The Comparsion of MCkenzie and Mulligan Exercise in Patients With Non-Specific Neck Pain

NCT ID: NCT05496699

Last Updated: 2022-08-11

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 30 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2022-04-01
• Study Completion Date: 2022-06-01

Brief Summary

Non-specific neck pain (NSBA) is defined as pain in the posterior and lateral parts of the neck in the absence of neurological and specific pathologies (fracture, infection, inflammation, etc.) between the superior nuchael line and the 1st thoracic vertebra. The lifetime neck pain rate is approximately 12-70%; Neck pain is the reason for admission in approximately 25% of applications to outpatient clinics of the Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinic. Neck pain is the most common spinal problem after low back pain, and it is defined as nonspecific neck pain due to its multifactorial etiology. Many conservative treatment methods are used in the treatment of NSBA. These include medical treatments, exercise, massage, acupuncture, neural therapy and physical therapy modalities. The basis of Mulligan's theory is based on a positional error that develops secondarily, causing misplacement of the joint. With the Mulligan mobilization technique, the joint is displaced to normal and positional error is corrected. Restoration of motion is aimed by repositioning the bone. The main indication in this technique is increased pain, stiffness and weakness in movement. The Mulligan mobilization technique is performed by asking for active movement while maintaining a manually applied joint shift. Painless movement is aimed at the joint. According to the general principles of Mulligan treatment, all techniques are applied in a way that does not cause pain and creates an effect that will eliminate the pain in a short time after the application.

Detailed Description

The McKenzie approach is an evaluative and therapeutic strategy in the practice of musculoskeletal physiotherapy to manage pain and restore the function of the cervical spine. This approach aims to control cervical disability when used in the early stages such as postural correction and increasing flexibility of adjacent musculotendinous structures. It aims to classify mechanically induced spinal pain into postural, dysfunctional and dysregulation syndromes to centralize and reduce spinal pain. Cervical self-treatment techniques used by McKenzie specialists have been shown to be effective for nonspecific neck pain. The purpose of evaluating patients with cervical-related disorders is to select self-management techniques as directional preference movements that should be repeated to reduce pain and symptoms. When we look at the studies in the literature; It has been reported that Mulligan concept techniques improve pain and disability symptoms in patients with chronic mechanical neck pain at the short- and medium-term effect level. In a study comparing Mulligan and McKenzie practices previously, it was concluded that Mulligan exercise was more effective in improving cervical range of motion than McKenzie exercise in adults with reduced cervical lordosis. In another comparative article, according to the results of the study comparing the two exercise techniques, it was seen that cervical ROM increased in both exercise groups.

However, it was concluded that the Mulligan exercise group showed better results than the Mckenzie group in the early period. Different types of mobilization are used to treat neck pain, but limited studies have been conducted to compare the effectiveness of two different mobilization techniques in the treatment of neck pain.

The aim of the study was that two different exercise programs (mckenzi-mulligan) were used in individuals with non-specific neck pain; to compare their effects on pain, range of motion (ROM) and functional outcomes. It is aimed to compare the effect of Mulligan exercises and Mckenzie exercises on pain reduction, joint range of motion, recovery speed, muscle activation and functional treatment in individuals with non-specific neck pain due to non-specific neck pain due to multifactorial etiology. Considering that there should be a larger number of studies on this subject with the literature review, it is aimed to contribute this study to the literature.

Conditions

Neck Pain

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

mckenzie group

Mckenzie exercise protocol will be applied to the participants in this group. It will be applied to the participants for 4 weeks and 5 days a week for 30 minutes. The exercise program will be performed by the patient under the supervision of a physiotherapist.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Mckenzie Exercises

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

1. Cervical Retraction Exercise in Sitting Position The participant sits on the chair, puts the second and third fingers on his chin and pushes his head posteriorly and inferiorly.

2. Cervical Rotation Exercise in Sitting Position

3. Cervical Retraction Exercise in Supine Position

4. Cervical Rotation Exercise in Supine Position The participant turns his head to the right and left, respectively, while taking his head back in the supine position with his head out of the bed.

5. Cervical Lateral Flexion Exercise

6. Cervical Flexion Exercise in Sitting Position

mullgian group

Mulligan exercise protocol will be applied to the participants in this group. It will be applied to the participants for 4 weeks and 5 days a week for 30 minutes. The exercise program will be performed by the patient under the supervision of a physiotherapist.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Mulligan Exercise

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

The exercises to be applied are listed below.

1- C1-C2 Self Mobilization Slip is applied for natural apophyseal cervical right rotation. The belt is put on level C1. At the same time, the participant actively pulls the belt and turns his head to the right. To facilitate the rotation of the belt in C1, pressure is applied to the belt in the same direction as C2 and rotation of the head towards the restricted side is requested. It waits like this for 3 seconds. These movements are done in the painless range.

Interventions

Mckenzie Exercises

1. Cervical Retraction Exercise in Sitting Position The participant sits on the chair, puts the second and third fingers on his chin and pushes his head posteriorly and inferiorly.

2. Cervical Rotation Exercise in Sitting Position

3. Cervical Retraction Exercise in Supine Position

4. Cervical Rotation Exercise in Supine Position The participant turns his head to the right and left, respectively, while taking his head back in the supine position with his head out of the bed.

5. Cervical Lateral Flexion Exercise

6. Cervical Flexion Exercise in Sitting Position

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Mulligan Exercise

The exercises to be applied are listed below.

1- C1-C2 Self Mobilization Slip is applied for natural apophyseal cervical right rotation. The belt is put on level C1. At the same time, the participant actively pulls the belt and turns his head to the right. To facilitate the rotation of the belt in C1, pressure is applied to the belt in the same direction as C2 and rotation of the head towards the restricted side is requested. It waits like this for 3 seconds. These movements are done in the painless range.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Individuals with neck pain of unknown origin for more than 3 months
• Individuals between the ages of 18-45
• Non-smokers
• Individuals who have the ability to understand and apply Turkish written and verbal instructions

Exclusion Criteria

• Individuals with a history of neck injury, micro or macro trauma,
• Individuals with tumors in and around the spinal cord,
• Individuals who have undergone surgery from the neck and shoulder region,
• Individuals with positive Vertebrobacillary Artery Test,
• Female individuals who are pregnant, individuals receiving hormone therapy,
• Individuals with neurological disease,
• Individuals with neuropathic pain due to neurological and systemic disorders,
• Patients with any loss of function in the upper extremities due to musculoskeletal disease

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 45 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Istinye University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Yasemin Çırak

Associate Professor

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Burcu Pamukçu

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Istinye University

Locations

İstinye University

Istanbul, , Turkey (Türkiye)

Countries

Turkey (Türkiye)

Other Identifiers

IstinyeFTR

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id