Compensation Mechanisms in Parkinson's Disease

NCT ID: NCT02869945

Last Updated: 2022-02-18

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 50 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2016-09-30
• Study Completion Date: 2021-07-01

Brief Summary

Parkinson's disease onset is clinically defined as the appearance of motor symptoms including akinesia, tremor and hypertonia. Several studies have shown that motor symptoms occur when at least 50 % of dopaminergic neurons are lost. However, there are evidence suggesting that the level of dopaminergic denervation is not homogenous at the time of diagnosis.

Some patients have a higher level of dopaminergic loss at disease onset indicating the existence of compensation mechanisms. The aim of this study is to decipher how the metabolism of dopamine is involved in this compensation with a focus on the polymorphism of the COMT gene. This gene is expressed according to two variant: (i) COMT H that encodes a form of the enzyme with a high level of activity and (ii) COMT L that encode a form of the enzyme with a low level of activity. Thus, there are 3 possible genotypes in the population: (i) COMT HH associated with an increased degradation of dopamine, (ii) COMT LL associated with a decreased degradation of dopamine and (iii) COMT HH (intermediary between COMT HH and COMT LL).

The hypothesis is that this polymorphism of the COMT gene may participate to compensation mechanisms in early PD. Patients with COMT HH genotype may have an earlier motor symptoms onset than patients with COMT LL genotype.

To test this hypothesis, we will recruit 51 patients with de novo PD will be recruited (17 patients for each genotype). Given the distribution of COMT polymorphism in the population, a maximum sample of 76 patients will be screened to recruit 17 patients for each genotype.

Clinical evaluation will include MDS-UPDRS, Non Motor Symptoms Scale, segmental symptoms scale, Montreal Cognitive assessment, MMSE, Frontal assessment battery and Parkinson's disease behavioral assessment scale (ECMP). All the patients will have a monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane in order to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation and an MRI scan with resting state study. Cerebrospinal fluid sampling will be optional and will allow direct measurements of dopamine metabolites.

The main outcome measure will be the level of dopaminergic denervation on I-123-Ioflupane scans according to COMT genotype, age, gender and severity of motor symptoms on the MDS-UPDRS part 3.

If this hypothesis is confirmed, this will allow to test the efficacy of COMT inhibitors in order to delay dopaminergic drugs initiation for PD patients.

Detailed Description

Parkinson's disease onset is clinically defined as the appearance of motor symptoms including akinesia, tremor and hypertonia. Several studies have shown that motor symptoms occur when at least 50 % of dopaminergic neurons are lost. However, there are evidence suggesting that the level of dopaminergic denervation is not homogenous at the time of diagnosis. Some patients have a higher level of dopaminergic loss at disease onset indicating the existence of compensation mechanisms.

The aim of this study is to decipher how the metabolism of dopamine is involved in this compensation with a focus on the polymorphism of the COMT gene. This gene is expressed according to two variants: (i) COMT H that encodes a form of the enzyme with a high level of aactivity and (ii) COMT L that encode a form of the enzyme with a low level of activity. Thus, there are 3 possible genotypes in the population: (i) COMT HH associated with an increased degradation of dopamine, (ii) COMT LL associated with a decreased degradation of dopamine and (iii) COMT HH (intermediary between COMT HH and COMT LL).

The hypothesis is that this polymorphism of the COMT gene may participate to compensation mechanisms in early PD. Patients with COMT HH genotype may have an earlier motor symptoms onset than patients with COMT LL genotype.

To test this hypothesis, 51 patients with de novo PD will be included (17 patients for each genotype). Given the distribution of COMT polymorphism in the population, a maximum sample of 76 patients will be screened for inclusion of 17 patients for each genotype.

Only untreated patients will be included in the study in order to have a reliable assessment of motor severity without interference of dopaminergic drugs.

The study will be scheduled as follow:

• At the first visit (V1), inclusion criteria will be checked and patients will sign the informed consent. COMT genotype of selected patients will be analyzed.
• Result of COMT genotype will be obtained within 4 weeks. Only the 17 first patients with each genotype will continue the study
• For these patients, an evaluation visit with clinical assessment including MDS-UPDRS, Non Motor Symptoms Scale, segmental symptoms scale, Montreal Cognitive assessment, MMSE, Frontal assessment battery and Parkinson's disease behavioral assessment scale (ECMP) will be performed..

All the patients will have a monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane in order to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation. An MRI scan with resting state study will also be performed to assess the compensation mechanisms at the networks level. Cerebrospinal fluid sampling will be optional and will allow direct measurements of dopamine metabolites.

The main outcome measure will be the level of dopaminergic denervation on I-123-Ioflupane scans according to COMT genotype with and without adjustment for age, gender and severity of motor symptoms on the MDS-UPDRS part 3.

Secondary outcome measures will include:

• level of dopaminergic denervation compared across the 3 genotypes (COMT HH, COMT HL and COMT HH) with and without adjustment for age, gender and motor scores
• determination of functional compensation at the networks scale assessed on fMRI resting state scan according to dopaminergic denervation
• determination of CSF dopamine metabolite profile at the time of diagnosis (CSF sampling will be optional).

If this hypothesis is confirmed, this will allow to test the efficacy of COMT inhibitors in order to delay dopaminergic drugs initiation for PD patients.

Conditions

Parkinson Disease

Study Design

• Allocation Method: NON_RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: BASIC_SCIENCE
• Blinding Strategy: TRIPLE

Study Groups

COMT HH

COMT HH gene

Group Type: OTHER

Identification of COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes

Intervention Type: GENETIC

COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes identification

Brain MRI with resting state scan

Intervention Type: OTHER

MRI scan with resting state study to be performed to assess the compensation mechanisms at the networks level.

Brain MPET

Intervention Type: OTHER

Monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation.

COMT HL

COMT HL gene

Group Type: OTHER

Identification of COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes

Intervention Type: GENETIC

COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes identification

Brain MRI with resting state scan

Intervention Type: OTHER

MRI scan with resting state study to be performed to assess the compensation mechanisms at the networks level.

Brain MPET

Intervention Type: OTHER

Monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation.

COMT LL

COMT LL gene

Group Type: OTHER

Identification of COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes

Intervention Type: GENETIC

COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes identification

Brain MRI with resting state scan

Intervention Type: OTHER

MRI scan with resting state study to be performed to assess the compensation mechanisms at the networks level.

Brain MPET

Intervention Type: OTHER

Monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation.

Interventions

Identification of COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes

COMT HH, COMT HL or COMT LL genes identification

Intervention Type: GENETIC

Brain MRI with resting state scan

MRI scan with resting state study to be performed to assess the compensation mechanisms at the networks level.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Brain MPET

Monophotonic emission tomography with I-123-Ioflupane to assess the level of dopaminergic denervation.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Man or woman ≥ 18 years old,
• Caucasian origin
• Parkinson's disease considered to be probable as defined by the criteria of UK Parkinson's disease Brain Bank (Hugues and coll 2002)
• Absence of anti-parkinsonian medication
• Patient affilied to a social security system
• Signed information consent form

Exclusion Criteria

• Parkinsonian syndrome secondary to neuroleptics
• Atypical parkinsonian syndrome such a multisystem atrophy, progressive supranuclear paralysis, dementia with levy bodies.
• MRI contraindication (claustrophobia, not compatible mechanical heart valve MRI, pacemaker, cochlear implant, other body ferromagnetic objects, pregnancy) - MPET contraindication (pregnancy, feeding, hypersensitivity to ioflupane [123]
• Patient under guardianship or trusteeship
• Any other significant pathology that could prevent patient participation and achievement of planned examinations (except for lumbar puncture)
• Patient participating or having participated in other biomedical research involving a drug in the three months prior to inclusion
• Hypersensitivity to local anesthetics with amide link or to any of the excipients

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Assistance Publique - Hôpitaux de Paris

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Principal Investigators

David Grabli, MD-PhD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Assistance Publique - Hôpitaux de Paris

Locations

Groupe Hospitalier Pitié-Salpêtrière

Paris, , France

Countries

France

Other Identifiers

P130939

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id