Comparison of the Malposition Rates of the Vertebral Pedicle Screws Using the PediGuard Technique: PediGuard Technique Associated With Fluoroscopy and Fluoroscopy Alone

NCT ID: NCT02826499

Last Updated: 2017-07-28

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 20 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2016-07-31
• Study Completion Date: 2017-07-31

Brief Summary

Pedicular screwing has become the gold standard for intervertebral fixation required in degenerative, scoliotic, tumoral pathologies or for fractures. Several pedicular screwing methods exist.

The free hand pedicular screwing requires a high learning curve and has, as a consequence, a high malposition rate.

The placing of pedicular screws under fluoroscopic control is the most common technique as it is both reproducible and accessible. It is a two dimensional imaging technique. The profile incidence at the level of the spine is mostly used to spot the vertebral pedicle and the direction of the screw in the sagittal plane. However, there is no real control of the direction of the pedicular screw in the horizontal or frontal plane. The screw malposition rate is less important than with the 'free hand' technique but remains none of the less significant. Furthermore, fluoroscopy is an irradiating imaging technique, both for the patient and the staff.

New revolutionary techniques as the tridimensional navigation and the per-operatory tomodensitometry appeared in the last few years. The techniques give the best results when used concommitantly. The material has the advantage of being very precise. The pedicular screw malposition rate is minimal after a three-dimensional localisation. However, those systems require qualified staff and expose the patient and the nursing team to high radiation levels. The costs are higher and the surgery duration is globally longer. It is thus difficult to implement this technique in each belgian hospital.

Finally, the Pediguard technique appeared on the market. It is a guide for the perforation of the pedicular channel, with a probe at its extremity. This probe allows a real time measurement of the electric conductivity of the tissues that are being crossed. The conductivity measure is translated in a sound signal. Because the cortical bone has a low conductivity, the probe will emit a low intensity sound signal. The cancellous bone has a medium conductivity. Therefore, the probe will emit a medium sound signal. However, in the event of a breach in the pedicular cortical, as blood and periost have a high conductibility, the probe will emit a intense, rapid pace, sound signal.The Pediguard technique helps thus to anticipate a cortical effraction, by detecting the proximity of the cortical wall. It is efficient but remains relatively expensive.

The main objective of this study is to determine the precision of the placing of pedicular screws, with and without Pediguard system, under fluoroscopy.

Conditions

Pedicular Screwing

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: PREVENTION
• Blinding Strategy: DOUBLE

Study Groups

Fluoroscopy

Vertebral instrumentation with pedicular screwing, performed under fluoroscopy.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Fluoroscopy

Intervention Type: OTHER

The placing of pedicular screws under fluoroscopic control is the most common technique as it is both reproducible and accessible. It is a two dimensional imaging technique. The profile incidence at the level of the spine is mostly used to spot the vertebral pedicle and the direction of the screw in the sagittal plane. However, there is no real control of the direction of the pedicular screw in the horizontal or frontal plane and it is an irradiating imaging technique.

Fluoroscopy and Pediguard

Vertebral instrumentation with pedicular screwing, performed under fluoroscopy, with the Pediguard system.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Pediguard

Intervention Type: DEVICE

It is a guide for the perforation of the pedicular channel, with a probe at its extremity. This probe allows a real time measurement of the electric conductivity of the tissues that are being crossed. The conductivity measure is translated in a sound signal. Because the cortical bone has a low conductivity, the probe will emit a low intensity sound signal. The cancellous bone has a medium conductivity. Therefore, the probe will emit a medium sound signal. However, in the event of a breach in the pedicular cortical, as blood and periost have a high conductibility, the probe will emit a intense, rapid pace, sound signal.The Pediguard technique helps thus to anticipate a cortical effraction, by detecting the proximity of the cortical wall.

Fluoroscopy

Intervention Type: OTHER

The placing of pedicular screws under fluoroscopic control is the most common technique as it is both reproducible and accessible. It is a two dimensional imaging technique. The profile incidence at the level of the spine is mostly used to spot the vertebral pedicle and the direction of the screw in the sagittal plane. However, there is no real control of the direction of the pedicular screw in the horizontal or frontal plane and it is an irradiating imaging technique.

Interventions

Pediguard

It is a guide for the perforation of the pedicular channel, with a probe at its extremity. This probe allows a real time measurement of the electric conductivity of the tissues that are being crossed. The conductivity measure is translated in a sound signal. Because the cortical bone has a low conductivity, the probe will emit a low intensity sound signal. The cancellous bone has a medium conductivity. Therefore, the probe will emit a medium sound signal. However, in the event of a breach in the pedicular cortical, as blood and periost have a high conductibility, the probe will emit a intense, rapid pace, sound signal.The Pediguard technique helps thus to anticipate a cortical effraction, by detecting the proximity of the cortical wall.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Fluoroscopy

The placing of pedicular screws under fluoroscopic control is the most common technique as it is both reproducible and accessible. It is a two dimensional imaging technique. The profile incidence at the level of the spine is mostly used to spot the vertebral pedicle and the direction of the screw in the sagittal plane. However, there is no real control of the direction of the pedicular screw in the horizontal or frontal plane and it is an irradiating imaging technique.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• All patients needing vertebral instrumentation with pedicular screwing

Exclusion Criteria

• Contra-indication to the placement of pedicular screws under fluoroscopy

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Brugmann University Hospital

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Tamas Illes

Head of clinic

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Tamas Illes, MD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

CHU Brugmann

Locations

CHU Brugmann

Brussels, , Belgium

Countries

Belgium

Other Identifiers

CHUB-Pediguard

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id