Impact of Baby Carrying Methods on Females Balance During Standing

NCT ID: NCT04793321

Last Updated: 2021-03-11

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 50 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2020-12-29
• Study Completion Date: 2021-02-17

Brief Summary

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of different baby carrying methods (including carrying in arms and carrying in a baby carrier) in the females' balance during standing and walking.

Detailed Description

Babywearing is defined as using a supporting device that helps to keep an infant close to a caregiver's trunk.

The practice of babywearing has many benefits to both children and caregivers as it is an extension of "skin-to-skin care (SSC)" or "kangaroo care" which has well-known therapeutic benefits. Such benefits for the infant include: improve physical and cognitive state, good sleep, less likely to continuously cry, better breastfeeding, temperature stability.

For mothers, many benefits were found as well for example lower stress and anxiety levels, decrease in heart rate HR and blood pressure BP, higher breastfeeding rates, increase maternal satisfaction, increased bonding of mother with their neonate .

Despite the great advantage of infant carrying, there are many adverse effects on the musculoskeletal system and ergonomics of the mother. Women who carry their babies throughout the day will probably have similar consequences as carrying an extra load so pain and injuries will occur.

It has been reported that infant carrying in-arms caused acute muscle soreness in the ipsilateral upper limb that was used to support the infant over the left shoulder. While during the front infant carrying methods (ICMs), the pressure of the infant carrier shoulder straps caused shoulder discomfort and pain.

The front infant carrying position has the next highest fatigue score as it results in lower Metabolic equivalent (METS) and VO2max value which means that it places significant demand on the metabolic system.

It have been reported that the increased cost of carrying an infant in one's arms is the cause for the development of infant carrying tools rapidly.

Infant carrying is a form of exterogestation, just like in pregnancy, there is an alteration that swings the center of gravity of the body, shifts the postural balance, and increases the risk of falls .

Contrariwise, the usage of the carrier resulted in more similar postural control variables to the unloaded condition. Mannen and colleagues advised the use of babywearing as it provides a mechanical advantage to the caregiver.

Surprisingly, no study so far has quantified the actual balance changes with different carrying methods (including carrying in arms and carrying in a baby carrier) during typical movements of daily life, such as walking or standing upright.

Previous research has indicated that carrying externals loads elicits an increase in the center of pressure (COP) measures of postural sway during quiet standing .

Mathew W. Hill & Price reported that holding external loads during standing is an important issue for many daily and occupational activities and these external loads can affect postural stability, which is important for the mother's and fetus's safety. Also, holding a load in the hand may have restricted and/or delayed postural reactions.

From this perspective, both carrying methods are considered extra load and the question is that there any carrying methods that have an advantage over others concerning balance?

Conditions

Balance; Distorted

Study Design

• Allocation Method: NA
• Intervention Model: SINGLE_GROUP
• Primary Study Purpose: OTHER
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

healty nulliparous females

each participant did three conditions:

1. holding nothing (unloaded).

2. holding an infant mannequin in arms(arms).

3. holding an infant mannequin in the baby carrier(carriers).

Group Type: OTHER

Baby carrier

Intervention Type: DEVICE

• It is made in china.
• It is made of Cotton-Polyester.
• It has 3 belts - 2 shoulder belts and one waist belt for superior lumbar support. Shoulder straps are padded and adjustable for the parent's comfort. It has webbing straps for shoulder and waist strap adjustment.
• It is suitable for newborn to 12-months baby
• It is available online at babyshopstores "https://www.babyshopstores.com/"

Biodex Balance System

Intervention Type: DEVICE

• The Biodex Balance System SD (The Biodex Balance System SD Model 945-300, 115 VAC, Shirley, NY, USA) is used to assess the balance in this study.
• It is an objective device that measures dynamic postural stability. It uses a circular platform that allows up to 20˚of of platform tilt in a 360˚ range of motion.
• The measures of postural stability score for BBS are the Overall Stability Index (OSI), Medial-Lateral Stability Index (MLSI), and Anterior-Posterior Stability Index (APSI). These indices are standard deviations that assess the path of sway around the zero point from the center of the platform and are measured in degrees. A high score in these stability indices indicates poor balance.

Infant mannequin

Intervention Type: OTHER

The mannequin infant has 3 Kg which corresponds to the infant's age from birth until 1month. This weight is selected as it corresponds to the age at which the infants are frequently carried by the mother .

Biodex gait trainer 2 TM

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Gait Trainer 2™ ( model number:950-385, 115 VAC 50/60 Hz, made in the USA) is used for participants to walk on as walking is one of the most common daily life activities. because caregivers commonly walk while carrying their infants as it has a calming effect on crying infants

It consists of :

• Display: Use Audio and Visual Biofeedback - real-time biofeedback prompts patients into a proper gait pattern.
• Heart Rate Monitoring
• Handrail
• Open Platform

Interventions

Baby carrier

• It is made in china.
• It is made of Cotton-Polyester.
• It has 3 belts - 2 shoulder belts and one waist belt for superior lumbar support. Shoulder straps are padded and adjustable for the parent's comfort. It has webbing straps for shoulder and waist strap adjustment.
• It is suitable for newborn to 12-months baby
• It is available online at babyshopstores "https://www.babyshopstores.com/"

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Biodex Balance System

• The Biodex Balance System SD (The Biodex Balance System SD Model 945-300, 115 VAC, Shirley, NY, USA) is used to assess the balance in this study.
• It is an objective device that measures dynamic postural stability. It uses a circular platform that allows up to 20˚of of platform tilt in a 360˚ range of motion.
• The measures of postural stability score for BBS are the Overall Stability Index (OSI), Medial-Lateral Stability Index (MLSI), and Anterior-Posterior Stability Index (APSI). These indices are standard deviations that assess the path of sway around the zero point from the center of the platform and are measured in degrees. A high score in these stability indices indicates poor balance.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Infant mannequin

The mannequin infant has 3 Kg which corresponds to the infant's age from birth until 1month. This weight is selected as it corresponds to the age at which the infants are frequently carried by the mother .

Intervention Type: OTHER

Biodex gait trainer 2 TM

Gait Trainer 2™ ( model number:950-385, 115 VAC 50/60 Hz, made in the USA) is used for participants to walk on as walking is one of the most common daily life activities. because caregivers commonly walk while carrying their infants as it has a calming effect on crying infants

It consists of :

• Display: Use Audio and Visual Biofeedback - real-time biofeedback prompts patients into a proper gait pattern.
• Heart Rate Monitoring
• Handrail
• Open Platform

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

1. Had normal menstrual cycles.

2. All females were recruited on a day other than mese days.

3. Their age ranged from 20 to 35 years old.

4. Their body mass index ranged from 18-30 kg/m².

5. Had no experience with babywearing or in arm-carrying methods

Exclusion Criteria

• Subjects were excluded if they had the following criteria:

1. Females who had irregular menstrual cycles.

2. Females who used oral contraceptive drugs or hormonal supplementary and injections through the previous 3 months.

3. Females who had Musculoskeletal disorders or pain in the upper and lower extremities in the prior 6 months.

4. Females complained of knee, ankle, or back pain.

5. Females with a severe chronic illness that interfere with balance such as vestibular dysfunction.

6. Any health condition that could interfere with the ability to maintain balance was excluded.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 20 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 35 Years
• Eligible Sex: FEMALE
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Hamada Ahmed

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Hamada Ahmed

Assistant Professor of Biomechanics, Faculty of Physical Therapy, Cairo University

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Prof. Dr. Amel Mohamed Yousef, Professor

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Cairo University

Locations

Faculty of Physical Therapy/ Cairo University

Giza, Dokki, Egypt

Countries

Egypt

References

Inanir A, Cakmak B, Hisim Y, Demirturk F. Evaluation of postural equilibrium and fall risk during pregnancy. Gait Posture. 2014 Apr;39(4):1122-5. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2014.01.013. Epub 2014 Feb 2.

Reference Type: BACKGROUND

PMID: 24630464 (View on PubMed)

Brown MB, Digby-Bowl CJ, Todd SD. Assessing Infant Carriage Systems: Ground Reaction Force Implications for Gait of the Caregiver. Hum Factors. 2018 Mar;60(2):160-171. doi: 10.1177/0018720817744661. Epub 2017 Dec 15.

Reference Type: BACKGROUND

PMID: 29244534 (View on PubMed)

Other Identifiers

baby carrying methods

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id