Mirrored Movement Compared to Cross-education

NCT ID: NCT03937232

Last Updated: 2019-05-03

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: UNKNOWN
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 80 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2019-09-01
• Study Completion Date: 2020-12-31

Brief Summary

Recovery after a hand or wrist injury often includes wearing a cast, or limiting daily activities to help with healing, but this may lead to deconditioning. Previous research suggests resistance training with the healthy arm during this period could help improve recovery of the injured arm: this is called cross-education. Mirror visual feedback (e.g. watching the movement of an uninjured hand in front of a mirror hiding the injured hand to create the illusion both hands are moving) is another cross-body method which can improve recovery after stroke, and prevent or reduce pain in complex regional pain syndrome. Both of these treatments may work because they activate a specific area in the brain: using them together might strengthen the effects. However, this has never been studied after injury. The investigators are proposing a pilot study to see if it is possible and helpful to use these treatments in combination to improve recovery of grip strength and reduction of pain and disability. The investigators will use this information as a foundation to tell us how to run the best study to test these ideas in ways to be confident in the results.

Detailed Description

When someone has an injury to the hand or wrist, often the person's doctor and therapists will ask them to use a cast or a splint to protect the body while it heals. They also may ask the person not to do certain movements, or any activities where it is necessary to use the hand for squeezing or gripping. This is important to allow healing, but the injured arm can become weaker during this period. New research has demonstrated that performing specific forms of exercise on the uninjured side can help speed recovery on the injured side, even when the injured hand is still in a cast.

Two of these types of exercise are called cross-education and mirror visual feedback. Cross-education means doing resistance or strengthening exercises on the uninjured side while the injured side is resting. Mirror visual feedback is performing exercise or movements with the uninjured hand in front of a mirror, hiding the injured hand resting behind the mirror, so it looks like the injured hand is doing the exercises too. The investigators think both of these exercises work because they use the same part of the brain, part of our movement control network that helps us coordinate movements on both sides of the body. Perhaps they might work even better if used together.

This study will test cross-education, mirror visual feedback or cross-education combined with mirror visual feedback added to the usual therapy after a hand or wrist injury. The investigators need to be sure that this is better than usual care, so some people who participate in the study will just have the usual care, and not do any extra exercise. Because limited research has been done on these methods after injury, this will be a small study to test the best ways to run a big study that will provide solid proof about these ideas. That means the investigators will ask participants to keep track of how often they do their exercises, and to tell the study team about any problems or concerns they have when they are doing their exercises.

If it can be demonstrated that cross-exercise and/or mirror visual feedback can speed up or improve recovery after a hand or wrist injury, it might help participants get back to work and their usual activities faster and with less pain. These treatments don't cost a lot of money or need a lot of special equipment, so they could be used in many different countries. If the study can show these exercises help with hand and wrist injuries, they might also be able to be used for therapy after stroke, or with other kinds of injuries like foot and ankle fractures.

Conditions

Hand Injuries

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: FACTORIAL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Cross-Education

Cross education has been defined as the unilateral training of a limb with resisted exercise for the benefit of transferring strength to the contralateral (often injured or immobilized) limb. Participants randomized to cross-education will be provided with a hand-grip strengthener, adjusted to provide resistance at 70-80% of their maximum grip strength. They will be given written, illustrated instructions for performing grip strengthening exercises for their uninjured hand in a seated position with both forearms comfortably supported; this will be demonstrated during the teaching session. The instructions will ask for the participant to complete 3 sets of 10 repetitions twice daily, with additional instructions for appropriate grading of resistance. A diary for tracking exercise completion and attendance for usual care will also be provided.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Cross-Education

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Home exercise program + usual care

Usual care

Intervention Type: OTHER

Hand rehabilitation provided by occupational therapists and physiotherapists in a multidisciplinary outpatient setting

Mirror Visual Feedback

Mirror visual feedback is the performance of movements with an uninjured hand in front of a mirror hiding the injured hand, thus creating the illusion of bilateral movement. Participants randomized to mirror visual feedback will be provided with a portable mirror and stand, and instructed with accompanying demonstration on how to set up on a table for comfortable visualization. They will be given written, illustrated instructions for performing mirror visualization of exercises completed by the uninjured hand only from a position of neutral rotation of the forearm. The instructions will ask for the participant to complete a three sets of 10 repetitions for finger flexion and extension (mimicking the fisting motion of the grip strengthening exercises) twice daily. A diary for tracking exercise completion and attendance for usual care will also be provided.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Mirror Visual Feedback

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Home exercise program + usual care

Usual care

Intervention Type: OTHER

Hand rehabilitation provided by occupational therapists and physiotherapists in a multidisciplinary outpatient setting

Cross-education + Mirror Visual Feedback

In this group, participants will perform the cross-education resistance exercise in front of the mirror, visualizing the performance of the resistance exercises. Participants randomized to cross education with mirror visual feedback will be provided with both a hand-grip strengthener and a portable mirror and stand, and instructed with accompanying demonstration on how to set up on a table for comfortable visualization. They will be given written, illustrated instructions for performing mirror visualization hand grip strengthening exercises completed by the uninjured hand only from a position of neutral rotation of the forearm. The instructions will ask for the participant to complete 3 sets of 10 repetitions twice daily, with additional instructions for appropriate grading of resistance. A diary for tracking exercise completion and attendance for usual care will also be provided.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Mirror Visual Feedback

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Home exercise program + usual care

Usual care

Intervention Type: OTHER

Hand rehabilitation provided by occupational therapists and physiotherapists in a multidisciplinary outpatient setting

Usual Care

Participants randomized to usual care will be encouraged to attend the recommended rehabilitation, and provided with a diary for frequency of rehab attendance, and tracking any exercises completed at home.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Usual care

Intervention Type: OTHER

Hand rehabilitation provided by occupational therapists and physiotherapists in a multidisciplinary outpatient setting

Interventions

Cross-Education

Home exercise program + usual care

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Mirror Visual Feedback

Home exercise program + usual care

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Usual care

Hand rehabilitation provided by occupational therapists and physiotherapists in a multidisciplinary outpatient setting

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Age 16 or older
• Acute injury to one hand or wrist requiring protection or immobilization, including fractures (managed conservatively or with surgery), tendon laceration/repairs, burns, and/or ligament injuries/repairs
• Able to provide informed consent

Exclusion Criteria

• Unable to complete study questionnaires in English
• Traumatic injuries to other limbs or axial skeleton (e.g. whiplash, rib fracture, concurrent lower limb injury)
• Anticipates difficulty to return for follow-up visits (i.e. out of catchment)

• Minimum Eligible Age: 16 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

McMaster University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Tara Packham

Assistant Professor

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Central Contacts

Tara Packham, PhD

Role: CONTACT

packhamt@mcmaster.ca

9055259140 ext. 27812

References

Green LA, Gabriel DA. The cross education of strength and skill following unilateral strength training in the upper and lower limbs. J Neurophysiol. 2018 Aug 1;120(2):468-479. doi: 10.1152/jn.00116.2018. Epub 2018 Apr 18.

Reference Type: BACKGROUND

PMID: 29668382 (View on PubMed)

Other Identifiers

5979

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id