Effects of a N95 Respirator vs Cloth Mask on Exercise Capacity During Treadmill Exercise.

NCT ID: NCT04415879

Last Updated: 2025-07-11

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 20 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2020-06-01
• Study Completion Date: 2020-08-01

Brief Summary

This study intends to find out how a cloth mask may impact exercise capacity, to provide guidance for exercisers to adjust their expectations and training accordingly. The investigators plan to asses exercise capacity through estimated peak oxygen consumption (eVO2peak), oxygen saturation and level of perceived exertion during treadmill based exercise while wearing a cloth mask compared to exercising without a cloth mask. The potential significance of this study is to determine if subjects can exercise safely and if their exercise training needs to be adjusted while following the current recommendations of wearing a cloth mask in public. The degree of airflow limitation experienced will depend on the type and fit of the mask being worn, and inadequeate airflow could possibly result in CO2 re-breathing if all air was not fully discharged from the mask with each breath. This re-breathing of CO2 could potentially limit the workload leading to a detriment in performance, and increase in adverse symptoms such as dizziness, lightheadedness, chest pain or shortness of breath that does not improve with rest.

Detailed Description

If healthcare providers are going to recommend that individuals exercise with cloth masks, it is imperative that future research is conducted to evaluate the degree to which airflow can be limited during exercise by wearing a cloth mask. At the completion of the study, the investigators will have further understanding of the effects of face masks during treadmill based running. To the investigators knowledge this is the first study to assess the effects of wearing protective cloth mask on exercise capacity.

Hypothesis The null hypothesis HO states that exercising with a cloth mask will be inferior to the current standard of exercising without a facemask, limiting peak exercise when non-inferiority margin is 1 estimated metabolic equivalent ( eMET 3.5 mlO2*kg-1*min-1).

The alternative hypothesis H1 states that exercising with a mask will not be inferior to the current standard of exercising without a facemask, limiting peak exercise when non-inferiority margin is 1 eMET.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN & METHODS Subject Recruitment: The investigators will recruit 20 subjects though the Cleveland Clinic. Inclusion Criteria: Healthy subjects age > 18, Exclusion Criteria: Any long-term disease that would interfere with their ability to exercise safely, fever >100.4 F, or pregnancy. Informed consent will be obtained by the CoPI, and need for medical clearance determined based on ACSM's 2015 preparticipation guidelines. To remain compliant with enterprise guidelines we will not be recruiting healthy subjects outside of the Cleveland Clinic staff at this time to avoid increase COVID-19 exposure risk. However, if the enterprise changes the guidelines we will expand our enrollment to include non Cleveland Clinic employees. Employees will not be solicited by direct initiation. Recruitment will involve only posted notice or general advertising that does not pressure employees into participating for fear of job loss, delayed promotion, or other influences from their superior.

Study Design: The study design is a prospective crossover non-inferiority trial where subjects will complete 3 separate graded exercise treadmill tests each time wearing either No Mask, N-95 Mask (3M), or Cloth Mask (Boco). The order of the mask worn will be randomly assign to minimize familiarization or training effect. All testing will be performed in a Cleveland Clinic facility following standardized COVID-19 screening precautions. The investigators will compare the data collected from each test to asses for differences between subject comfort, peak exercise capacity (eMET), heart rate response during exercise and recovery.

Testing: After completing the informed consent and being medically cleared, subjects will then perform a symptom limited graded exercise treadmill test using a modified Balke protocol with continuous 12-lead EKG monitoring. Exercise tests will be stopped if any significant cardiac arrhythmias occur or significant ST segment depressions develops. The test will be terminated if ST elevation (> 1.0 mm), marked ST displacement (horizontal or downsloping of > 2mm, measured 60 to 80 ms after the J point), moderate to severe angina, Signs of poor perfusion (cyanosis or pallor), Sustained ventricular tachycardia or other arrhythmia, including second or third decree AV block, that interferes with normal maintenance of cardiac output during exercise, or development of bunle-branch block that cnannot be distinguished from bentricular tachycardia. The modified Balke, which is a well-accepted treadmill protocol that keeps the speed constant and increases workload by grade. Subjects will rest for 3 minutes and resting heart rate, blood pressure, subjective perceptions of the face mask will be measured. Subjects then will walk at 0% grade at 3 miles per hour for 2 minutes. Elevation will be increased by 2% after the initial 2 minutes and by 1% each minute thereafter until the test is terminated. Heart rate, RPEand oxygen saturation will be measured with a pulse oximeter at baseline, last 5-10 seconds of each stage and the investigators will continue to monitor heart rate during recovery at 1, 3 and 5 minutes post exercise. The investigators will monitor each stage for perceived exertion, feelings of light headedness, anxiety, and discomfort. The test will also be terminated at the request of the subject or if any chest pain develops. The scale of measuring subjective perceptions instrument will be adminstereted after collecting 5 minutes of resting, end of the exercise test, and at 5 minutes post recovery. The graded exercise test will be performed once with No Mask, once with a 3M 8200 N-95 Respirator, and once with a Cloth Mask (Boco). Subjects will be randomized by a random number generater (1= No Mask, 2= N-95, 3= Cloth Mask) to determine the order the perform each exercise test No Mask, N-95 or Cloth Mask and will complete the other tests 2 atleast 1 day apart. Subjects will be instructed to abstain from exercise for 2 days before the test.

Mask:

3M 8200 N-95 Respirator obtain from a third party provider. N-95 Respirators have been purchased outside the Cleveland Clinic supply chain. Cloth Face Mask manufactured by Boco is a custom designed two-layer face masks are built with a tightly woven polyester outer shell fabric and a soft, breathable performance knit mesh inner linig. Includes a slit pocket where a filter can be added.

Conditions

COVID-19

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: CROSSOVER
• Primary Study Purpose: HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

No Mask

Individuals will perform a Modified Balke Treadmill test with no mask and their estimated VO2 peak will be calculated based off of peak workload.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

N-95 Respirator

Intervention Type: OTHER

N-95 mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Cloth Face Mask

Intervention Type: OTHER

A cloth mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

N-95 Respirator

Individuals will perform a Modified Balke Treadmill test while wearing a N-95 Respirator and their estimated VO2 peak will be calculated based off of peak workload.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

N-95 Respirator

Intervention Type: OTHER

N-95 mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Cloth Face Mask

Intervention Type: OTHER

A cloth mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Cloth Mask

Individuals will perform a Modified Balke Treadmill test while wearing a cloth mask and their estimated VO2 peak will be calculated based off of peak workload.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

N-95 Respirator

Intervention Type: OTHER

N-95 mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Cloth Face Mask

Intervention Type: OTHER

A cloth mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Interventions

N-95 Respirator

N-95 mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Intervention Type: OTHER

Cloth Face Mask

A cloth mask will be worn as personal protective equipment during a graded exercise test

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Age 18 years or older
• Cleveland Clinic Employee
• Must not be pregnant

Exclusion Criteria

• Medical condition that would interfere with ability to exercise safely

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

The Cleveland Clinic

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Debasis Sahoo

Staff Physician

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Locations

Cleveland Clinic

Cleveland, Ohio, United States

Countries

United States

Other Identifiers

20-538

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id