C-FLASH (Cigarillo Flavor and Abuse Liability, Attention, and Substitution in youtH)
NCT ID: NCT04358705
Last Updated: 2024-03-06
Study Results
The study team has not published outcome measurements, participant flow, or safety data for this trial yet. Check back later for updates.
Basic Information
Get a concise snapshot of the trial, including recruitment status, study phase, enrollment targets, and key timeline milestones.
COMPLETED
NA
658 participants
INTERVENTIONAL
2020-05-29
2023-02-10
Brief Summary
Review the sponsor-provided synopsis that highlights what the study is about and why it is being conducted.
Related Clinical Trials
Explore similar clinical trials based on study characteristics and research focus.
Little Cigar and Cigarillo Warnings to Reduce Tobacco-Related Cancers and Disease - Eye Tracking
NCT06546618
Attitudes and Smoking Perceptions in the Real Environment
NCT06617520
Effects of Cigar Flavors on Measures of Abuse Liability Among Young Adults
NCT02937051
Attitudes and Perceptions Attitudes and Smoking Perceptions in the Real Environment -II
NCT06668350
The Impact of Cigarillo Warnings on Purchasing
NCT05434013
Detailed Description
Dive into the extended narrative that explains the scientific background, objectives, and procedures in greater depth.
Supplemental Aim 1: Consists of evaluation of the differences in perceptions of flavors on appeal, purchasing and risk perceptions of cigarillo products between young adult sexual and gender minorities (SGM) and heterosexual females. A convenience sample of SGM females will be recruited using online social media platforms with targeted advertising. From the parent survey (or Aim 1), an existing sample of female heterosexual cigarillo users will be leveraged. Both samples will receive the same survey, Aim 1, to compare perceptions of appeal, risk, and purchasing across cigarillos and other tobacco products.
Aim 1 of this study is exploratory and will consist of an online survey. Findings from Aim 1 will inform the questions asked about advertising and product use in Aim 2 and 3. Both Aim 2 and 3 are randomized sections. Participants in Aim 2 are either tobacco users or non-users. Participants will be asked to view a series of tobacco related images. The sequence of those images is randomized. In Aim 3, participants will be randomized in terms of the options they are presented within the Experimental Tobacco Marketplace (ETM) (i.e. which tobacco items they can purchase and at what price).
Supplemental Aim 3 consists of evaluating the differences in the abuse liability/addictive potential of flavored versus unflavored cigarillos and the substitutability of flavored versus unflavored disposable e-cigarettes between young adult sexual and gender minorities (SGM) and heterosexual females. SGM female cigarillousers will be recruited from participants of the Supplemental Aim 1 sample and be compared to heterosexual female participants of the parent study (or Aim 3). Both samples will receive the same questions and be exposed to the same ETM conditions tocompare perceptions of appeal of flavors and substitutability between cigarillos, e-cigarettes, and other tobacco products.
Conditions
See the medical conditions and disease areas that this research is targeting or investigating.
Study Design
Understand how the trial is structured, including allocation methods, masking strategies, primary purpose, and other design elements.
NON_RANDOMIZED
PARALLEL
PREVENTION
NONE
Study Groups
Review each arm or cohort in the study, along with the interventions and objectives associated with them.
Young Cigarillo User (YCU) Sample
Aim 1: Online survey. 392 participants from the full YCU sample
Supplemental Aim 1: A sample of 196 heterosexual females from the Aim 1 survey will be compared to the SGM females
Aim 2: 150 participants from Columbus, Ohio, and surrounding areas will be recruited for an Eye Tracking Activity to capture visual attention to cigarillo packaging. Visual attention will be examined in 3 conditions: 1) flavored product images, 2) unflavored product images, and 3) a mixture of flavored and unflavored product images.
Aim 3: (162 participants from Aim 1 survey). Consists of the Online Electronic Tobacco Marketplace (ETM) and the aim 3 survey components:
* Demographic screener questions
* Tobacco product withdrawal scale
* ETM
* Quality Assurance Question
* Tobacco product withdrawal scale
* Survey (nicotine dependence \& flavor preferences)
A sample of 88 from the 162 Aim 3 participants will be compared with 88 SGM participants from supplemental Aim 1.
Aim 1: Online survey
This survey will evaluate perceptions of flavors on appeal, purchasing and risk perceptions of cigarillo products among young adult and adolescent cigarillo users. This survey will be used to inform survey design for further aims.
As a proxy for biological verification of tobacco use status, data on brand, frequency, and pricing will be collected to confirm user status
Participants will rate the role of flavor and report perceptions of product appeal, health risk, advertising exposure and use intentions. Participants will also complete purchase and substitution tasks.
Eye Tracking Activity
The eye tracking activity consists of a single in-person eye tracking activity that will take place in a private office in Columbus, Ohio where the participant will be seated in a chair within a typical viewing distance from a computer monitor equipped with an infrared camera on the monitor to capture precise eye movements. Participants will have their gaze monitored continuously by the camera on the computer monitor while a randomized set of stimuli (e.g., tobacco product images) are viewed (n=30) for 10 seconds per image. Following each image, an on-screen closed response question will re-center the participant's gaze for standardization prior to the next image.
Eye tracking survey
Other Names: Participants will complete a survey using Qualtrics immediately after the eye tracking activity and one week following completion of the activity via email to measure recall of brand name, product flavors, perceptions of cigarillo harm, and tobacco use behaviors and intentions.
Online Experimental Marketplace (ETM)
Administered online via Qualtrics
Participants are given an account balance for use during their assigned ETM based on their average weekly tobacco use calculated from previous interview. Participants will view all four price conditions and all four flavor conditions in random order for a total of 16 rounds
Cigarillo price conditions: 1) market price 2) ½ market price 3) 2X market price 4) 4X market price
Flavor condition: 1) flavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored disposable-cigarettes available 2) unflavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored ecigarettes available 3) flavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available 4) unflavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available.
Participants will purchase cigarillos with their account balance. During all ETM conditions, constant-priced alternative tobacco products (smokeless tobacco, nicotine lozenges, nicotine gum, and the nicotine patch) will be available in addition to the cigarillos and e-cigarettes.
Aim 3 survey
Consists of:
* A screener and demographic data collection.
* A tobacco product withdrawal scale
* Upon completion of the ETM, participants will be asked to respond to a quality assurance question regarding the conditions that varied. Participants will be shown a list of 8 possible conditions and must chose one of the three that varied in order to be eligible to receive compensation.
* The tobacco product withdrawal scale again
* Measurements of nicotine dependence and flavor preferences
Supplemental Aim 1 Interviews
Participants from the preceding online survey (who identify as women from Aim 1/supplemental aim 1 survey) who agreed to be contacted for future study will be emailed an invitation to the eligibility screener. Individuals interested will complete a screener to ensure participants identify as women and to verify that they have ever used cigarillos. Eligible participants will be contacted to schedule a 60- to 90-minute Zoom interview about their tobacco, nicotine, and cannabis product use experiences, with particular focus on flavored cigarillo usage initiation, current use, and responses to potential flavor restrictions.
Sexual and Gender Minority (SGM) Female Cigarillo Users
Supplemental Aim 1: An online convenience sample of 196 SGM females will complete the Aim 1 online survey and will be compared to sample of 196 heterosexual females from the YCU sample
Supplemental Aim 3: (88 SGM females who participated in the Supplemental Aim 1 survey). Consists of the ETM and the aim 3 survey components in the following order:
* Demographic screener questions
* Tobacco product withdrawal scale
* ETM
* Quality Assurance Question
* Tobacco product withdrawal scale
* Survey (nicotine dependence \& flavor preferences)
Aim 1: Online survey
This survey will evaluate perceptions of flavors on appeal, purchasing and risk perceptions of cigarillo products among young adult and adolescent cigarillo users. This survey will be used to inform survey design for further aims.
As a proxy for biological verification of tobacco use status, data on brand, frequency, and pricing will be collected to confirm user status
Participants will rate the role of flavor and report perceptions of product appeal, health risk, advertising exposure and use intentions. Participants will also complete purchase and substitution tasks.
Eye Tracking Activity
The eye tracking activity consists of a single in-person eye tracking activity that will take place in a private office in Columbus, Ohio where the participant will be seated in a chair within a typical viewing distance from a computer monitor equipped with an infrared camera on the monitor to capture precise eye movements. Participants will have their gaze monitored continuously by the camera on the computer monitor while a randomized set of stimuli (e.g., tobacco product images) are viewed (n=30) for 10 seconds per image. Following each image, an on-screen closed response question will re-center the participant's gaze for standardization prior to the next image.
Eye tracking survey
Other Names: Participants will complete a survey using Qualtrics immediately after the eye tracking activity and one week following completion of the activity via email to measure recall of brand name, product flavors, perceptions of cigarillo harm, and tobacco use behaviors and intentions.
Online Experimental Marketplace (ETM)
Administered online via Qualtrics
Participants are given an account balance for use during their assigned ETM based on their average weekly tobacco use calculated from previous interview. Participants will view all four price conditions and all four flavor conditions in random order for a total of 16 rounds
Cigarillo price conditions: 1) market price 2) ½ market price 3) 2X market price 4) 4X market price
Flavor condition: 1) flavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored disposable-cigarettes available 2) unflavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored ecigarettes available 3) flavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available 4) unflavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available.
Participants will purchase cigarillos with their account balance. During all ETM conditions, constant-priced alternative tobacco products (smokeless tobacco, nicotine lozenges, nicotine gum, and the nicotine patch) will be available in addition to the cigarillos and e-cigarettes.
Aim 3 survey
Consists of:
* A screener and demographic data collection.
* A tobacco product withdrawal scale
* Upon completion of the ETM, participants will be asked to respond to a quality assurance question regarding the conditions that varied. Participants will be shown a list of 8 possible conditions and must chose one of the three that varied in order to be eligible to receive compensation.
* The tobacco product withdrawal scale again
* Measurements of nicotine dependence and flavor preferences
Cognitive interview
Separate population of participants (n=29) who were a mix of cigarillo users, dual e-cigarette and cigarillo users, e-cigarette users, and non-users. The cognitive interviews informed the Aim 1 survey
Cognitive Interviews
Cognitive Interviews will be done in-person, using Zoom, or over the phone. Interviews will be video or audio recorded. . The participant will be given a select section of the survey questions from Aim 1. The survey will be uploaded to Qualtrics to reflect the way that survey would be conducted in Aim 1. With the survey questions in front of the participant on the computer screen, research personnel will ask probing questions about each one of the survey questions. If the participant is not able to participate in person or via Zoom, they will be allowed to be interview over the phone with access to the Qualtrics survey or a paper form. If the participant is unable to access the internet, the participant will be read the questions by research personnel. The participant will provide feedback about the questions and walk the research personnel through their thought process for approaching each survey question.
Interventions
Learn about the drugs, procedures, or behavioral strategies being tested and how they are applied within this trial.
Aim 1: Online survey
This survey will evaluate perceptions of flavors on appeal, purchasing and risk perceptions of cigarillo products among young adult and adolescent cigarillo users. This survey will be used to inform survey design for further aims.
As a proxy for biological verification of tobacco use status, data on brand, frequency, and pricing will be collected to confirm user status
Participants will rate the role of flavor and report perceptions of product appeal, health risk, advertising exposure and use intentions. Participants will also complete purchase and substitution tasks.
Eye Tracking Activity
The eye tracking activity consists of a single in-person eye tracking activity that will take place in a private office in Columbus, Ohio where the participant will be seated in a chair within a typical viewing distance from a computer monitor equipped with an infrared camera on the monitor to capture precise eye movements. Participants will have their gaze monitored continuously by the camera on the computer monitor while a randomized set of stimuli (e.g., tobacco product images) are viewed (n=30) for 10 seconds per image. Following each image, an on-screen closed response question will re-center the participant's gaze for standardization prior to the next image.
Eye tracking survey
Other Names: Participants will complete a survey using Qualtrics immediately after the eye tracking activity and one week following completion of the activity via email to measure recall of brand name, product flavors, perceptions of cigarillo harm, and tobacco use behaviors and intentions.
Online Experimental Marketplace (ETM)
Administered online via Qualtrics
Participants are given an account balance for use during their assigned ETM based on their average weekly tobacco use calculated from previous interview. Participants will view all four price conditions and all four flavor conditions in random order for a total of 16 rounds
Cigarillo price conditions: 1) market price 2) ½ market price 3) 2X market price 4) 4X market price
Flavor condition: 1) flavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored disposable-cigarettes available 2) unflavored cigarillos and fruit-flavored ecigarettes available 3) flavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available 4) unflavored cigarillos and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes available.
Participants will purchase cigarillos with their account balance. During all ETM conditions, constant-priced alternative tobacco products (smokeless tobacco, nicotine lozenges, nicotine gum, and the nicotine patch) will be available in addition to the cigarillos and e-cigarettes.
Aim 3 survey
Consists of:
* A screener and demographic data collection.
* A tobacco product withdrawal scale
* Upon completion of the ETM, participants will be asked to respond to a quality assurance question regarding the conditions that varied. Participants will be shown a list of 8 possible conditions and must chose one of the three that varied in order to be eligible to receive compensation.
* The tobacco product withdrawal scale again
* Measurements of nicotine dependence and flavor preferences
Cognitive Interviews
Cognitive Interviews will be done in-person, using Zoom, or over the phone. Interviews will be video or audio recorded. . The participant will be given a select section of the survey questions from Aim 1. The survey will be uploaded to Qualtrics to reflect the way that survey would be conducted in Aim 1. With the survey questions in front of the participant on the computer screen, research personnel will ask probing questions about each one of the survey questions. If the participant is not able to participate in person or via Zoom, they will be allowed to be interview over the phone with access to the Qualtrics survey or a paper form. If the participant is unable to access the internet, the participant will be read the questions by research personnel. The participant will provide feedback about the questions and walk the research personnel through their thought process for approaching each survey question.
Supplemental Aim 1 Interviews
Participants from the preceding online survey (who identify as women from Aim 1/supplemental aim 1 survey) who agreed to be contacted for future study will be emailed an invitation to the eligibility screener. Individuals interested will complete a screener to ensure participants identify as women and to verify that they have ever used cigarillos. Eligible participants will be contacted to schedule a 60- to 90-minute Zoom interview about their tobacco, nicotine, and cannabis product use experiences, with particular focus on flavored cigarillo usage initiation, current use, and responses to potential flavor restrictions.
Eligibility Criteria
Check the participation requirements, including inclusion and exclusion rules, age limits, and whether healthy volunteers are accepted.
Inclusion Criteria
* Individuals who have smoked an average of 2 cigarillos per week over the past month.
* Individuals willing to provide informed consent and participate in the online survey.
* Age range: 21-28 years
* Individuals who have smoked an average of 2 cigarillos per week over the past month.
* Individuals willing to provide informed consent and participate in the online survey.
* Individuals who identify as female, trans-female/woman, or non-binary
* Individuals who identify as not heterosexual
* Previous participant in Supplemental Aim 1 or Aim 1 survey.
* Participant agreed to be contacted to participate in future studies.
* Individuals who have ever used a cigarillo.
* Individuals willing to provide informed consent and participate in the interview.
* Individuals who identify as women (cis- or transwomen)
* Age range: 21-28 years
* Sample 1: Individuals who have smoked an average of 2 cigarillos per week over the past month and did not smoke an average of 2 e-cigarettes per week over the past month
* Sample 2: Individuals who have smoked an average of 2 e-cigarettes per week over the past month and did not smoke an average of 2 cigarillos per week over the past month
* Sample 3: Individuals who have smoked an average of 2 cigarillos AND 2 e-cigarettes per week over the past month
* Sample 4: Individuals who have never smoked tobacco or used nicotine products
* Individuals willing to provide informed consent and participate in a qualitative interview.
Aim 2:
* Age range: 16-28 years
* Individuals not having chronic eye diseases known to interfere with eye tracking equipment (i.e. glaucoma, regression lenses, cataracts, etc.)
* Individuals willing to meet in-person at lab in Columbus, Ohio to complete study procedures.
* Individuals willing to provide informed consent or assent and participate in the online survey.
* Age range: 21-28 years
* Individuals who smoked 2 cigarillos per week over the past month.
* Age range: 21-28 years
* Individuals who smoked 2 cigarillos a week over the past month
* Individuals who identify as female, trans-female/woman, or non-binary
* Individuals who identify as lesbian, bisexual, pansexual, or queer
Exclusion Criteria
Supplemental Aim 1:
* Individuals who currently do not smoke at least 2 cigarillos per week
* Individuals who identify as male or trans-man
* Individuals who identify as heterosexual
Supplemental Aim 1 Interviews:
* Individuals who have never used a cigarillo.
* Individuals who do not identify as women (cis- or transwomen)
* Individuals unwilling to provide informed consent and participate in the interview
Cognitive Interviews:
\- Pregnant females
Aim 3:
* Individuals who currently do not smoke at least 2 cigarillos per week
* Females who are pregnant or lactating
Supplemental Aim 3:
* Individuals who currently do not smoke at least 2 cigarillos per week
* Individuals who identify as male or transman
* Individuals who identify as heterosexual
16 Years
28 Years
ALL
No
Sponsors
Meet the organizations funding or collaborating on the study and learn about their roles.
Case Comprehensive Cancer Center
OTHER
Responsible Party
Identify the individual or organization who holds primary responsibility for the study information submitted to regulators.
Principal Investigators
Learn about the lead researchers overseeing the trial and their institutional affiliations.
Erika Trapl, PhD
Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR
Case Western Reserve University, Case Comprehensive Cancer Center
Locations
Explore where the study is taking place and check the recruitment status at each participating site.
Case Western Reserve University, Case Comprehensive Cancer Center
Cleveland, Ohio, United States
Countries
Review the countries where the study has at least one active or historical site.
Other Identifiers
Review additional registry numbers or institutional identifiers associated with this trial.
CASE13Z19
Identifier Type: -
Identifier Source: org_study_id
More Related Trials
Additional clinical trials that may be relevant based on similarity analysis.