Cooled Radiofrequency vs. Hyaluronic Acid to Manage Knee Pain

NCT ID: NCT03381248

Last Updated: 2023-10-10

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 177 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2017-12-07
• Study Completion Date: 2020-07-20

Brief Summary

This is a prospective, randomized, multicenter comparison study examining the outcomes of subjects with osteoarthritis and knee pain undergoing a procedure to create a radiofrequency lesion of the genicular nerves with the Cooled Radiofrequency Ablation (CRFA) system compared to subjects receiving Hyaluronic Acid (HA). Approximately 168 subjects will be enrolled into this study, with subjects undergoing either CRFA or HA injection in a 1:1 randomization scheme. Follow-up will be conducted for 12 months post-CRFA, with the primary endpoint being completed at month 6. Subjects randomized to the comparison (HA) group will have the option to cross-over to the neurotomy group after completing the 6-month endpoint assessment. They will be followed for an additional 6 months. Pain, overall outcome, quality of life, pain medication use, and adverse events will be compared between the two treatment groups to determine success. Subjects who were randomized to and received COOLIEF* as their initial treatment will have the option to add 2 additional visits at 6-month intervals, representing 18 and 24 months post initial treatment.

Detailed Description

The COOLIEF™ system components utilized in the study are the same in form and function regardless of specific product branding (COOLIEF* or SInergy*). The COOLIEF™ system is comprised of three primary components (collectively known as 'disposables') and is used in conjunction with the Pain Management generator, pump unit, connector cables (collectively known as 'Hardware') and dispersive electrodes (also known as 'grounding pads'):

• Cooled Radiofrequency Sterile Tube Kit (sterile, single use, non-body contact): It is used for closed-loop circulation of sterile water through a Halyard Health* Cooled Radiofrequency Probe. It includes a burette and tubing.
• Cooled Radiofrequency Introducer (sterile, single use): It is to be used with the Probes only. The Cooled Radiofrequency Introducer provides a path for the Probe to the targeted nervous tissue.
• Cooled Radiofrequency Probe (sterile, single use): It is inserted through an Introducer into or near nervous tissue. The active tip extends 4mm from the introducer and delivers energy. Sterile water circulates internally to cool the Probe while it delivers radiofrequency energy. A thermocouple in the Probe measures the cooled electrode temperature throughout the procedure.

The product is comprised of an electrically insulated shaft with an active tip that functions as an electrode for radiofrequency energy delivery, a handle, tubes with luer locks and a cable with a 7-pin connector. The Introducer includes an insulated stainless steel cannula and a stylet. The Tube Kit is comprised of a burette and flexible tubing fitted with luer locks for connection to the Probe. The Probe, Introducer, and Tube Kit are ethylene oxide sterilized and supplied sterile. These components can be packaged together in a kit or as separate components. The devices should be stored in a cool, dry environment. The Instructions For Use (IFU) documents (Appendix 1) are included in each kit.

Halyard Health maintains a list of all model numbers and sizes for the system components.

The control product/device, Synvisc-One® (hylan G-F 20) (HA), is an elastoviscous high molecular weight fluid containing hylan A and hylan B polymers produced from chicken combs. Hylans are derivatives of hyaluronan (sodium hyaluronate). Hylan G-F 20 is unique in that the hyaluronan is chemically crosslinked. Hyaluronan is a long-chain polymer containing repeating disaccharide units of Na-glucuronate-N-acetylglucosamine.

Synvisc-One is a single injection regimen therapy indicated for the treatment of pain in Osteoarthritis of the knee in patients who have failed to respond adequately to conservative nonpharmacologic therapy and simple analgesics, e.g., acetaminophen.

Following treatment, subjects in the CRF treatment group will follow up at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months. These subjects will then have the option to return for two additional visits at 18 and 24 months. Subjects initially randomized to the comparison (HA) group will follow up at 1, 3, and 6 months, and then be given the option to receive crossover CRF treatment. If crossover CRF treatment was received, subjects will return for follow up visits at 1, 3, and 6 months post-treatment. If crossover treatment was not received, subjects will return for their final 12 month visit.

Study Duration:

• Treatment Group: Up to 24 months following index procedure
• Control Group: Up to 13 months, depending upon receipt of cross-over procedure.

Effectiveness Endpoints:

• Numeric Rating Scale (NRS, Usual Level of Pain)
• Western Ontario & McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC)
• EQ-5D-5L Health-Related Quality of Life Questionnaire
• Global Perceived Effect Scale

Conditions

Osteoarthritis of the Knee

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

Cooled Radiofrequency

Cooled radiofrequency energy will be delivered to study subjects' knees to ablate culprit sensory nerves and reduce knee pain. Subjects in this group will be followed for 12 months post-procedure.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Cooled Radiofrequency

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Delivery of energy to ablate sensory nerves via cooled radiofrequency probe.

Hyaluronic Acid, then Cooled Radiofrequency

Hyaluronic acid injections will be administered to study subjects' knees to reduce knee pain. Subjects in this group will have the option to crossover to receive cooled radiofrequency after 6-months. Crossover subjects will be followed for an additional 6 months post-procedure. Non-crossover subjects will continue to be followed until the 12-month timepoint.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Hyaluronic Acid Injection

Intervention Type: OTHER

Delivery of hyaluronic acid into knee by injection with needle to reduce knee pain.

Crossover from Hyaluronic Acid Injection to Cooled Radiofrequency

Intervention Type: OTHER

Delivery of hyaluronic acid into knee by injection with needle to reduce knee pain. After 6 months, qualifying subjects in this group will have the option to crossover to receive cooled radiofrequency treatment.

Interventions

Cooled Radiofrequency

Delivery of energy to ablate sensory nerves via cooled radiofrequency probe.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Hyaluronic Acid Injection

Delivery of hyaluronic acid into knee by injection with needle to reduce knee pain.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Crossover from Hyaluronic Acid Injection to Cooled Radiofrequency

Delivery of hyaluronic acid into knee by injection with needle to reduce knee pain. After 6 months, qualifying subjects in this group will have the option to crossover to receive cooled radiofrequency treatment.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Other Intervention Names

Coolief; Viscosupplementation; Viscosupplementation; Cooled Radiofrequency

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

1. Age ≥ 21 years

2. Able to understand the informed consent form and provide written informed consent and able to complete outcome measures

3. Chronic knee pain for longer than 6 months that interferes with functional activities (for example, ambulation, prolonged standing, etc.)

4. Continued pain in the target knee despite at least 3 months of conservative treatments, including activity modification, home exercise, protective weight bearing, and/or analgesics (for example, acetaminophen or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs [NSAIDs])

5. Positive response (defined as a decrease in numeric pain scores of at least 50%) to a single genicular nerve block of the index knee

6. Pain on NRS ≥ 6 on an 11-point scale for the index knee

7. Radiologic confirmation of arthritis (x-ray/MRI/CT) of Osteoarthritis (OA) grade of 2 (mild), 3 (moderate) or 4 (severe) noted within 6 months for the index knee

8. An intra-articular hyaluronic acid injection is indicated as an appropriate treatment option

9. WOMAC Knee Score group at baseline of Score of ≥ 2 (0 to 4 scale) on WOMAC question 1 (Pain) and a mean score of ≥ 1.5 on all five questions of the WOMAC pain subscale.

10. Analgesics including membrane stabilizers such as Neurontin/gabapentin and antidepressants for pain such as Cymbalta/duloxetine must be clinically stable (defined as stable dosage for ≥ 6 weeks prior to the screening visit) and shall not change during the course of the study without approval of the investigator

11. Agree to see one physician (study physician) for knee pain during the study period

12. Willing to utilize double barrier contraceptive method if of child bearing potential.

13. Willing to delay any surgical intervention for the index knee for the period of the study follow up

14. Willingness to provide informed consent and to comply with the requirements of this protocol for the full duration of the study

Exclusion Criteria

1. Evidence of inflammatory arthritis (for example, rheumatoid arthritis) or other systemic inflammatory condition (for example, gout, fibromyalgia) that could cause knee pain

2. Evidence of neuropathic pain affecting the index knee

3. Previous or pending lower limb amputation

4. Intra-articular steroid injection into the index knee within 90 days from randomization

5. Hyaluronic acid injection, platelet rich plasma (PRP), stem cell, or arthroscopic debridement/lavage injection into the index knee within 180 days from randomization

6. Prior radiofrequency ablation of the genicular nerves of the index knee

7. Prior partial, resurfacing, or total knee arthroplasty of the index knee (residual hardware)

8. Clinically significant ligamentous laxity of the index knee

9. Clinically significant valgus/varus deformities or evidence of pathology (other than osteoarthritis of knee) that materially affects gait or function of the knee or is the underlying cause of the knee pain and/or functional limitations

10. Body mass index (BMI) > 40 kg/m2

11. Extremely thin patients and those with minimal subcutaneous tissue thickness that would not accommodate a radiofrequency lesion of up to 14 mm in diameter to limit the risk of skin burns

12. Pending or active compensation claim, litigation or disability remuneration (secondary gain)

13. Pregnant, nursing or intent on becoming pregnant during the study period

14. Chronic pain associated with significant psychosocial dysfunction

15. Beck's Depression Index score of > 22 (indicates clinically depressed state)

16. Allergies to any of the medications to be used during the procedures, including known hypersensitivity (allergy) to hyaluronate preparations or allergies to avian or avian-derived products (including eggs, feathers, or poultry)

17. Active joint infection or systemic or localized infection at needle entry sites (subject may be considered for inclusion once infection is resolved)

18. History of uncontrolled coagulopathy, ongoing coagulation treatment that cannot be safely interrupted for procedure, or unexplained or uncontrollable bleeding that is uncorrectable.

19. Identifiable anatomical variability that would materially alter the procedure as described in the protocol

20. Within the preceding 2 years, subject has suffered from active narcotic addiction, substance, or alcohol abuse

21. Current prescribed opioid medications greater than 60 morphine equivalent daily opioid dose

22. Uncontrolled immunosuppression (e.g. AIDS, cancer, diabetes, etc.)

23. Subject currently implanted with pacemaker, stimulator or defibrillator.

24. Participating in another clinical trial/investigation within 30 days prior to signing informed consent

25. Subject unwilling or unable to comply with follow up schedule or protocol requirements

• Minimum Eligible Age: 21 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Avanos Medical

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Principal Investigators

Antonia F Chen, MD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Brigham and Women's Hospital

Locations

Lyman Medical Research

Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, United States

Ocshner Baptist Clinical Trials Unit

New Orleans, Louisiana, United States

Mayo Clinic

Rochester, Minnesota, United States

Clinical Investigations, LLC

Edmond, Oklahoma, United States

University Orthopedics Center

Altoona, Pennsylvania, United States

University of Pennsylvania

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States

University Orthopedics Center

State College, Pennsylvania, United States

Piedmont Comprehensive Pain Management

Anderson, South Carolina, United States

University of Virginia

Charlottesville, Virginia, United States

Virginia iSpine Physicians

Richmond, Virginia, United States

Countries

United States

References

Chen AF, Khalouf F, Zora K, DePalma M, Kohan L, Guirguis M, Beall D, Loudermilk E, Pingree MJ, Badiola I, Lyman J. Cooled radiofrequency ablation provides extended clinical utility in the management of knee osteoarthritis: 12-month results from a prospective, multi-center, randomized, cross-over trial comparing cooled radiofrequency ablation to a single hyaluronic acid injection. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2020 Jun 9;21(1):363. doi: 10.1186/s12891-020-03380-5.

Reference Type: DERIVED

PMID: 32517739 (View on PubMed)

Provided Documents

Document Type: Study Protocol and Statistical Analysis Plan

View Document

Other Identifiers

105-17-0001

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id