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2014-07-01
• Study Completion Date: 2017-06-30

Brief Summary

clinical comparative study comparing the effectiveness of fractional CO2, long pulsed Nd YAG and their combination in collagen remodeling in keloid clinically, biochemically and histopathologically

Detailed Description

Patients The study included 30 Egyptian patients with keloid scar recruited from the Out Patient Clinic, Dermatology Department, Cairo University.

Methodology

Patients:

• Thirty patients with keloid scar(s) were included in the study

• Every patient was subjected to the following:

1. Complete history taking: History of disease onset, course and duration, family history as well as history of any systemic or dermatological disease interfering with the eligibility of participation in the study.

Thirty patients were included in the study which is a clinical comparative study comparing the effectiveness of fractional CO2, long pulsed Nd YAG and their combination in collagen remodeling in keloid clinically in all the included patients and biochemically and immunohistochemically fifteen patient

2. Full clinical examination:

• General examination to determine any systemic or dermatological disease that might preclude the patient from participation in the study such as collagen disease.
• Local examination to determine Fitzpatrick skin color of the patient and the site and extent of the scar to be treated.

Methods:

• Cases with multiple keloid scars three lesions 2 to 3 cm apart from each other were selected and labeled. The first one (lesion A) was treated using fractional CO2 laser 10,600 nm, the second (lesion B) long pulsed Nd YAG laser 1064 nm, while the last (lesion C) combined fractional CO2 followed by Nd YAG lasers after half an hour were used

• patients who had a large sized lesion, the lesion was divided into three equal parts 2 to 3 cm apart from each other, they were labeled as areas A, B and C then subjected to the same treatment modalities as mentioned in case of multiple lesions.
• Patients received 4 treatment sessions 4 to 8 weeks apart. Laser modalities and parameters
• Topical anesthesia (lidocaine 2.5% and prilocaine 2.5%) was applied to the working area 30 to 60 minutes before the sessions, washed off and properly dried before the procedure.
• Ablative fractional 10,600 nm carbon dioxide laser (DEKA smartxide DOT, Italy) and long pulsed Nd-YAG (DEKA synchro FT) were used in the treatment sessions with the following parameters Fractional CO2 Stacking: 5, Power: 20 Watt, Dwell time: 1000 micro second, Spacing : 800 micro meter fluence: 40 j/cm2 Pulse duration: 0.3 milli second Spot size: 5 mm Passes: 3.

Assessment Assessment was done before treatment every session and one months after the final laser treatment. Clinical assessment was done for all patients while histopathological and biochemical assessment were done only in 15 patients.

A. Clinical evaluation Clinical assessment was fulfilled via calculating the scores of both the Vancouver Scar Scale; and the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale. Patients were assessed every session, any side effects were reported, e.g pain, swelling, infection, hyper pigmentation or hypo pigmentation.

B. Histopathological and biochemical evaluation

Fifteen patients were randomly selected and subjected to the pre and post treatment biopsies :

• Pretreatment biopsy:

Three mm punch skin biopsy was taken from the keloid (any lesion A, B, or C) before starting treatment sessions ●Post treatment biopsies: Each lesion (A, B, C) was biopsied separately (3 mm punch biopsy), one month after last treatment session.

Biopsies of controls ●parts of excess skin from 12 patients undergoing abdominoplasty were used as controls for levels of TGFβ1 and TGFβ3.

Procedure

• Biopsies were fixed in 10 % neutral buffered formalin, and then embedded in paraffin blocks. Sections were prepared for routine staining by H&E. Other sections were prepared for histochemical staining of collagen fibres using Masson's trichrome stain and elastic fibres using orcein stain

• All sections were examined using a Zeiss, Primo star light microscope (Zeiss, Germany). The microscope has an integrated camera by which photomicrographs depicting the various histopathological and histochemical findings were obtained. All photomicrographs presented in the thesis are according to their original magnification.

• Evaluation of elastic fibres in orcein stained sections:

Orcein stained sections were graded according to the grading criteria proved by Ozog et al. in 2013 for the appearance of the dermal elastic tissue as follows:

0 normal

1. short fragmented elastic fibres

2. intermediate between 1 and 3

3. fibrillar elastic fibres, parallel to epidermis

4. intermediate between 3 and 5

5. absent or nearly absent.

Image analyzer evaluation (morphometric study):

The area percent of collagen and elastic fibres were quantitatively evaluated in Masson's trichrome and orcein stained sections respectively at magnification X100 in 5 non overlapping fields for all patients. Image analysis was done using Leica Qwin 500C image analyzer computer system (England) present in the Histology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University .

Conditions

Keloid

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: CROSSOVER
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm one session every month for 4 months

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm

Intervention Type: DEVICE

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm session, every month for 4 months

Nd YAG laser 1064nm

Nd YAG laser 1064nm

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Nd YAG laser1064 nm

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Nd YAG laser1064 nm laser session, every month for 4 months

combined two laser types

combined fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm and Nd YAG laser 1064nm lasers treatment to keloid

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm

Intervention Type: DEVICE

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm session, every month for 4 months

Nd YAG laser1064 nm

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Nd YAG laser1064 nm laser session, every month for 4 months

Interventions

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm

fractional CO2 laser 10,600nm session, every month for 4 months

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Nd YAG laser1064 nm

Nd YAG laser1064 nm laser session, every month for 4 months

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Patients with keloid scars of at least 6 months duration.
• No limitations regarding sex of the patients.
• Patients with three or more lesions 2 to 3 cm apart or patients having a large sized lesion.

Exclusion Criteria

• Patients who had received any form of treatment during the last four weeks prior to treatment such as intralesional steroids or a laser procedure during the last six months.
• Patients with active skin infections e.g. herpes or autoimmune disease.
• Patients with previous history of adverse outcome related to laser therapy.
• Recent use of Isotretinoin (within 6 months prior to the procedure).
• Patients with known allergies to lidocaine.
• Smoking, pregnancy
• Patients with unrealistic expectations

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Cairo University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Ahmed Foad Mohamed

specialist of dermatology.students hospital. Cairo university

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Shereen O Tawfik, MD

Role: STUDY_DIRECTOR

professor of Dermatology.faculty of medicine. Cairo university

Other Identifiers

3060114

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id