Are We Providing Timely Access to Musculoskeletal Outpatient Therapy Services? an Exploratory Study

NCT ID: NCT06829875

Last Updated: 2025-02-17

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: RECRUITING
• Total Enrollment: 135 participants
• Study Classification: OBSERVATIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2025-02-04
• Study Completion Date: 2025-09-30

Brief Summary

Waiting times for NHS services are of growing public interest. This is because accessing some services is getting more difficult, and we know that longer waits can result in negative impacts for those waiting.

People in Wales waiting for care for their musculoskeletal problems are deemed to be cared for in good time if they get an appointment in less than 14 weeks. This target has been set by Welsh Government, for everyone who waits, no matter what condition they are waiting with and how that condition is affecting them.

We know that impact of wait for people with MSK problems can vary, from complete recovery, to worsening of their pain and function. The impact experienced seems to be influenced by factors such as their age and their mental health statusz\. This suggests that setting one target for all may not be the right thing to do. However, we don't yet know whether waiting over 14 weeks has a big effect on impact. We also don't know about the lived experience of those waiting, while they wait, despite knowing that learning this is vital to informing change.

We plan to study the impact of waiting for these services by asking those waiting to complete a survey that measures the impact of their msk problem, at the start and end of their wait, and then understanding how the scores correlate with length of time waited. We will also ask some of these people to document their experience as they wait. We hope that this will provide an understanding of how effective the current target is at measuring access to these services, and whether we need to think differently. People will be able to complete this work in their own home.

Detailed Description

Access to NHS and social care services has been of increasing public interest for many years. Increasing waits to services has been long documented, and the COVID-19 pandemic saw waiting times soar to an all time high. This is not favourable because of the known negative impacts experienced by the waiter, when waiting longer for the services they need. Improving access to services is not only a National Driver featured throughout policy (A Healthier Wales, 2018) but a legal obligation (Duty of Quality, 2023). Access to services in Wales has been studied by Welsh Government for decades. This is usually measured by the time taken in weeks from referral to treatment, and is supported to be necessary in some areas, whereby increased waiting time can result in morbidity, or mortality, for example, heart attacks and strokes.

Literature exploring impact with wait is lacking when considering many areas of health, for example musculoskeletal conditions. However, such services are also duty bound to report their waiting times to Welsh Government.

Outpatient MSk Therapy Services, for example, report how long each person waits before an initial appointment is offered, in number of weeks. An appointment offered within 14 weeks of referral is considered 'timely' and people waiting over this time are considered to be 'breaching'. How this target became to be considered significant is not publicly justified. The impact of those waiting over 14 weeks on the person waiting, is not known.

Impact exploring those waiting for treatment for musuculoskeletal disorders is extremely limited. However, preliminary, retrospective study during COVID-19 suggests that those waiting for these services during this time, experienced a diversity of impact, from symptom recovery to deterioration of condition. The variables observed differed between individuals, as opposing to differing lengths of wait, and seemed to be influenced by personal factors such as socioeconomic and mental health status. This provides an insight that impact of wait is variable between individuals and does not align with current study of accessibility subjecting all people to the same arbitrary target without knowing what happens around this time. We know that future health and social care services need to be sustainable for the NHS to survive. We know that we need to look at things differently, considering the quality of the care that is provided rather than the quantity, and we are duty bound to explore how the NHS is doing with respect to quality, using both qualitative and quantitative information, involving all stakeholders. We know that this is vital to inform positive system change. However, there is no current exploration into the experience of waiting for MSk services, in the eyes of the waiter, as they wait.

Understanding this may help us to understand what a future model of MSk Outpatient healthcare should look like with respect to accessibility, and implement a sustainable solution for future generations. This is assuming that our current understanding of wait is inadequate, or not appropriate, based on the information available communicating accessibility through use of an arbitrary, unjustified blanket target for all, which remains an unknown.

This research project aims to understand the impact of chronological wait for people waiting for Musculoskeletal Therapy Outpatient Services, with reference given to under and over 14 weeks, to understand if the current target is effective at communicating how we are doing in this domain. It will also explore the lived experience of waiting in the eyes of the waiter, and seeks to understand whether this understanding aligns with what we see when studying impact of wait chronologically, with a view to provide a quality rich understanding of the impact of waiting for these services, and provide a direction of travel for future study.

Conditions

Musculoskeletal

Study Design

• Observational Model Type: COHORT
• Study Time Perspective: PROSPECTIVE

Study Groups

service users entering waiting lists for outpatient musculoskeletal physiotherapy, podiatry and OY

wait for outpatient appointment

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

this is an observational study measuring impact of pain and function at start and end of wait for those waiting for care from outpatient physiotherapy occupations therapy and podiatry

Interventions

wait for outpatient appointment

this is an observational study measuring impact of pain and function at start and end of wait for those waiting for care from outpatient physiotherapy occupations therapy and podiatry

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• aged 18 years or over
• have entered a waiting list for outpatient podiatry, occupational therapy or physiotherapy with a musculoskeletal complaint
• able to provide informed consent
• be able to read and write english

Exclusion Criteria

• are considered a vulnerable adult
• exhibit additional communication needs, to include but not limited to, language barrier

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Cardiff University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Cardiff and Vale University Health Board

OTHER_GOV

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Principal Investigators

Sara P James, MSc

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Cardiff and Vale University Health Board

Locations

Cardiff and Vale University Healthboard

Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom

Site Status: RECRUITING

Countries

United Kingdom

Central Contacts

Sara P James, MSc

Role: CONTACT

sara.james6@wales.nhs.uk

07494885624

Rachel Norman

Role: CONTACT

rachel.norman2@wales.nhs.uk

Facility Contacts

Sara P James, MSc

Role: primary

sara.james6@wales.nhs.uk

07494885624

Other Identifiers

8851

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id