Improving Initial Management of the Injured at Ghanaian District and Regional Hospitals With a Trauma Intake Form
NCT ID: NCT04547192
Last Updated: 2024-01-02
Study Results
Results available
Outcome measurements, participant flow, baseline characteristics, and adverse events have been published for this study.
View full resultsBasic Information
Get a concise snapshot of the trial, including recruitment status, study phase, enrollment targets, and key timeline milestones.
Recruitment Status
COMPLETED
Clinical Phase
NA
Total Enrollment
4105 participants
Study Classification
INTERVENTIONAL
Study Start Date
2020-10-01
Study Completion Date
2022-04-30
Brief Summary
Review the sponsor-provided synopsis that highlights what the study is about and why it is being conducted.
Brief Summary: Improving care of the injured (trauma care) is a way to the large burden of injury in low- and middle-income countries. The important initial period of trauma care is often chaotic and prone to errors. The World Health Organization created a Trauma Care Checklist (TCC), which improved key performance indicators of care at tertiary hospitals but encountered factors which decreased its uptake. The investigators propose the use of a model Trauma Intake Form (TIF) with potential to achieve the benefits of the TCC, but with automatic usage and with accompanying improvements in documentation for key elements of care. It is especially oriented for smaller hospitals. The investigators propose a pragmatic randomized clinical trial with introduction of the TIF at 8 hospitals sequentially, with start times randomized by stepped-wedge design. Specifically, the investigators aim to determine the effectiveness the TIF to function as a checklist for increasing the appropriate use of key performance indicators during care of the injured in emergency units of non-tertiary hospitals in Ghana, as assessed by independent observers; to determine the percent of injured patients with adequate data on initial assessment before vs. after introduction of the TIF in emergency units of non-tertiary hospitals in Ghana; and to increase the capacity of the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology and the network of non-tertiary hospitals in southern Ghana to undertake high-quality trauma care research, including clinical trials.
Related Clinical Trials
Explore similar clinical trials based on study characteristics and research focus.
Pre and Post-Implementation of Injury/Trauma First Aid Training Among Early Secondary School Students in Fako, Cameroon
NCT07110077
Trauma/Injury Problem
COMPLETED
NA
Teaching First Aid and Trauma Management to School Students
NCT05563129
Trauma-related Wound
Head Injury
Choking
+3 more
COMPLETED
NA
The Flipped Classroom Method in Basic Life Support Training
NCT06243081
Education
NOT_YET_RECRUITING
NA
The Impact of First Aid Blended Learning Training on Learning Outcomes and Helping Behaviour of Adult Laypeople in Rwanda
NCT06003504
Emergencies
Injuries
Illness Physical
COMPLETED
NA
Feasibility and Effectiveness Study of a Compassionate Mind Training Program for Teachers
NCT05107323
Teachers
COMPLETED
NA
Detailed Description
Dive into the extended narrative that explains the scientific background, objectives, and procedures in greater depth.
Background: Injuries constitute an important public health problem in Ghana and other low- and middle-income countries (LMIC). The large burden of injury can be reduced by strengthening the process of care (1). The period of initial assessment and care of the injured has been identified as having the potential for significant errors (2, 3). Quality improvement efforts can reduce these errors (4, 5).
A systematic approach to the initial assessment and care of the injured ensures early detection of life-threatening conditions, prompting timely performance of necessary interventions (6, 7). The WHO Trauma Care Checklist (TCC), specifically developed for the early assessment and care of injured patients, led to improvements in key performance indicators of care as well as a decrease in mortality (1). Despite the usefulness of checklists in surgical practice, many countries report low usage rates (8-11). One unique barrier with the TCC is its application at the end of the initial trauma assessment, by which time some members of the trauma team may have left (12). Other approaches that would trigger more automatic use of the checklist might achieve the objectives of the TCC while improving compliance to its use. The Trauma Intake Form (TIF) to be tested in this study has been designed to achieve this goal.
An additional functionality of the TIF is improving data recording for both better immediate clinical care and better ability to conduct quality improvement programs. Data elements needed for this purpose were created through a Delphi process to develop a set of key performance indicators that were deemed to be accurate proxies of quality trauma care, simple to measure and feasible to collect at non-tertiary hospitals of LMICs (13). The TIF was created as a means of operationalizing key performance indicators by building them into the clinical chart of injured patients undergoing initial care in emergency units.
The extent to which a systematic approach is employed in the initial assessment of injured patients arriving at emergency units of district and regional hospitals in Ghana is unknown. With successful training of emergency health service providers in the use of the TIF and its subsequent adoption, improvements in systematic assessment and care of the injured in these hospitals can be achieved.
Specific aim 1. To determine the effectiveness of the TIF to function as a checklist for increasing the appropriate use of key performance indicators during care of the injured in emergency units in district and regional hospitals in Ghana, as assessed by independent observers.
Hypothesis: The TIF will increase the appropriate use of key performance indicators by significant and clinically meaningful levels. For example, we expect the TIF to increase the percent of all injured patients whose blood pressure is checked at arrival by a minimum of 8%, and increase the percent of those with heart rate checked by a minimum of 8%. For seriously injured patients, we expect the TIF to improve the achievement of additional key performance indicators by clinically meaningful levels. For example, we expect the TIF to increase the percent of patients with chest examination by a minimum of 8%, increase the percent of patients with hemoperitoneum ruled out by a minimum of 12%, and improve the percent of patients with examination of all distal pulses by a minimum of 13%.
Specific aim 2. To determine the percent of injured patients with adequate data on initial assessment before vs. after introduction of the TIF in emergency units in district and regional hospitals in Ghana.
Hypothesis. The TIF will increase documentation of important clinical data on injured patients (including all of the following: time of injury, mechanism of injury, respiratory rate at presentation, heart rate at presentation, blood pressure at presentation, consciousness level at presentation, temperature at presentation, and time of disposition) by at least 5%.
Specific aim 3. To increase the capacity of the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology and the network of district and regional hospitals in to undertake high-quality trauma care research, including clinical trials.
Methods A pragmatic randomized clinical trial will be carried out at 8 district and regional hospitals in Ghana. The intervention to be tested is the TIF to be used in recording information about injured patients during their initial assessment and care and which is designed to decrease omission of critical steps in care and so to improve care and also record keeping.
The unit of randomization will be hospitals and a stepped-wedge design will be used to select which hospitals will start use of the TIF at what time. We have select eight hospitals across four regions in Ghana to represent district or regional hospitals with more than adequate flow of injured patients (≥75 patients per month)
The effectiveness of the TIF will be assessed at the 8 study hospitals by measuring the use of key performance indicators during initial care of the injured before vs. after introduction of the TIF. Data on the key performance indicators will be obtained from observations by research assistants (RAs) of care provided by Emergency Health Service Providers (EHSPs) and by data from medical records. The investigators will obtain written consent from the EHSPs whose actions will be observed.
The investigators will then station RAs in the emergency units of recruited hospitals to observe EHSP practices regarding initial care of the injured using an observation form (derived from the TIF) as the investigators observe EHSPs assess and manage each participant arriving during the 8-hour shift of the RAs. The RAs will fill the form without interaction with EHSPs or the participant. For any components of the assessment and management that RAs are unable to directly observe, RAs will obtain information from the participants records to complete the observation form before the participant leaves the emergency unit.
After introduction of the TIF, RAs will complete the observation form for each participant as before. Prior to the participant leaving the emergency unit, RAs will make a blinded copy of the TIF completed by the EHSP in assessing and managing the participant. RAs will complete the observation form with information from participants records and/or from the EHSP-filled TIF. Both before and after introduction of the TIF, RAs will review the medical records of all participants observed for additional safety-related data, including occurrence of complications or death. These details will also be obtained from medical records at time of discharge for all participants who are admitted to the hospital.
The investigators will employ a stepped-wedge design in sequentially introducing the TIF to the 8 selected hospitals considered as 4 groups of 2 hospitals each. First, following 14 weeks of initial observation of EHSP practices at all 8 selected hospitals, the investigators will conduct a training workshop for EHSPs of the first randomly-selected group of hospitals on use of the TIF. Following the workshop, the EHSPs will be encouraged to begin use of the TIF at their hospitals. After another 14 weeks, the investigators will conduct the two-day training workshop for the next group of randomly selected hospitals, after which use of the TIF will begin at those hospitals. The investigators will continue this sequential conduct of training workshops followed by use of TIF every 14 weeks until all 8 hospitals have been exhausted. The RAs will continue to observe EHSP practices for a further 14 weeks during which the TIF will be in use at all 8 hospitals. The total duration of observation of EHSP practices will be 70 weeks. At the end of year one, the investigators will organize a one-day workshop for leadership of participating hospitals to review study progress.
A systematic approach to the initial assessment and care of the injured ensures early detection of life-threatening conditions, prompting timely performance of necessary interventions (6, 7). The WHO Trauma Care Checklist (TCC), specifically developed for the early assessment and care of injured patients, led to improvements in key performance indicators of care as well as a decrease in mortality (1). Despite the usefulness of checklists in surgical practice, many countries report low usage rates (8-11). One unique barrier with the TCC is its application at the end of the initial trauma assessment, by which time some members of the trauma team may have left (12). Other approaches that would trigger more automatic use of the checklist might achieve the objectives of the TCC while improving compliance to its use. The Trauma Intake Form (TIF) to be tested in this study has been designed to achieve this goal.
An additional functionality of the TIF is improving data recording for both better immediate clinical care and better ability to conduct quality improvement programs. Data elements needed for this purpose were created through a Delphi process to develop a set of key performance indicators that were deemed to be accurate proxies of quality trauma care, simple to measure and feasible to collect at non-tertiary hospitals of LMICs (13). The TIF was created as a means of operationalizing key performance indicators by building them into the clinical chart of injured patients undergoing initial care in emergency units.
The extent to which a systematic approach is employed in the initial assessment of injured patients arriving at emergency units of district and regional hospitals in Ghana is unknown. With successful training of emergency health service providers in the use of the TIF and its subsequent adoption, improvements in systematic assessment and care of the injured in these hospitals can be achieved.
Specific aim 1. To determine the effectiveness of the TIF to function as a checklist for increasing the appropriate use of key performance indicators during care of the injured in emergency units in district and regional hospitals in Ghana, as assessed by independent observers.
Hypothesis: The TIF will increase the appropriate use of key performance indicators by significant and clinically meaningful levels. For example, we expect the TIF to increase the percent of all injured patients whose blood pressure is checked at arrival by a minimum of 8%, and increase the percent of those with heart rate checked by a minimum of 8%. For seriously injured patients, we expect the TIF to improve the achievement of additional key performance indicators by clinically meaningful levels. For example, we expect the TIF to increase the percent of patients with chest examination by a minimum of 8%, increase the percent of patients with hemoperitoneum ruled out by a minimum of 12%, and improve the percent of patients with examination of all distal pulses by a minimum of 13%.
Specific aim 2. To determine the percent of injured patients with adequate data on initial assessment before vs. after introduction of the TIF in emergency units in district and regional hospitals in Ghana.
Hypothesis. The TIF will increase documentation of important clinical data on injured patients (including all of the following: time of injury, mechanism of injury, respiratory rate at presentation, heart rate at presentation, blood pressure at presentation, consciousness level at presentation, temperature at presentation, and time of disposition) by at least 5%.
Specific aim 3. To increase the capacity of the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology and the network of district and regional hospitals in to undertake high-quality trauma care research, including clinical trials.
Methods A pragmatic randomized clinical trial will be carried out at 8 district and regional hospitals in Ghana. The intervention to be tested is the TIF to be used in recording information about injured patients during their initial assessment and care and which is designed to decrease omission of critical steps in care and so to improve care and also record keeping.
The unit of randomization will be hospitals and a stepped-wedge design will be used to select which hospitals will start use of the TIF at what time. We have select eight hospitals across four regions in Ghana to represent district or regional hospitals with more than adequate flow of injured patients (≥75 patients per month)
The effectiveness of the TIF will be assessed at the 8 study hospitals by measuring the use of key performance indicators during initial care of the injured before vs. after introduction of the TIF. Data on the key performance indicators will be obtained from observations by research assistants (RAs) of care provided by Emergency Health Service Providers (EHSPs) and by data from medical records. The investigators will obtain written consent from the EHSPs whose actions will be observed.
The investigators will then station RAs in the emergency units of recruited hospitals to observe EHSP practices regarding initial care of the injured using an observation form (derived from the TIF) as the investigators observe EHSPs assess and manage each participant arriving during the 8-hour shift of the RAs. The RAs will fill the form without interaction with EHSPs or the participant. For any components of the assessment and management that RAs are unable to directly observe, RAs will obtain information from the participants records to complete the observation form before the participant leaves the emergency unit.
After introduction of the TIF, RAs will complete the observation form for each participant as before. Prior to the participant leaving the emergency unit, RAs will make a blinded copy of the TIF completed by the EHSP in assessing and managing the participant. RAs will complete the observation form with information from participants records and/or from the EHSP-filled TIF. Both before and after introduction of the TIF, RAs will review the medical records of all participants observed for additional safety-related data, including occurrence of complications or death. These details will also be obtained from medical records at time of discharge for all participants who are admitted to the hospital.
The investigators will employ a stepped-wedge design in sequentially introducing the TIF to the 8 selected hospitals considered as 4 groups of 2 hospitals each. First, following 14 weeks of initial observation of EHSP practices at all 8 selected hospitals, the investigators will conduct a training workshop for EHSPs of the first randomly-selected group of hospitals on use of the TIF. Following the workshop, the EHSPs will be encouraged to begin use of the TIF at their hospitals. After another 14 weeks, the investigators will conduct the two-day training workshop for the next group of randomly selected hospitals, after which use of the TIF will begin at those hospitals. The investigators will continue this sequential conduct of training workshops followed by use of TIF every 14 weeks until all 8 hospitals have been exhausted. The RAs will continue to observe EHSP practices for a further 14 weeks during which the TIF will be in use at all 8 hospitals. The total duration of observation of EHSP practices will be 70 weeks. At the end of year one, the investigators will organize a one-day workshop for leadership of participating hospitals to review study progress.
Conditions
See the medical conditions and disease areas that this research is targeting or investigating.
Behavior Problem
Study Design
Understand how the trial is structured, including allocation methods, masking strategies, primary purpose, and other design elements.
Allocation Method
RANDOMIZED
Intervention Model
SEQUENTIAL
Pragmatic randomized clinical trial with introduction of the TIF at 8 hospitals sequentially, with start times randomized by stepped-wedge design.
Primary Study Purpose
HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
Blinding Strategy
NONE
Study Groups
Review each arm or cohort in the study, along with the interventions and objectives associated with them.
Pre TIF introduction
Emergency Health Service prior to introduction of TIF.
Group Type
NO_INTERVENTION
No interventions assigned to this group
Post introduction of TIF
Emergency Health Service after introduction of TIF.
Group Type
EXPERIMENTAL
Improving initial care of the injured
Intervention Type
OTHER
Improvement in Care Processes
Interventions
Learn about the drugs, procedures, or behavioral strategies being tested and how they are applied within this trial.
Improving initial care of the injured
Improvement in Care Processes
Intervention Type
OTHER
Eligibility Criteria
Check the participation requirements, including inclusion and exclusion rules, age limits, and whether healthy volunteers are accepted.
Inclusion Criteria
* Emergency health care providers at the study hospitals
* Patient with injury who is treated in the emergency unit of one of the study hospitals
* Patient with injury who is treated in the emergency unit of one of the study hospitals
Exclusion Criteria
* Non-emergency health care providers at the study hospitals
* Non-injured patient at the study hospitals
* Non-injured patient at the study hospitals
Eligible Sex
ALL
Accepts Healthy Volunteers
No
Sponsors
Meet the organizations funding or collaborating on the study and learn about their roles.
Fogarty International Center of the National Institute of Health
NIH
Sponsor Role
collaborator
Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology
OTHER
Sponsor Role
lead
Responsible Party
Identify the individual or organization who holds primary responsibility for the study information submitted to regulators.
Responsibility Role
SPONSOR
Principal Investigators
Learn about the lead researchers overseeing the trial and their institutional affiliations.
Peter Donkor
Role: STUDY_DIRECTOR
Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology
Locations
Explore where the study is taking place and check the recruitment status at each participating site.
Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology
Kumasi, , Ghana
Site Status
Countries
Review the countries where the study has at least one active or historical site.
Ghana
References
Explore related publications, articles, or registry entries linked to this study.
Gyedu A, Issaka A, Donkor P, Mock C. Utilization of a Trauma Quality Improvement Tool in a Clinical Trial: Effects When Tool Not Used. World J Surg. 2025 Jul;49(7):1960-1968. doi: 10.1002/wjs.12633. Epub 2025 May 19.
Reference Type
DERIVED
Gyedu A, Amponsah-Manu F, Mensah S, Donkor P, Mock C. An evaluation of the Hawthorne effect in a clinical trial of trauma care in Ghana. World J Surg. 2024 Dec;48(12):3020-3026. doi: 10.1002/wjs.12410. Epub 2024 Nov 8.
Reference Type
DERIVED
Gyedu A, Amponsah-Manu F, Awuku K, Ameyaw E, Korankye KK, Donkor P, Mock C. Differences in trauma care between district and regional hospitals and impact of a trauma intake form with decision support prompts in Ghana: A stepped-wedge cluster randomized trial. World J Surg. 2024 Mar;48(3):527-539. doi: 10.1002/wjs.12082. Epub 2024 Feb 5.
Reference Type
DERIVED
Gyedu A, Stewart BT, Nakua E, Donkor P. Standardized trauma intake form with clinical decision support prompts improves care and reduces mortality for seriously injured patients in non-tertiary hospitals in Ghana: stepped-wedge cluster randomized trial. Br J Surg. 2023 Oct 10;110(11):1473-1481. doi: 10.1093/bjs/znad253.
Reference Type
DERIVED
Provided Documents
Download supplemental materials such as informed consent forms, study protocols, or participant manuals.
Document Type: Study Protocol and Statistical Analysis Plan
Other Identifiers
More Related Trials
Additional clinical trials that may be relevant based on similarity analysis.
Transfusion Camp for Medical Students in Rwanda
NCT06259734
ACTIVE_NOT_RECRUITING
NA
Effectiveness of Road Traffic Crashes First-aid Education Among Commercial Motorcyclists in Kigali-City, Rwanda
NCT04932239
COMPLETED
NA
GBV, Primary Trauma & Trauma Resilience & Understanding Self-help Therapy Utilization in Uganda
NCT06073964
COMPLETED
NA
Effect of an Educational Intervention on CPR Knowledge and Skills in Schoolchildren
NCT06929715
NOT_YET_RECRUITING
NA
School Activity for the Reduction of Distress, Pain and Negative Emotions in Children Experiencing Hospital School
NCT04046692
COMPLETED
Impact of School Based Intervention on Psychosocial Factors Associated With Trauma Among Adolescents
NCT05631691
UNKNOWN
NA
Gamified Flipped Class Room and Nursing Students' Skills Competency and Confidence
NCT04859192
COMPLETED
NA
Enhancing Social Communication and Emotional Development in Under 5 Children
NCT04541069
UNKNOWN
NA
Improving Care and Preventing Maltreatment of Orphans
NCT03594617
COMPLETED
NA
An Educational Intervention Based on the Teach Back Method on Self-care Practice Among Menopausal Women
NCT03313739
COMPLETED
NA
Trauma and Truth Interventions (NET) Versus Conflict Resolution and Social Skills Trainings for Vulnerable Youths in Northern Uganda
NCT00893750
COMPLETED
NA
Occupational Therapy Trauma Informed Workshops and Consultations for Teachers at Head Start
NCT05261451
COMPLETED
NA
Assessing the Effects of Educational Training Aimed to Improve Pain-reporting Reliability in Children After Surgery
NCT04306679
COMPLETED
NA
The Effect of Therapeutic Communication Program on the Psychological State of Children
NCT06275711
COMPLETED
NA
Knowledge, Personal Views and Experiences of a Group of Dental Interns Toward Physical Child Abuse
NCT03566420
UNKNOWN
The Effect of Clear Masks in Improving Patient Relationships
NCT04595695
COMPLETED
NA
The Effect of Emotion Recognition and Empathy Focused Education Program Applied to Earthquake Survivors on Anxiety, Rumination and Post-traumatic Growth Levels of Children
NCT05815966
UNKNOWN
NA
Experiences Reported by Siblings of Children Hospitalized in the PICU
NCT06664333
RECRUITING
Legal-Education Plus Trauma-informed Therapy to Improve Community Acceptance and Reintegration of Repentant Terrorists in Nigeria
NCT05397483
UNKNOWN
NA
Preventing Violence Against Children in Schools Study
NCT03745573
UNKNOWN
NA
Virtual Reality Situation-Based Flipped Learning
NCT06223425
RECRUITING
NA
The Effect of Cognitive Rehabilitation on Cognitive Skills, Academic Performance And Quality of Life in Refugee Children
NCT05093738
UNKNOWN
NA
Education Using WhatsApp and Face-to-Face Meetings on IYCF for the Nutritional Status of Infants
NCT05502978
COMPLETED
NA
Unleashing Unpredictability: The Batman Project and Its Impact on Prosocial Behavior and Awareness
NCT06481748
NOT_YET_RECRUITING
Nurse-Led ROOTS-Soft Skills Intervention for Bullying Prevention
NCT07261397
COMPLETED
NA