Effects of Stress on Team Coordination and Performance

NCT ID: NCT05798052

Last Updated: 2023-04-04

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: UNKNOWN
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 108 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2023-04-30
• Study Completion Date: 2024-04-30

Brief Summary

Healthcare teams often encounter challenging circumstances where they must deliver high-quality care. For a team to function effectively, its members must not only be individually competent, but they also need to collaborate and cooperate using their respective expertise. Such teams often work under high stress situations, where they need to make high stakes decisions under conditions of uncertainty, time-sensitivity and variable levels of control. Research shows that such emergency situations provoke stress responses in individuals, which can impair attention, memory, reasoning, and decision-making. However, it remains unclear how individual-level stress responses influence team communication, coordination, and performance. The aims of this study are to a) compare team coordination, communication, and performance in low stress versus high stress simulated emergency situations; and b) characterize the relationship between teams' stress profiles and the teams' performance and coordination. The study will be a within-subject experimental design, with teams serving as their own controls. Teams of emergency medicine residents and nurses will participate in two simulation scenarios: one in a low stress condition, and the other in a high stress condition (counterbalanced across the teams).

Detailed Description

Healthcare teams often encounter challenging circumstances where they must deliver high-quality care. For a team to function effectively, its members must not only be individually competent, but they also need to collaborate and cooperate using their respective expertise. Effective teamwork has been demonstrated to have a positive effect on patient outcomes and adherence to treatment guidelines. As a result, team training interventions have become increasingly prevalent in healthcare. These interventions predominantly focus on generic team competencies that can be transported across different situations and team compositions. A recent meta-analysis found that team training resulted in large effect sizes for the learning and transfer of cognitive and skills-based outcomes, but weaker effects on teamwork performance and medical errors. As such, there are calls to better understand the factors that affect teamwork. Teams often work under high stress situations, where they need to make high stakes decisions under conditions of uncertainty, time-sensitivity and variable levels of control. Research shows that such emergency situations provoke stress responses in individuals, which can impair attention, memory, reasoning, and decision-making. However, it remains unclear how individual-level stress responses influence team communication, coordination, and performance. The aims of this study are to a) compare team coordination, communication, and performance in low stress versus high stress simulated emergency situations; and b) characterize the relationship between teams' stress profiles and the teams' performance and coordination.

Methods: The study will be a randomized control trial, with teams serving as their own controls. Teams of emergency medicine residents and nurses will participate in two simulation scenarios: one in a low stress condition, and the other in a high stress condition (counterbalanced across the teams). Based on previous similar studies on the impact of stress on individual performance, where large effects sizes are seen (.7 -.75)8, the study will recruit a minimum of 17 teams (two-tailed test, alpha set at .05 and power set at .80). In both low and high stress scenario versions, the underlying mechanism of disease or injury will be identical, as will be the expected clinical management of the situation. Known stressors will be added to the scenarios, ensuring ecological validity (stressors that occur in real life). The stressors will include a) socio-evaluative stressors (presence of other with ability to negatively judge); b) increases in the severity of the situation (unstable patient); c) increases in the stakes (e.g. woman in early stages of pregnancy), d) noise, as well as e) unexpected brief complications (e.g. brief equipment challenge).

The participants' subjective (State-Trait Anxiety Inventory- STAI11, cognitive appraisal) and physiological stress (heart rate variability) responses will be measured. Stress responses will be compared at baseline, immediately before, and immediately after each scenario, as well as during for the physiological measures. The team performance will be assessed using the Team Emergency Assessment Measure (TEAM).

Conditions

Stress Reaction; Stress, Psychological; Stress, Physiological

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: CROSSOVER
• Primary Study Purpose: HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Low-High stress group

Complete the first simulated clinical scenario in the low stress condition, then complete the second simulated scenario in the high stress condition.

Group Type: OTHER

Psychological stressors added to simulated clinical scenarios.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

In both low and high stress scenario versions, the underlying mechanism of disease or injury will be identical, as will be the expected clinical management of the situation. Known stressors9,10 will be added to the scenarios, ensuring ecological validity (stressors that occur in real life). The stressors will include a) socio-evaluative stressors (presence of other with ability to negatively judge); b) increases in the severity of the situation (unstable patient); c) increases in the stakes (e.g. woman in early stages of pregnancy), d) noise, as well as e) unexpected brief complications (e.g. brief equipment challenge).

High-Low stress groups

Complete the first simulated clinical scenario in the high stress condition, then complete the second simulated scenario in the low stress condition.

Group Type: OTHER

Psychological stressors added to simulated clinical scenarios.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

In both low and high stress scenario versions, the underlying mechanism of disease or injury will be identical, as will be the expected clinical management of the situation. Known stressors9,10 will be added to the scenarios, ensuring ecological validity (stressors that occur in real life). The stressors will include a) socio-evaluative stressors (presence of other with ability to negatively judge); b) increases in the severity of the situation (unstable patient); c) increases in the stakes (e.g. woman in early stages of pregnancy), d) noise, as well as e) unexpected brief complications (e.g. brief equipment challenge).

Interventions

Psychological stressors added to simulated clinical scenarios.

In both low and high stress scenario versions, the underlying mechanism of disease or injury will be identical, as will be the expected clinical management of the situation. Known stressors9,10 will be added to the scenarios, ensuring ecological validity (stressors that occur in real life). The stressors will include a) socio-evaluative stressors (presence of other with ability to negatively judge); b) increases in the severity of the situation (unstable patient); c) increases in the stakes (e.g. woman in early stages of pregnancy), d) noise, as well as e) unexpected brief complications (e.g. brief equipment challenge).

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Teams of postgraduate residents enrolled at the University of Ottawa, and The Ottawa Hospital emergency medicine nurses scheduled to attend simulation education sessions organized within their department.

Exclusion Criteria

• none

• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

University of Ottawa

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Ottawa Hospital Research Institute

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Locations

University of Ottawa Skills and Simulation Centre

Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Countries

Canada

Other Identifiers

2020752-01H

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id