Relaxing Effects of Acupuncture, Sham Acupuncture or no Acupuncture

NCT ID: NCT03441698

Last Updated: 2018-03-29

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 363 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2013-09-30
• Study Completion Date: 2017-04-30

Brief Summary

Background: The communication between a patient and clinician may have significant effects on treatment outcomes and one likely mediator of the communication-related treatment effects is patient expectations, as demonstrated by placebo studies in various clinical domains. To investigate the link between patient-clinician interactions and patient expectancy in a clinical setting, acupuncture is suggested an effective method, as acupuncture is a procedure with known non-specific treatment components. As a scene for investigating the importance of expectations on treatment outcomes, the investigators used acupuncture for relaxation effects. It is commonly reported that participants experience a sense of relaxation during acupuncture treatment, yet, it is not known if the effects are related to the specific effects of needling or non-specific effects associated with the treatment procedure.

Aim: To investigate if communication type (positive or neutral) about the expected treatment outcome affected i) participants' expectations, ii) short-term relaxation effects in response to genuine or sham acupuncture or to rest, and to investigate if treatment expectations were related to outcome.

Procedure: Volunteers, i.e. Swedish individuals in general, not part of any specific patient group, are given written and oral study information and are screened for study criteria. The volunteers giving informed consent are randomized to one treatment session a´30 minutes with a) genuine acupuncture or b) sham acupuncture (telescopic non-penetrating needles).

They are compared to a non-randomized reference group that receive no acupuncture, just 30 minutes of rest.

Within the three groups, participants are randomized to 1) positive communication or 2) neutral communication from therapists, regarding expected treatment effects.

Outcome measures: Visual analogue scales (VAS) (0-100 millimeter) measured treatment expectations and relaxation, at baseline two hours before the treatment session, pre treatment (directly before the treatment session) and post treatment (directly after the treatment session). Heart rate, blood pressure, and salivary cortisol are measured pre and post treatment. Primary endpoint is change in relaxation pre to post treatment.

Detailed Description

Background: The communication between a patient and clinician may have significant effects on treatment outcomes and one likely mediator of the communication-related treatment effects is patient expectations, as demonstrated by placebo studies in various clinical domains. To investigate the link between patient-clinician interactions and patient expectancy in a clinical setting, acupuncture is suggested an effective method, as acupuncture is a procedure with known non-specific treatment components. As a scene for investigating the importance of expectations on treatment outcomes, the investigators used acupuncture for relaxation effects. It is commonly reported that participants experience a sense of relaxation during acupuncture treatment, yet, it is not known if the effects are related to the specific effects of needling or non-specific effects associated with the treatment procedure.

Aim: To investigate if communication type (positive or neutral) about the expected treatment outcome affected i) participants' expectations, ii) short-term relaxation effects in response to genuine or sham acupuncture or to rest, and to investigate if treatment expectations were related to outcome.

Procedure: Volunteers, i.e. Swedish individuals in general, not part of any specific patient group, are given written and oral study information and are screened for study criteria. The volunteers giving informed consent are blinded randomized, by use of a computerized random table, to one treatment session a´30 minutes with a) genuine manual acupuncture delivered to the traditional acupuncture point PC6 or b) sham acupuncture delivered to a sham acupuncture point at the double distance to the wrist compared to the PC6, using telescopic non-penetrating needles. The acupuncture treatments (genuine or sham) was given by one of nine physiotherapists.

They are compared to a non-randomized reference group that receive no acupuncture, just a treatment of 30 minutes of rest, given by one of three physiotherapists according to a standardized treatment protocol.

Within the three groups (genuine acupuncture, sham acupuncture or no acupuncture, just rest), the participants are randomized to 1) positive communication or 2) neutral communication from therapists according to a standardized treatment protocol, regarding expected treatment effects.

The participants are blinded to type of acupuncture and communication type. The investigator entering data is blinded to treatment type and communication type. The evaluator is blinded to treatment type and communication type.

Outcome measures: Visual analogue scales (VAS) (0-100 millimeter) measure treatment expectations and level of relaxation, muscle tensions and stress at baseline two hours before the treatment session, pre treatment (directly before the treatment session) and post treatment (directly after the treatment session). Heart rate, blood pressure, and salivary cortisol are measured pre and post treatment. Primary endpoint is change in level of relaxation pre to post treatment.

Conditions

Healthy Volunteers

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: FACTORIAL
• Primary Study Purpose: SUPPORTIVE_CARE
• Blinding Strategy: TRIPLE

Study Groups

Genuine acupuncture (A)

Genuine acupuncture (A) with neutral communication (A1) or positive communication (A2)

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Genuine acupuncture (A)

Intervention Type: DEVICE

A) Acupuncture is administered bilaterally to the acupuncture point PC6 located two body-inches proximal of the wrist crease, between the tendons of palmaris longus and flexor carpii radialis. Sharp acupuncture needles were inserted into a depth of a half body-inch. The needles are manipulated three times (at the start, middle and end of the treatment session) by twirling and lifting until deqi occurs. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Sham Acupuncture (B)

Sham acupuncture (B) with neutral communication (B1) or positive communication (B2)

Group Type: PLACEBO_COMPARATOR

Sham acupuncture (B)

Intervention Type: DEVICE

B) Sham acupuncture is administered bilaterally to a non-acupuncture point two body-inches proximal and one body-inch radial from PC6. The telescopic Park Sham Device was used. The needle looks identical to a real needle, but is blunt and glides upward into its handle instead of penetrating. The marking tubes holds the needle in place. The therapist give an illusion of manipulating the needle by turning it three times until it touched the skin, but no deqi occurs. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Rest (C)

Rest (C) with neutral communication (C1) or positive communication (C2)

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Rest

Intervention Type: OTHER

C) Rest means resting for 30 minutes, either sitting or lying down. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Interventions

Genuine acupuncture (A)

A) Acupuncture is administered bilaterally to the acupuncture point PC6 located two body-inches proximal of the wrist crease, between the tendons of palmaris longus and flexor carpii radialis. Sharp acupuncture needles were inserted into a depth of a half body-inch. The needles are manipulated three times (at the start, middle and end of the treatment session) by twirling and lifting until deqi occurs. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Sham acupuncture (B)

B) Sham acupuncture is administered bilaterally to a non-acupuncture point two body-inches proximal and one body-inch radial from PC6. The telescopic Park Sham Device was used. The needle looks identical to a real needle, but is blunt and glides upward into its handle instead of penetrating. The marking tubes holds the needle in place. The therapist give an illusion of manipulating the needle by turning it three times until it touched the skin, but no deqi occurs. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Rest

C) Rest means resting for 30 minutes, either sitting or lying down. Within the groups A, B and C, the participants are randomized to two communication types: 1) neutral communication or 2) strengthened positive communication regarding expected relaxing effects of their treatment, using a standardized communication model.

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• minimum age 18 years,
• physical, mental and linguistic capacity to give informed consent, e.g. understand Swedish

Exclusion Criteria

• previous education in acupuncture therapy, in terms of being an acupuncture therapist.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Linkoeping University

OTHER_GOV

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Västernorrland County Council, Sweden

OTHER_GOV

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Ylva Widgren

Study coordinator

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Anna E Enblom, PhD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

County council of Östergötland

Other Identifiers

Relaxation001

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id