Reducing Recurrent Knee Flexion Contracture by Correcting Leg Length Discrepancy After Total Knee Arthroplasty for OA

NCT ID: NCT02861521

Last Updated: 2022-10-03

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 4 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2016-08-31
• Study Completion Date: 2021-03-31

Brief Summary

Moving one's joints through their full range of motion (ROM) is crucial for health and wellbeing. Those who are unable to do so have difficulty carrying out simple activities like walking or feeding themselves. Lost joint ROM is called a contracture. Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common form of arthritis. About a third of people with knee OA develop knee flexion contractures (KFlCs), the inability to fully straighten the knee. Having a KFlC before a knee replacement is a big risk factor for redeveloping one after the operation. Many people with a KFlC in the knee for surgery also have a KFlC in the other knee. The investigators believe that this non-surgical KFlC increases the risk of re-developing a KFlC in the surgical knee after surgery by encouraging bending of the surgical knee to avoid one leg being shorter than the other. No one has ever looked at whether fixing this leg length difference using a shoe lift would prevent this problem and there is little information to help design such a study. Here the investigators will see if testing shoe lift use for preventing KFlC is feasible. The investigators hypothesis is that a study evaluating the benefit of using a shoe lift to correct leg length difference in the non-surgical knee is feasible.

Detailed Description

Joint contractures are characterized by a restriction in the full passive range of motion (ROM) of a joint and are a major burden on public health. They restrict mobility, have a negative impact on quality of life, limit an individual's productivity and earning potential, and can prevent basic activities of daily living such as dressing and eating. The geriatric population is particularly vulnerable to contractures due to accumulated comorbidities leading to restricted joint movement and permanent loss of ROM.

A knee flexion contracture (KFlC) is a limitation in knee extension. Patients with KFlCs limp and are afflicted with a constant enhanced energy demand on the quadriceps muscle, putting them at higher risk for falls and injury. Walking is slow and abnormally tiring for those with KFlC such that patients may choose to walk less or not at all. Murphy et al. identified a significant increase in energy cost of walking with a KFlC of ≥15°. In addition, KFlCs cause a functional shortening in the affected limb resulting in a leg length discrepancy (LLD). LLDs contribute to even greater energy requirements for ambulation, worse pain due to premature joint wear, and are associated with knee osteoarthritis progression. One study identified shoe modification as a means of correcting this treatable risk factor. To the investigators' knowledge, no study has examined the effect of shoe modification on KFlC.

Contractures are associated with many conditions including arthritis. In the setting of osteoarthritis (OA), the most common arthritis and a world-leading cause of disability in the elderly, contractures are highly prevalent: over one third of 3,400 patients with OA presenting for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) had a KFlC. The burden of KFlC in OA is further compounded by the pre-operative contracture putting the patient at a higher risk for contracture, knee pain and poor outcome post-operatively. Loss of pre-operative ROM was found to be the best predictor of lost post-operative ROM.

During TKA, surgeons are often able to restore some or all knee ROM which transiently eliminates the contracture in the immediate post-operative period. Unfortunately, full ROM is lost over time in a notable proportion of patients. The overall incidence of KFlC following TKA has been reported to be between 1 to 5%. In patients with pre-operative KFlC, this has been reported as high as 15% with the resulting post-operative KFlCs still present at 3-year follow-up4. Patients who develop post-operative KFlC report less satisfaction, poorer function and more pain post-surgically. Post-operative loss of ROM has been described as one of the most common causes of readmission within the first 90 days after surgery and was identified as being the primary reason for nearly 20% of revision TKAs. These large percentages represent a significant number considering that 719,000 replacements were performed in the USA in 2010 and that the Ottawa hospital alone performs over 500 TKAs per year. KFlCs therefore contribute to increased health care costs.

Treatment of KFlC includes aggressive physiotherapy, therapeutic modalities, continuous passive ROM devices, bracing, manipulation under anesthesia, arthroscopy, open arthrolysis, or TKA revision surgery. Despite these numerous and costly options however, treatment is often unrewarding. Overall, contractures draw heavily on health care resources because of their chronic nature and poor response to treatment.

In a previous study, the investigators' group examined factors associated with KFlC in patients with end-stage OA going for TKA. By comparing those with contracture to those without, the investigators found that having a KFlC in the knee scheduled for TKA (the surgical knee) was associated with having a KFlC in the other (non-surgical) knee1. Once the surgical KFlC was corrected intra-operatively, these patients would suffer from a functionally shorter limb on the unoperated side. Given the disadvantages of walking on limbs of unequal length, patients may inadvertently flex the surgical knee when walking in order to equalize the limb lengths. By not accessing the full range of extension in the surgical knee, this could, over time, result in the re-development of a KFlC in the surgical knee. In this study the investigators propose to correct the LLD using a shoe lift for the unoperated knee with KFlC. The investigators believe this will reduce the likelihood of re-developing KFlC after TKA in the surgical knee. This simple, relatively inexpensive, intervention could reduce post-surgical morbidity, TKA revision rate and long-term costs to the healthcare system. Unfortunately, there is little data in the literature outlining the benefits of shoe lifts post-operatively.

Innovation: The investigators will use a simple inexpensive intervention (a shoe lift) to correct leg length shortening in the non-surgical limb in patients with OA and bilateral knee flexion contractures who have had a unilateral total knee replacement.

Objective: Determining the feasibility of studying the effects of shoe lift treatment on post-arthroplasty range of motion in the surgical knee in patients with bilateral pre-operative knee flexion contractures

Rationale: Post-operative KFlCs cause pain, and reduce function and patient satisfaction. They are a common cause of chronic disability and are costly and difficult to treat. Prevention of post-operative KFlC would therefore be beneficial to patients and the health care system. The investigators believe that providing a shoe lift to the non-surgical knee will reduce the incidence of developing post-operative KFlC in the surgical knee in patients with pre-operative KFlC. To the investigators knowledge, there is presently insufficient data in the literature upon which to design a study testing this hypothesis, either in terms of power analysis or outcome measures. By completing this Objective the investigators will accomplish 3 goals: (1) determine data variance for a power analysis for a future study, (2) determine if either of two validated pain and functional outcome measures are sensitive to differences in knee ROM, and (3) determine the number of subjects that the investigators are able to recruit within the timeframe of the study.

In this Objective, the investigators will recruit subjects and randomly allocate them to 1 of 2 groups, both having 1° knee OA with bilateral KFlCs who are scheduled for TKA:

Group 1: Leg length discrepancy (LLD) 2° to KFlC in the non-operated limb will be corrected using a shoe lift after TKA.

Group 2: "Sham" shoe modification that does not correct LLD in the non-surgical limb after TKA.

Hypothesis: It is feasible to design a larger randomized control trial to evaluate the pain and functional outcome benefits of using a shoe lift for the non-surgical knee post-operatively in patients with OA and bilateral pre-operative KFlCs. These benefits can be detected using a validated OA outcome tool.

During their post-operative inpatient stay, participants will have both their anatomic leg lengths measured (ASIS to medial malleolus) and will then be referred to be fitted with the appropriate shoe adjustment.

Conditions

Osteoarthritis; Contracture

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: PREVENTION
• Blinding Strategy: TRIPLE

Study Groups

Corrective shoe lift

Participants will be given an external shoe lift to correct post-operative leg length discrepancy (LLD).

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Shoe lift

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Subjects will be given a shoe lift post-knee replacement to correct leg length discrepancy

Sham shoe intervention

Participants will be given a sham shoe intervention that does not correct post-operative leg length discrepancy.

Group Type: SHAM_COMPARATOR

Sham

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Sham shoe modification

Interventions

Shoe lift

Subjects will be given a shoe lift post-knee replacement to correct leg length discrepancy

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Sham

Sham shoe modification

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Patients scheduled for unilateral TKA for 1° OA will be assessed for eligibility. Those meeting the American College of Rheumatology criteria for knee OA and having bilateral knee flexion contractures (KFlCs) will be recruited. KFlC will be defined as a loss of knee extension of 6 or more degrees.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Ottawa Hospital Research Institute

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Principal Investigators

T Mark Campbell, MD MSc FRCPC

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

University of Ottawa

Locations

The Ottawa Hospital

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Countries

Canada

Other Identifiers

M16-16-033

Identifier Type: OTHER_GRANT

Identifier Source: secondary_id

20160109-01H

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id