Knee Split Comparison After ACL Reconstruction

NCT ID: NCT04360928

Last Updated: 2025-01-09

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: TERMINATED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 21 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2023-08-01
• Study Completion Date: 2025-01-06

Brief Summary

This study will evaluate the efficacy of the Graymont X ERIS Knee Splint brace in the postoperative period of ACL reconstruction to improve range of motion, specifically the achievement of terminal extension and time-to-achievement compared to the standard hinged knee brace. This will be directly measured with goniometric angle and heel-height measurements relative to the contralateral side. Other metrics will include standard, validated patient reported outcomes and requirements for additional interventions to treat extension deficits including, but not limited to, additional therapy, intraarticular injections, oral corticosteroids, manipulation under anesthesia, or arthroscopic arthrolysis.

Detailed Description

This study will be a prospective randomized controlled trial of patients undergoing arthroscopic reconstruction of full thickness ACL tears with bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft. All patients who sign the consent form will be enrolled in the study and randomized to one of the two treatment arms.

Subjects will be appropriately fitted for the brace corresponding to randomization on the day of surgery. All braces will be placed on the subject in the operating room at the conclusion of the procedure. All patient will begin a standardized physical therapy protocol on postoperative day 1-14.

Follow-up will take place at standard of care office visits at 1-week, 2-week, 6-weeks, 12-weeks, and 6-months. Range of motion, including goniometric angle and heel-height measurements, will be recorded at all postoperative time points. Time-to-achievement of full symmetric extension relative to the non-surgical knee will be monitored and recorded. At 3, 6, and 12 months, patients will also be asked to complete standardized, patient-reported outcomes questionnaires including IKDC, KOOS, PROMIS, VAS pain, VR/SF 12, and brief resilience scale. Patients will also be asked to answer questions regarding return to work and return to sport throughout the 1-year postoperative period.

Both treatment groups will progress according to standardized, postoperative rehabilitation programs, similar to the program outlined below.

Phase I: Protection, Range of Motion (ROM), and Proprioception

Goal:

• To protect the surgical graft, restore lower extremity mobility, and proprioception

Precautions:

• Patient can initiate immediate weight bearing with knee immobilizer brace locked at 0º extension.
• Patients may unlock or remove brace once they are able to perform a straight leg raise without any quadriceps lag and perform a single leg stance (SLS) on surgical limb for at least 30 seconds. Patients must also wear the brace with any weight bearing activity for six weeks.

Criteria for progression to next phase:

• Non-antalgic gait with no observable gait impairments
• ROM: Goal of extension to at least 0º, and flexion within 10º of contralateral knee.
• Perform single leg stance on surgical limb on dynamic surfaces (balance board, foam, etc.)

Exercises to be included:

ROM:

• Flexion: heel slides, wall slides, prone hamstring curls
• Extension: supine or prone hangs, hamstring and calf stretching

NWB strengthening:

• Quadriceps sets (prone and supine), leg raises, and bridges on a swiss ball

Proprioception:

• SLS from static to dynamic surfaces and movements, 3-way lunges, balance board, rebounder or therapist ball tossing

Phase II: Strength and Endurance

Goal:

• Build single limb endurance and to prepare for agility training

Precautions:

• No running/jogging or jumping.

Criteria for progression to next phase:

• Full, pain free knee AROM within 3º of contralateral knee
• Able to perform single leg squat to approximately 60º knee flexion for 2 minutes without joint pain or compensations
• No compensatory gait patterns during faster ambulation speeds

Exercises to be included:

ROM:

• Stretching as needed (calf, hamstring, quad, trunk, upper body)

NWB:

• Trunk/core dynamics

Proprioception:

• Single leg stance with trunk rotations (use resistance for progression), floor touches, cone pick-ups on stable and unstable surfaces

Phase III: Power and Agility

Goal:

• Gain type II, fast twitch muscle fibers and prepare for return to sport training

Precautions:

• Not to be initiated until at least 12 weeks post-operatively
• No uncontrolled jumping (i.e. on grass, when not supervised by medical staff)
• No cutting or pivoting at full speeds

Criteria for progression to next phase:

• Perform single leg squat to approximately 60º knee flexion for 3 minutes against external resistance
• Perform lateral and diagonal jumping of a distance equal to the patient's leg length or greater for 2 minutes or longer
• Perform double leg jumps from at least. a 12-inch surface
• Perform single leg static jumps from flat surface

Exercises to be included:

Leg press, lunge, hamstring curl

Agility:

• Ladder training, cone drills, lateral and diagonal jumping adding external resistance

Phase IV: Return to Sport Training

Precautions:

• No physical contact during sport specific training
• No live sport performance until cleared by functional sports assessment and surgeon

Patients will undergo standard of care physical therapy 2-3 times per week for 20 weeks as directed by their physician. Physical therapy will begin as directed by physician generally before post op day 14.

Conditions

ACL Tear; Arthrofibrosis; ACL Injury

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Graymont X ERIS Knee Splint Degree Splinting Group

These patients will be randomized to receive the Graymont X ERIS Knee Splint. Patients will follow the same standardized postoperative rehabilitation protocol.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Graymont X ERIS Knee Splint

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Specific type of splint which utilizes an inflatable air pocket on the posterior aspect of the leg to provide a combination of bracing and splinting in full extension in the immediate postoperative period.

Standard Hinged Knee Brace

These patients will be randomized to receive a standard hinged knee brace. Patients will follow the same standardized postoperative rehabilitation protocol.

Group Type: SHAM_COMPARATOR

Standard Hinge Knee Brace

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Standard knee brace used postoperatively after ACL reconstruction.

Interventions

Graymont X ERIS Knee Splint

Specific type of splint which utilizes an inflatable air pocket on the posterior aspect of the leg to provide a combination of bracing and splinting in full extension in the immediate postoperative period.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Standard Hinge Knee Brace

Standard knee brace used postoperatively after ACL reconstruction.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Primary ACL Reconstruction
• No associated repair or reconstruction procedures (meniscal repair, other ligamentous pathology). Patients undergoing concurrent partial meniscectomy would be eligible for inclusion.
• Clinical and radiographic examination (MRI), performed as standard of care prior to study enrollment, consistent with an acute full thickness ACL tear and surgical consent for ACL reconstruction with a patellar tendon autograft
• Written and informed consent for study participation

Exclusion Criteria

• Patients younger than 18 or older than 40 years of age
• Revision surgery or prior history of knee surgery
• Concomitant ligamentous, meniscal, or cartilage injury that would alter postoperative weight bearing status or rehabilitation protocol
• Inability to comply with the proposed follow-up clinic visits
• Patients lacking decisional capacity
• Pregnant or breast-feeding women
• Worker's compensation patients
• Any clinically significant finding that would place the patient at health risk, impact the study, or affect the completion of the study
• Any psychiatric illness that would prevent comprehension of the details and nature of the study and interfere with follow-up clinic visits

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 40 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Rush University Medical Center

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Locations

Rush University Medical Center

Chicago, Illinois, United States

Countries

United States

Other Identifiers

20030401

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id