Non-Inferiority of Fibroguide Collagen Membrane Compared to Autologous Connective Tissue Graft for Coverage of Multiple Adjacent Recession. Multicenter Trial.

NCT ID: NCT07083050

Last Updated: 2025-08-07

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: RECRUITING
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 160 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2015-07-12
• Study Completion Date: 2029-12-31

Brief Summary

This study deals with coverage of multiple denuded roots. The current standard treatment requires surgical correction and uses soft tissue taken from the roof of the mouth to enhance results. The hypothesis of this trial is that a synthetic collagen matrix (called Fibrogide) can be used to replace soft tissue taken from the subject. If the collagen matrix will prove to be equally as effective as the patient own tissue, it will be possible to avoid a more extensive surgery and decrease pain and discomfort.

Detailed Description

Objectives Primary objective: to assess non-inferiority of differences in root coverage of recession defects comparing the use of Volume Stable Collagen Matrix (VCMX, Geistlich Fibro-Gide®) ed to the use of CTG at 12 months Secondary objectives: to assess if VCMX is non-inferior in terms of complete root coverage, percentage of root coverage and professional evaluation of aesthetics. Moreover, the study is also designed to test if VCMX Geistlich Fibro-Gide® reduces morbidity, shortens time to recovery and improves patient based related outcomes with respect to the use of autologous connective tissue graft harvested from the patient own palate when used to obtain root coverage of multiple adjacent gingival recessions. Moreover, as adverse events, complete root coverage, and professional evaluation of aesthetics will be assessed

Design and Outcomes This will be a parallel group, controlled, assessor-blind, randomized, multicenter, multinational, clinical trial.

The statistical design will be a non-inferiority trial in terms of the professional outcomes measuring root coverage and aesthetics and a superiority trial in terms of patients related outcomes.

Based on a recently completed and published RCT with similar design (Geistlich Mucograft® study), the sample size has been estimated in 80 subjects per treatment arm (about 200 recessions/arm) to be analyzed with a multilevel statistical approach and a non-inferiority margin of 0.25 mm in recession coverage. The non-inferiority margin has been set as 50% of the clinically relevant difference estimated at 0.5 mm.

Randomization will be performed by computer generated random codes, using random permuted blocks with a block size of 4 to avoid uneven splits and minimization for the key prognostic factor cigarette smoking. Allocation will be concealed to the surgeons until completion of preparation of the recipient bed by opaque envelopes. A central study registrar will perform patient registration.

Study locations will include academic centers and a practice-based research network in Italy, Germany, and Spain.

A single examiner, blind with respect to the treatment assignment, will perform all primary outcome measurements at each center. Trained personnel not involved with the surgical intervention will: i) administer patient questionnaires, ii) provide instructions and collect patient diaries. A single calibrated investigator with specific experience in using the specific score will centrally perform assessment of esthetic scores on standardized digital images.

A biostatistician blind with respect to treatment assignment will perform the analysis.

Interventions and Duration The two intervention groups will consist of surgery with connective tissue graft from the palate (standard of care control) and surgery with the application of Geistlich Fibro-Gide®. Experienced clinicians will deliver treatment consisting of root coverage surgery using coronally advanced flaps, the most utilized procedure for coverage of multiple recessions. Surgery will be standardized and the same procedures/materials will be employed to ensure consistency essentially as performed in the completed Mucograft study.

The total duration of the Followfollow-up of individual patients will be up to 1 year and extended to 3 years for the collection of long-term follow-up data.

Sample Size and Study Population Study population will consist of 160 subjects with a minimum of two adjacent RT1 and RT2 (with periodontal attachment <2 mm) recessions of the gingival margin (average 2.5 recessions per subject, of which one should be 3 mm or deeper) requiring surgical intervention for root coverage. Heavy smokers (>10 cigarette/day) will be excluded.

Conditions

Gingival Recession, Plastic Surgery

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Coronally Advanced Flap plus Collagen Matrix

Coronally Advanced Flap plus Collagen Matrix Tissue Substitute

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Volume stable collagen matrix

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Volume stable collagen matrix obtained from porcine collagen after proprietary cross-linking by device manufacturer

Coronally Advanced Flap plus Autologous Connective Tissue Graft

Current standard of care

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Autologous Connective Tissue Graft from the Hard Palate

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Autologous connective tissue surgically harvested from the hard palate and transplanted in the area of gingival recession

Interventions

Volume stable collagen matrix

Volume stable collagen matrix obtained from porcine collagen after proprietary cross-linking by device manufacturer

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Autologous Connective Tissue Graft from the Hard Palate

Autologous connective tissue surgically harvested from the hard palate and transplanted in the area of gingival recession

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Other Intervention Names

Fibrogide; CTG

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Male and female, 18 to 70 years of age, with a minimum of two adjacent teeth with gingival recession (at least one with a depth ≥ 3 mm - RT1 or RT2 with 2 mm or less of interdental periodontal attachment loss) in anterior and premolar teeth in the maxilla and requiring surgical intervention, without medical contraindications to elective surgery. In case of recessions on five or more adjacent teeth, the teeth at the external sides will not be included in the study.
• At least 2 mm marginal keratinized tissue width and irrespective of soft tissue thickness prior therapy. The study should involve treatment naïve patients in terms of root coverage procedures. Prior therapy should include treatment of gingival inflammation, if present, instructions in non-traumatic oral hygiene, and reconstruction of the cemento-enamel junction with adhesive dental materials in case of cervical abrasion or erosion involving this structure
• Evidence of subject ability to achieve good oral hygiene and control gingivitis in the whole of the dentition (FMPS<25% and FMBS<25%)
• Ability to understand study procedures and to comply with them for the entire length of the study. Ability and willingness to give written informed consent.

Exclusion Criteria

• Presence of untreated periodontitis
• Persistence of uncorrected gingival trauma from tooth brushing
• Interdental attachment loss greater than 2 mm or furcation involvement in the experimental teeth
• Presence of less than 2 mm of keratinized tissue width
• Presence of severe tooth malposition, rotation or clinically significant super-eruption
• Self reported current smoking exceeding 10 cigarettes/day or pipe or cigar smoking
• Rheumatoid arthritis or known sensitization to collagen based medical products.
• Presence of medical contraindications to elective surgery
• Participation in another interventional clinical trial
• Current drug or alcohol use or dependence that, in the opinion of the site investigator, would interfere with adherence to study requirements.
• Inability or unwillingness of individual to give written informed consent.
• Uncontrolled diabetes mellitus
• Allergy to collagen
• Pregnancy or lactation or sexually active female subjects who are of childbearing potential and who are not using hormonal or barrier methods of birth control (e.g., oral or parenteral contraceptives, diaphragm plus spermicide, condoms).
• Radiotherapy
• immunosuppressive therapy
• chronic steroid therapy (inhaler or systemic).

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 70 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

University of Florence

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Universitat Internacional de Catalunya

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Maurizio Tonetti

NETWORK

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Maurizio Tonetti

Executive Director

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Maurizio Tonetti, DMD PhD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

The European Research Group on Periodontology (ERGOPerio)

Locations

Ospedale Careggi

Florence, , Italy

Site Status: RECRUITING

International University of Catalunya

Barcelona, , Spain

Site Status: RECRUITING

Countries

Italy; Spain

Central Contacts

Maurizio Tonetti, DMD, PhD

Role: CONTACT

maurizio.tonetti@ergoperio.eu

393473289709

Luigi Barbato, DMD, PhD

Role: CONTACT

luigi.barbato@unifi.it

39-3299457556

Facility Contacts

Luigi Barbato, DMD PhD

Role: primary

luigi.barbato@unifi.it

39-3299457556

Francesco Cairo, DMD

Role: backup

Francesco.cairo@unifi.it

39-3392961343

Jose Nart, DMD PhD

Role: primary

jose@nartperiodoncia.com

34-626331060

Gonzalo Blasi, DMD

Role: backup

gonzaloblasi@uic.es

34-626331060

Other Identifiers

Fibroguide

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id