Computerized PAINRelieveIt Protocol for Cancer Pain Control in Hospice

NCT ID: NCT02026115

Last Updated: 2025-09-15

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 262 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2014-01-31
• Study Completion Date: 2016-09-30

Brief Summary

The study purpose is to compare usual hospice care and PAINRelieveIt groups for effects on: (1) patient outcomes (analgesic adherence; worst pain intensity, satisfaction, and misconceptions) and lay caregiver outcome (pain misconceptions) in a diverse sample of 250 cancer patient-caregiver dyads receiving hospice care; and (2) nurse outcomes (obtained appropriate analgesics for patient) in a sample of hospice nurses. The investigators hypothesize that at posttest, controlling for pretest data and compared to the usual care group, the PAINRelieveIt group will: a) report decreased scores for worst pain intensity and pain misconceptions; b) have increased analgesic adherence (primary outcome); and c) have a larger proportion who report satisfaction with pain intensity and whose nurses obtained appropriate analgesics for the patients' pain.

Detailed Description

Unrelieved cancer pain at the end of life is a major health problem and is inconsistent with patient-centered goals for their last days. Building on a successful approach researched in outpatient oncology settings, the investigators propose a study testing PAINRelieveIt, a system-level intervention of computerized tools with patient-reported pain outcomes (in English, Spanish, Chinese languages), decision support for clinicians (English) and multimedia education tailored to each cancer patient and lay caregiver.

Using a 1-week pre-test/post-test randomized design in patients receiving home level hospice care provided by two Chicago-area hospices, we will compare effects of usual hospice care with PAINReportIt Summary and usual hospice care with PAINRelieveIt on pain outcomes. The tablet-based PAINRelieveIt includes valid and reliable pain tools (PAINReportIt), a summary of the patient's pain data with decision support for hospice nurses to obtain recommendations for algorithm-based analgesic therapies (PAINConsultN), and multimedia education tailored to the patient's and lay caregiver's pain management misconceptions (PainUCope). Patient's/caregiver's answers are automatically stored in an electronic database, from which the system generates a PAINReportIt Summary (usual hospice care control group); PAINConsultN and PainUCope (experimental group). All patients will receive usual hospice care. All patients/caregivers will complete PAINReportIt at pretest and 1-week later (posttest); patients also complete parts of PAINReportIt daily. Via daily e-mail updates, the control-group hospice nurses will receive a PAINReportIt Summary and experimental-group hospice nurses will receive a PAINConsultN. Additionally, experimental group patients/caregivers will view multimedia educational materials via PAINUCope to help patients report pain and adhere to prescribed analgesics.

Specific aims are to compare usual hospice care and PAINRelieveIt groups for effects on:

1. Patient outcomes (analgesic adherence; worst pain intensity, satisfaction, and misconceptions) and lay caregiver outcome (pain misconceptions) in a diverse sample of 250 cancer patient-caregiver dyads receiving hospice care.

2. Nurse outcomes (obtained appropriate analgesics for patient) in a sample of hospice nurses.

The investigators hypothesize that at posttest, controlling for pretest data and compared to the usual care group, the PAINRelieveIt group will: a) report decreased scores for worst pain intensity and pain misconceptions; b) have increased analgesic adherence (primary outcome); and c) have a larger proportion who report satisfaction with pain intensity and whose nurses obtained appropriate analgesics for the patients' pain.

Findings will guide future system-level research to implement PAINRelieveIt in a multi-site, longitudinal trial that will test the effect of disseminating this technology on clinical decisions for managing pain and patient/caregiver pain outcomes in a national sample of hospices. This approach offers improved pain control for dying patients and other populations.

Conditions

Cancer; Pain

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: SUPPORTIVE_CARE
• Blinding Strategy: TRIPLE

Study Groups

usual hospice care

The usual care group will receive the typical hospice care and interact with PAINReportIt to provide data necessary for the analysis of study aims. They will use the tablet computer at baseline and at the study end and daily between. They also will have access to what looks like PAINUCope, but is really computer games so that they have similar attention with the computer as the experimental group. For ethical purposes, we will provide a PAINReportIt Summary to their hospice nurses to have access to their pain assessment information, something we did not do in previous studies focused on efficacy of the interventions.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

PAINReportIt

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

PAINReportIt is a software program developed with an electronic McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ) and now includes questions about analgesics used by patients and a shortened version of the pain Barriers Questionnaire (BQ). It is designed as an interactive, touch screen way to assess pain. It can be self-administered and requires little or no patient computer experience and little or no provider time. The patient can read instructions on-screen and practice all types of selection responses found the program. Directions from the paper tools were modified to address the touch screen method of recording responses. The copyright is owned by Dr. Ronald Melzack for the MPQ and Dr. Sandra Ward for the BQ. Both individuals authorized the modifications, format, and computerized use of the tools.

PAINRelieveIt (experimental group)

We will use Nursing Consult LLC's PAINRelieveIt software that includes: (1) PAINReportIt that has screens to collect pain, medications, and misconception data; (2) the intervention for the nurse clinicians, PAINConsultN; and (3) the intervention for the patients and lay caregiver, PAINUCope. This innovative, new program is the first computerized, multi-dimensional, self-report measure of pain with clinician decision support for analgesic prescriptions and multimedia patient education tailored to the patient's misconceptions and pain. Prototype versions of PAINConsultN and PAINUCope were tested in recently completed studies among outpatients with cancer and patients with sickle cell disease in outpatient, emergency and hospital settings.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

PAINReportIt

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

PAINReportIt is a software program developed with an electronic McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ) and now includes questions about analgesics used by patients and a shortened version of the pain Barriers Questionnaire (BQ). It is designed as an interactive, touch screen way to assess pain. It can be self-administered and requires little or no patient computer experience and little or no provider time. The patient can read instructions on-screen and practice all types of selection responses found the program. Directions from the paper tools were modified to address the touch screen method of recording responses. The copyright is owned by Dr. Ronald Melzack for the MPQ and Dr. Sandra Ward for the BQ. Both individuals authorized the modifications, format, and computerized use of the tools.

PAINConsultN

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

PAINConsultN for hospice nurses. Our previous studies support the feasibility and clinical effect of PAINConsultN. This narrative and graphic tool provides decision support for the nurse's clinical decisions regarding management of the patient's pain. Based on the PAINReportIt output and published cancer pain guidelines, PAINConsultN generates an algorithm-based consultation report with a list of recommendations that could be useful to provide improved pain relief. If the patient's PAINReportIt output indicates the pain level is consistent with the patient's goals for pain management and represents no pain or a mild pain level, the consultation report acknowledges the therapy plan and reinforces its consistency with pain guidelines.

PAINUCope

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

We tested the PAINUCope piece of the intervention in 3 completed studies. PAINUCope is a multimedia, computer generated tool that gives tailored information to overcome patients' misconceptions about pain and help them engage in activities that help reduce their pain. PAINUCope focuses on 2 crucial aspects of pain management: 1) reporting cancer pain and 2) safe and effective use of pain medicines. The educational materials are written at a 6th grade reading level and presented as 21st Century best-practices, evidence-based facts or scripts for the person with cancer or sickle cell disease (in one study). The facts or scripts are customized to the patient's need for this type of health information. The patient's responses on PAINReportIt guide the specific information shared via PAINUCope.

Interventions

PAINReportIt

PAINReportIt is a software program developed with an electronic McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ) and now includes questions about analgesics used by patients and a shortened version of the pain Barriers Questionnaire (BQ). It is designed as an interactive, touch screen way to assess pain. It can be self-administered and requires little or no patient computer experience and little or no provider time. The patient can read instructions on-screen and practice all types of selection responses found the program. Directions from the paper tools were modified to address the touch screen method of recording responses. The copyright is owned by Dr. Ronald Melzack for the MPQ and Dr. Sandra Ward for the BQ. Both individuals authorized the modifications, format, and computerized use of the tools.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

PAINConsultN

PAINConsultN for hospice nurses. Our previous studies support the feasibility and clinical effect of PAINConsultN. This narrative and graphic tool provides decision support for the nurse's clinical decisions regarding management of the patient's pain. Based on the PAINReportIt output and published cancer pain guidelines, PAINConsultN generates an algorithm-based consultation report with a list of recommendations that could be useful to provide improved pain relief. If the patient's PAINReportIt output indicates the pain level is consistent with the patient's goals for pain management and represents no pain or a mild pain level, the consultation report acknowledges the therapy plan and reinforces its consistency with pain guidelines.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

PAINUCope

We tested the PAINUCope piece of the intervention in 3 completed studies. PAINUCope is a multimedia, computer generated tool that gives tailored information to overcome patients' misconceptions about pain and help them engage in activities that help reduce their pain. PAINUCope focuses on 2 crucial aspects of pain management: 1) reporting cancer pain and 2) safe and effective use of pain medicines. The educational materials are written at a 6th grade reading level and presented as 21st Century best-practices, evidence-based facts or scripts for the person with cancer or sickle cell disease (in one study). The facts or scripts are customized to the patient's need for this type of health information. The patient's responses on PAINReportIt guide the specific information shared via PAINUCope.

Intervention Type: BEHAVIORAL

Other Intervention Names

PAINRelieveIt's PAINReportIt; PAINRelieveIt's PANConsultN; PAINRelieveIt's PAINUCope

Eligibility Criteria

Exclusion Criteria

• Patients and lay caregivers will be excluded if they: (1) are legally blind or deaf; or (2) have cognitive or physical impairments making it impossible to communicate or to complete study instruments at enrollment or any time during the study.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

JourneyCare Home Health & Hospice

UNKNOWN

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Rainbow Hospice

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

University of Illinois at Chicago

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Diana J. Wilkie

Adjunct Professor

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Principal Investigators

Diana J Wilkie, PhD

Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

University of Illinois at Chicago

Other Identifiers

IH-1304-6553

Identifier Type: OTHER_GRANT

Identifier Source: secondary_id

2013-0986

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id