Clinical Evaluation of Enamel Microhardness Using Tooth Whitening Agents

NCT ID: NCT07165366

Last Updated: 2026-01-20

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 40 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2024-06-13
• Study Completion Date: 2025-06-01

Brief Summary

The investigator will review the medical history taken by the participants' orthodontist that determined participants eligibility to participate in this study on the first appointment. If the investigator determines that the position and condition of participants' teeth meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria for participation in this study, the participant will be enrolled to participate in the study. Once accepted, a small area (1 mm) of the premolars will be flattened and polished. Next, participants upper teeth will be scanned to make an impression, and the bleaching tray will be made on it. None of these procedures are painful, nor do they require anesthesia. This first appointment will last about 60 minutes. At the second appointment, the initial color of the upper premolar to be bleached will be taken. Participants will also be given a personalized whitening tray, a container to store the tray when not in use, a tube of low-concentration teeth whitening agent, and a toothbrush and toothpaste. The investigator will show participants how to place the tray on the upper arch. Participants will wear it through the night for fourteen nights. Participants will be given a chart to mark every night when the tray is used and teeth are brushed. Investigators will call participants the next day and in 7 days to see if participants have had any problems putting the gel in the tray and using it. This appointment will last approximately 30 minutes. The third appointment will consist of the investigator isolating one of the lower premolars that will be extracted. Some gel will be applied to that tooth three times; each time, the gel will stay on participant's tooth for 20 minutes. If the soft tissue or tooth is sensitive, a soothing gel will be applied to relieve the discomfort. This appointment will last approximately 90 minutes. The fourth appointment will be 14 days after the at-home bleaching was done and the in-office bleaching was accomplished. During this appointment, a lower premolar might be etched for 15 seconds. At this appointment, the oral surgeon the participant's orthodontist recommends will extract the participant's teeth. That will be the final appointment. During these 14 days, participant must keep cleaning teeth every day at least twice a day.

Detailed Description

14- PROJECT METHODOLOGY: Methods and materials This study consists of 40 patients requiring the extraction of four permanent first or second premolars for orthodontic reasons. Patients will be recruited from the Universidad Intercontinental (UIC) Graduate Program in Orthodontics, and private orthodontist dental offices in the city of Mexico. Patients who identify as needing extraction of the four first or second permanent premolars and who meet the following inclusion criteria will be invited to participate in the study.

Inclusion criteria:

• Have the four premolars in different quadrants that their orthodontist recommends be extracted.
• The premolars to be extracted should have prominent facial surfaces.
• Willing to have the four premolars slightly flattened and smoothed.
• Willing to have all four premolars extracted for orthodontic reasons.
• Between 12 and 35 years of age.
• Willing to attend four appointments.
• Willing to wear a custom-made whitening tray during the evening when they sleep.
• Willing to have their premolars bleached with In-Office and At-Home bleaching agents and one of their teeth that will be extracted treated with phosphoric acid.
• Willing to sign a consent form (parents must co-sign if they are under 18).
• Willing to discontinue active orthodontic treatment during whitening treatment.
• Willing to brush at least twice a day with fluoridated toothpaste provided during the study.

Exclusion criteria:

• Restorations or visible cavities in any tooth to be extracted.
• The presence of visible intraoral structural defects or pathology.
• Use of over-the-counter or professionally prescribed whitening agents in the past six months.
• Teeth with tetracycline staining.
• History of any medical illness that may interfere with the study or require special considerations.
• Pregnant or lactating women.
• Not willing to do the blood tests (biometrics hematic, prothrombin, and thromboplastin) prior to extractions (a legal requirement of the Oral Surgery Department of the UIC).

Treatment plan:

The study will be approved by Ultradent Products, Inc. and the Health Sciences Divisional Area Bioethics Committee, which is the equivalent of the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of UIC before any patients will be evaluated for eligibility to enter the study.

At the first appointment (selection appointment), the absence of evident cavities or restorations in the four premolars will be clinically verified with an intraoral mirror. Root formation will be confirmed with the panoramic radiograph from the patient's orthodontic chart. The treatment will be explained, and the patient will be allowed to ask questions and discuss any concerns. Subjects will be informed that the study will consist of 4 appointments. If the patient qualifies and agrees to be part of the study, they will be asked to sign an approved Consent Form. Parents or guardians will be asked to sign the consent form for patients under 18 years of age. Participants will be given a copy of the signed Consent Form. The requirements are that the four teeth that will be extracted for orthodontic reasons will be flattened and polished to produce a one-by-one millimeter surface on the facial or most prominent surface. This will be done with a 169L bur and fine and extra-fine sandpaper discs. Additionally, they must agree to use a whitening tray every night for 14 nights with Opalescence 10% CP with or without PF (potassium nitrate and fluoride) on an upper right premolar (UR) or on the upper left premolar (UL) (the tooth that has the best alignment). The contralateral lower right (LR) or lower left (LL) premolar will be treated with 40% hydrogen peroxide (HP) Opalescent Boost PF at the dental clinic for three 20-minute periods according to the manufacturer's instructions**. Thirty of the 40 subjects will treat their UR or UL premolar treated with Opalescence 10% CP with PF. The remaining 10 subjects will treat their UR or UL premolar with Opalescence 10% CP without PF.

A digital scan impression (Dentsply Sirona Scanner) of each subject's dentition will be taken and study models fabricated. On the UR or UL premolar of the model, a 0.5 mm thick resin veneer of unfilled Block-Out-Resin (Ultradent Products Inc.) will be placed. The veneer will be applied on the facial surface or, by exception, on the lingual surface (the most prominent) of the tooth at 1.0 mm mesial, distal, and incisal, and 1.5 mm from the gingival margin. The resin veneer will be light-cured for 15 seconds using a standard visible curing light unit. Bleaching trays will be fabricated from 0.035-inch plastic sheets (Sof-Tray; Ultradent Products Inc.) on each subject's digital model and appropriately trimmed in the UIC laboratory and/or in a private practice laboratory. The trays will be trimmed with microscissors, 0.5 mm from the gingival margin. If the patient has started the placement of braces and/or orthodontic bands, the trays will be modified with "windows" to accommodate the brackets, if necessary, and the second molars in the bleaching trays will be removed to allow a better adaptation (no movements or orthodontic treatments will be allowed in any of the four premolars to be extracted).

The second appointment will occur at least 24 hours after the first appointment. The subject will receive the maxillary whitening tray with a single reservoir for the UR or UL premolar, a tube of Opalescent 10% CP containing or not containing PF whitening gel, and a container for tray storage, when tray is not in use. During this appointment, the color of that premolar will be taken with VITA Bleachedguide 3-D MASTER shade guide (VITA, Zahnfabrik, Germany). The tray will be placed in the mouth to ensure a proper fit without interference. The subject will be instructed to place a small amount of whitening gel into the individual reservoir for the UR or UL premolar each evening, then carefully placing the tray over the teeth, and wipe off the excess gel. The subject will be instructed to wear the bleaching tray for at least 8 hours every night, for 14 nights, after brushing their teeth. Each morning after using the tray, the subject will be instructed to brush off the used gel, rinse the tray, store it in the container provided, and brush their teeth with the toothpaste provided. Subjects need to brush thoroughly twice a day, morning and night. During the 14 days of whitening at home, the subject will be contacted twice by phone or text message to make sure they are using the tray with the whitening gel, properly.

The third appointment will occur on day 15. The subject will return the maxillary whitening tray and will be encouraged to report any concerns with the bleaching treatment or tray usage. During this appointment, the LR or LL premolar and collateral to the premolar that was bleached at-home will be isolated with OpalDam (Ultradent Products, Inc.) and will be treated with Opalescent Boost 40% HP. The treatment will consist of application of the gel three separate times, each for will remain on the one premolar for 20 minutes, according to the manufacturer's instructions*. If the soft tissue or tooth becomes sensitive, a soothing gel will be applied to relieve discomfort (Opalescence UltraEZ). Tissue sensitivity usually lasts about thirty minutes and tooth sensitivity usually decreases in two or three days. This appointment will last approximately 90 minutes. During this appointment, an orthodontic separator band or elastic band of 2.5 to 4.5 oz / ⅛" to ¼" (depending on interproximal access) will be placed in the gingival area of each premolar to create bone resorption and facilitate an atraumatic extraction. The final color will be taken of the premolar that received 14 days of whitening at-home, as well as the initial and final color of the premolar that will be bleached in-office with VITA Bleachedguide 3-D Master (VITA Zahnfabrik); this is to corroborate and document that the teeth were successfully whitened. At this appointment, the subject will be reminded to complete the blood tests required by the UIC oral surgery department since, without these lab tests, the extractions cannot be performed. Therefore, the compensation would not be completed. Also, the subject will be reminded to continue documenting on the log the brushing of at least twice a day for at least one minute each time and will be asked to follow these instructions for the next 14 days.

The fourth and final appointment will take place on day 29, in other words,14 days after the third appointment and 14 days after they have already finished their whitening treatment at home and in the office. At this appointment, 6 subjects, three of the 30 subjects that used 10% CP with PF and three of the 10 subjects that used 10% CP without the PF, will have their mandibular second control tooth etched with 35% phosphoric acid (Ultradent Products, Inc.) for 15 seconds. These 6 subjects will be chosen to be treated before extractions with the etchant at a time convenient to the oral surgeon and Dr. Fugaro. Extractions will be performed during this appointment for all subjects. Four to five UIC maxillofacial surgeons will perform the extractions. Local anesthetics will be at the discretion of the oral surgeon and the patient's needs. Extractions will be performed with a simple elevator forceps technique as described in the attached protocol**. Immediately after extractions, the teeth will be cleaned to remove any debris with a dental curette without touching the treated area. The teeth will then be placed in a plastic snap top container (Fisher Scientific) with a wet sponge (sodium-free drinking water) and 0.12% chlorhexidine at the bottom of the bottle and snapped closed. Each vial will be labeled with the date of extraction, a subject identification number, the subject's initials, the tooth number, and how the tooth was treated (at home, in office, etched, or control) and forwarded for testing to Therametric Technologies, Inc.

Conditions

Dental Atraumatic Restorative Treatment

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: SUPPORTIVE_CARE
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Control

Teeth left untreated as control group.

Group Type: NO_INTERVENTION

No interventions assigned to this group

OP 10% CP

Teeth treated with 10% CP over a14 day span

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Carbamide Peroxide 10%

Intervention Type: DIAGNOSTIC_TEST

treatment over 14 days of 10% Carbamide Peroxide

OP 40% HP

Teeth treated with 40% Hydrogen Peroxide

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Hydrogen Peroxide

Intervention Type: DIAGNOSTIC_TEST

treatment of 40% Hydrogen Peroxide

Interventions

Carbamide Peroxide 10%

treatment over 14 days of 10% Carbamide Peroxide

Intervention Type: DIAGNOSTIC_TEST

Hydrogen Peroxide

treatment of 40% Hydrogen Peroxide

Intervention Type: DIAGNOSTIC_TEST

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Have the four premolars in different quadrants that their orthodontist recommends be extracted.
• The premolars to be extracted should have prominent facial surfaces.
• Willing to have the four premolars slightly flattened and smoothed.
• Willing to have all four premolars extracted for orthodontic reasons.
• Between 12 and 35 years of age.
• Willing to attend four appointments.
• Willing to wear a custom-made whitening tray during the evening when they sleep.
• Willing to have their premolars bleached with In-Office and At-Home bleaching agents and one of their teeth that will be extracted treated with phosphoric acid.
• Willing to sign a consent form (parents must co-sign if they are under 18).
• Willing to discontinue active orthodontic treatment during whitening treatment.
• Willing to brush at least twice a day with fluoridated toothpaste provided during the study.

Exclusion Criteria

• Restorations or visible cavities in any tooth to be extracted.
• The presence of visible intraoral structural defects or pathology.
• Use of over-the-counter or professionally prescribed whitening agents in the past six months.
• Teeth with tetracycline staining.
• History of any medical illness that may interfere with the study or require special considerations.
• Pregnant or lactating women.
• Not willing to do the blood tests (biometrics hematic, prothrombin, and thromboplastin) prior to extractions (a legal requirement of the Oral Surgery Department of the UIC).

• Minimum Eligible Age: 12 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 35 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Universidad Intercontinental

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Indiana University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Ultradent Products, Inc.

INDUSTRY

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Principal Investigators

Bruce A Matis, DDS, MSD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Indiana University

Locations

Universidad Intercontinental

Mexico City, Tialpan, Mexico

Countries

Mexico

Provided Documents

Document Type: Study Protocol

View Document

Document Type: Statistical Analysis Plan: statistical analysis plan

View Document

Document Type: Statistical Analysis Plan: Updated statistical analysis plan

View Document

Document Type: Informed Consent Form

View Document

Study Documents

Document Type: Statistical Analysis Plan

View Document

Document Type: Informed Consent Form

View Document

Related Links

https://indiana-my.sharepoint.com/:w:/g/personal/tmatis_iu_edu/EXk1Wua2GxBPo1gcO7KMZxUBEu5I3HUln-A2paATQIxsOg?e=Zdtd69

Study Protocol

Other Identifiers

1-2025 Enamel Hardness

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id