Comparative Effects Of Exergaming And Otago Exercise On Anticipatory Postural Control And Sensory Integration In Older Adults

NCT ID: NCT07308353

Last Updated: 2025-12-29

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: ACTIVE_NOT_RECRUITING
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 36 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2025-11-18
• Study Completion Date: 2026-07-01

Brief Summary

This study explores whether non-immersive, interactive Exergaming using Xbox Kinect can go beyond conventional exercise by actively training the brain and body to react faster, balance smarter, and move more confidently. Through dynamic games like Reflex Ridge and 20,000 Leaks, we aim to stimulate internal perturbations and real-time Sensory Integration, something Otago doesn't directly target.

In this randomized controlled trial, 36 older adults (aged 55+) will be assigned to either the Exergaming or Otago group. Both groups will receive 6 weeks of supervised balance training (3x/week, 30 mins/session). Primary outcomes include Sensory Integration, measured using modified Clinical Test of Sensory Interaction and Balance (mCTSIB) and Anticipatory postural control assessed through Limits of Stability (LOS) test. Timed up and Go (TUG) will capture functional mobility, which will serve as the secondary outcome in this study.

Both mCTSIB and LOS will be administered using the Postural Stability System of Biodex, a reliable and valid computerized platform designed to objectively quantify postural control under varying sensory conditions.

With evidence-based outcome tools and rigorous analysis, this project doesn't just aim to compare two programs, it's about challenging tradition, modernizing rehab, and making balance training smarter, safer, and more engaging for the elders we serve.

This research could be a leap forward in community-based fall prevention and a step toward a more responsive, personalized future in Neurological Rehabilitation.

Detailed Description

Falls are the second leading cause of unintentional injury-related deaths globally and pose as a major public health issue, especially for older individuals. Elderly population experience difficulties in switching quickly between various reliable sensory inputs, which increases risk of falls and injuries. Balance and gait disorders are among the most common causes associated with falls in older individuals. Age-related declines in Sensory Integration and Anticipatory balance responses are one of the leading contributors to falls in older adults.

Rogers et al. in 2021 conducted the only identified head-to-head feasibility RCT directly comparing exergaming interventions with the Otago Exercise Program (OEP) in older adults. This mixed method study establishes the foundational evidence that exergaming and Otago exercise demonstrate comparable clinical benefits on functional balance measures, while identifying need for more detailed comparative studies using objective instrumented measures like Postural Stability System of Biodex.

Chen et al. conducted a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis in 2021. This meta-analytic evidence establishes a strong foundation supporting the hypothesis that exergaming interventions can outperform conventional exercise approaches on objective postural control metrics, directly informing the rationale for comparative effectiveness studies examining exergaming versus established fall-prevention programs like the Otago Exercise Program.

The Otago Exercise Program (OEP) is a promising intervention for preventing falls, thereby improving balance and gait. Previous studies reported improved effects on balance using the OEP conducted in a group setting. In 2022 Khumpaneid et al., conducted a study aimed to investigate the effects of a modified-OEP on four components of actual balance (static, dynamic, proactive, and reactive balance) and perceived balance in healthy older adults aged 60-85 years old. The modified-OEP group showed significant improvement in the four components of actual balance and in perceived balance.

The study conducted by Sápi et al., in 2021 aimed to evaluate whether Kinect exergame balance training could beneficially impact sensory reweighting in women over 60 years old. 14 healthy women participated in a single-group pretest/posttest/follow-up usability study. Participants engaged in Kinect for Xbox 360 console games three times a week, for 30 minutes per session, over a 6-week period (18 visits in total). This usability study provides evidence that Kinect exergaming can be a valuable intervention for improving balance and reducing fall risk in older women by enhancing mediolateral stability and sensory reweighting. This implies that the Exergaming may have improved proprioceptive function by providing visual feedback and challenging motor skills.

Pacheco et al., in 2020 conducted a research aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of exergames in improving mobility and balance among older adults without neurological conditions. Exergames led to significant improvements in mobility, as evidenced by better performance on the TUG. The study also found that older adults generally adhered well to exergame programs, with reported adherence rates of up to 100% in some trials.

In this study participants will be randomly allocated in 2 groups, A and B. Each group will contain 18 participants.

Group A will receive Otago Exercise Program Group B will receive treatment through Xbox Exergaming. Otago Exercise Program (OEP) consist of 5 Strengthening Exercises , 12 Progressive Balance Exercises and Walking Training (as tolerated).

Non-immersive exergaming using the Xbox Kinect system, designed to engage multisensory balance responses, anticipatory postural adjustments, and internal perturbation mechanisms through gamified movement. Games Include: 20,000 Leaks, Reflex Ridge , River Rush, Rally Ball.

It is imperative to explore and compare the efficacy of Xbox Kinect-based exergaming versus the Otago Exercise Program in improving sensory integration and anticipatory postural control in older adults. By addressing this research gap, the current study aims to contribute novel insights into the development of more responsive, engaging, and relevant balance interventions for the aging population.

Conditions

Exergaming; Exercise Therapy; Frail Elderly; Healthy Aging; Mobility Limitation; Muscle Strength; Postural Balance; Proprioception

Keywords

Exergaming; Exercise Therapy; Frail Elderly; Healthy Aging; Mobility limitation; Muscle Strength; Postural Balance; Proprioception

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

Otago Exercise Program

Strengthening exercises

1. Knee extensor (front knee strength)

2. Knee flexor (Back knee strength)

3. Hip abductor (side hip strength)

4. Ankle plantarflexors (calf raises)

5. Ankle dorsiflexors (toe raises) Balance retraining exercises

1. Knee bends 2. Backwards walking 3. Walking and turning around 4. Sideways walking 5. Tandem stance (Heel toe stand) 6. Tandem walk (heel toe walk) 7. One leg stand 8. Heel walking 9. Toe walk 10. Heel toe walking backwards 11. sit to stand 12. Stair walking

Levels:

LEVEL A 10 repetitions Hold support LEVEL B 10 repetitions, no support or 10 repetitions, hold support, repeat LEVEL C 10 repetitions No support, repeat LEVEL D 3 x 10 repetitions No support

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Otago Exercise Program

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

It will consist of 5 Strengthening Exercises, 12 Progressive Balance Exercises and Walking Training (as tolerated). Protocol will include 3 sessions per week 30 minutes per session for total of 6 weeks Strength exercises will be progressed by increasing repetitions, weight, or duration. Balance tasks will be made challenging by reducing upper limb support, altering base of support, or eyes closing. Progression will be adjusted weekly based on performance and comfort.

All sessions will be delivered under physiotherapist supervision using the official OEP manual.

Exergaming

Games Included:

20,000 Leaks - multi-directional reaching, internal perturbations Reflex Ridge - anticipatory jumping, ducking, trunk-limb coordination River Rush - dynamic weight shifting, lateral stepping Rally Ball - anticipatory posture control, bilateral upper limb coordination Levels: Basic, Intermediate and Advance

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Exergaming

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

This intervention involves non-immersive exergaming using the Xbox Kinect system.

Games Included are 20,000 Leaks, Reflex Ridge, River Rush and Rally Ball. Games will be played 3 times per week for 30 minutes for total of 6 weeks. Three difficulty levels include Basic, Intermediate and Advance. Progression based on participant performance, game scores (gold/silver pins, stars), and therapist observation. For first three weeks 2/3 Game Plays and last three weeks there will be 4/5 game plays.

Sessions will be supervised one-on-one by a physiotherapist. Participant performance, fatigue, and safety will be monitored throughout the session.

Interventions

Otago Exercise Program

It will consist of 5 Strengthening Exercises, 12 Progressive Balance Exercises and Walking Training (as tolerated). Protocol will include 3 sessions per week 30 minutes per session for total of 6 weeks Strength exercises will be progressed by increasing repetitions, weight, or duration. Balance tasks will be made challenging by reducing upper limb support, altering base of support, or eyes closing. Progression will be adjusted weekly based on performance and comfort.

All sessions will be delivered under physiotherapist supervision using the official OEP manual.

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Exergaming

This intervention involves non-immersive exergaming using the Xbox Kinect system.

Games Included are 20,000 Leaks, Reflex Ridge, River Rush and Rally Ball. Games will be played 3 times per week for 30 minutes for total of 6 weeks. Three difficulty levels include Basic, Intermediate and Advance. Progression based on participant performance, game scores (gold/silver pins, stars), and therapist observation. For first three weeks 2/3 Game Plays and last three weeks there will be 4/5 game plays.

Sessions will be supervised one-on-one by a physiotherapist. Participant performance, fatigue, and safety will be monitored throughout the session.

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Age ≥ 55 years
• Both Genders
• Ambulatory, community-dwelling
• Able to stand unassisted >1 min
• TUG ≤ 13.5 s
• Able to understand and follow command

Exclusion Criteria

• Diagnosed vestibular and neurological conditions affecting balance
• Orthopedic Conditions i.e., Recent fractures or surgeries, cervical spine issues or severe OA
• Severe visual or auditory deficits
• Use of Assistive device
• Currently enrolled in any other balance or exercise program

• Minimum Eligible Age: 55 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Foundation University Islamabad

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Responsibility Role: SPONSOR

Locations

Foundation University College of Physical Therapy

Islamabad, , Pakistan

Countries

Pakistan

Other Identifiers

FUI/CTR/2025/14

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id