Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation on Singer's Voice

NCT ID: NCT06612528

Last Updated: 2024-09-25

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: ENROLLING_BY_INVITATION
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 30 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2024-03-11
• Study Completion Date: 2025-06-20

Brief Summary

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) can be used to temporarily and reversibly modulate brain functions and is an increasingly utilized tool to investigate the relationships between brain and behavior. This study aimed to identify the effects of tDCS on vocal quality, vocal range, neuromotor functioning of the larynx and self-reported vocal effort in vocally healthy singers. This is a triple-blinded, sham-controlled, randomized clinical trial. The participants will be randomized to one of the three tDCS groups (primary motor cortex, cerebellum or sham). In each group a voice training will be applied at the same tDCS time. The three groups are: (i) cerebellum; (ii) primary motor cortex (M1); (iii) sham. The tDCS parameters in the active groups are anodal - 2mA for 20 minutes, at the sham group the stimuli are finished 30 secondes before starting. Volunteers will pass for 10 intervention days and they will be evaluated for vocal performance before the sessions, in the day 5 of intervention, the last day of intervention (day 10) and 1 month later for follow up evaluation. Voice recordings will be take to assess the following vocal parameters: vocal range profile (VRP) at weak and strong intensities; vocal quality (jitter, shimmer, irregularity, glottal-to-noise excitation ratio, and dysphonia acoustic index) at weak, habitual, and strong intensities; laryngeal diadochokinesis, and self-reported vocal effort using the adapted Borg CR10 scale.

Detailed Description

Data collection is being conducted at the Applied Neuroscience Laboratory (LANA) of the Federal University of Pernambuco (UFPE). Videolaryngoscopy is performed at the UFPE Hospital, in the laryngology outpatient clinic.

This phase of the study includes vocally healthy individuals who are singers without formal music or singing training. Residents of the city of Recife and the Metropolitan Region, aged 18 to 45 years. The age range was chosen considering the period of maximum vocal efficiency To determine the sample size, in phase 2, a pilot study was conducted with 15 participants that will serve as a parameter for sample size calculation. This will be done using the G*Power 3.1 program, considering a statistical power (β) of 80% and a significance level (α) of 5%. For this analysis, the primary vocal outcome variables (vocal range profile) will be considered, and the sample size will be considered the largest value among the selected outcomes.

Singers without formal music training and without vocal complaints are included. In order to assess vocal health, all singers underwent videolaryngoscopy, performed by an otolaryngologist. After the exam, subjects are selected who, according to the otolaryngologist's report, presented functional anatomical and physiological conditions. Individuals with minimal structural alterations (MSA) will not be excluded, as long as the glottal closure is complete and with regular glottal vibration on stroboscopy.

Individuals who are smokers or who present signs and symptoms of laryngeal, pharyngeal or respiratory diseases at the time of data collection are excluded from the sample. Volunteers who use neuroactive medications regularly, have metal implants in the cervical region or above, and have any history of seizures or epilepsy will also be excluded.

The sample of singers is being constituted by convenience through individuals who are singers without vocal complaints of both sexes, recruited through advertisements in electronic media. The first contact with the volunteers is through a screening to verify the eligibility criteria.

The same data collection instruments from phase 1 are used in phase 2 of this study. Added to this is the vocal exercise, performed with the aid of a silicone tube with the following dimensions: 35cm in length, 1cm in diameter and 2mm in thickness, and with the distal end immersed at a distance of 3cm from the bottom of a 500ml plastic bottle containing 2/3 of water and with the spaces delimited. This study seeks to investigate the combined effects of tDCS and vocal exercises on singers' voices. We will conduct a clinical trial to examine the impact of concurrent neuromodulation and vocal training. Anodal tDCS will be applied at 2mA for 20 minutes to three groups: (i) M1; (ii) Cerebellum; and (iii) sham. All groups will also perform vocal exercises using a flexible tube (FT) for a total of 12 minutes. Participants will complete an adverse effects questionnaire after each session to report any discomfort. Vocal assessment is performed before the intervention to obtain results on vocal parameters, vocal range profile, and vocal effort, as well as on the 5th day after the start of the intervention, on the 10th day, and 1 month after the end of the activities. The entire assessment procedure is being performed as described in phase 1 of this study, only the request for the vocal task to assess perceived effort is different in the phase 2 singers. In this case, the participants answered the same Borg CR 10-BR scale questionnaire - adapted for vocal effort to assess the singers' self-perception of the proposed tasks, however, the singers are instructed to report the intensity of the effort produced during the singing task of a song of their choice, according to their self-perceived difficulty.

In order to determine the volunteers who would be in each group, and for subsequent sample size calculation, a randomization was performed for 15 volunteers, by an external researcher, using a random table and adjusted to allow for counterbalancing Codes were assigned to the groups, which were kept in opaque and numbered envelopes, available only to the person responsible for applying the tDCS. In this way, the evaluator, the therapist responsible for the vocal technique with a flexible tube immersed in water, and the singer remain "blind" to the type of stimulation to which the participants are subjected. After performing the sample size calculation, a new randomization will be performed to allocate the participants who will continue in the data collection to complete the number of necessary volunteers.

The participants are allocated into three groups, namely: (i) M1; (ii) Cerebellum; (ii) sham. In all groups, 10 consecutive sessions of anodal tDCS associated with vocal exercise are performed, these only do not occur on weekends. For the application of tDCS in the groups: (i) M1, the stimulation electrode (anode) is positioned over C5 (international 10-20 EEG system) with the cathode (negative pole) positioned over the contralateral supraorbital region; (ii) Cerebellum, the stimulation electrode over the cerebellar cortex (inion, slightly to the right) and the reference electrode (cathode) is positioned over the right deltoid muscle; (ii) sham, the montage equivalent to cerebellar stimulation is performed, however in the sham stimulation there is an interruption of the stimulation 30 seconds after the start, thus the current intensity drops to zero mA, but the electrodes remained on the scalp of the volunteers until the end of the vocal exercise. The exercise with FT is performed for a total of 20 minutes (3 minutes of FT, four sequences, followed by 2 minutes of interval) in all groups. In the sham group, the electrodes are only removed after the end of the vocal exercises, so that the patient is unaware of the type of stimulation (real or sham) to which they were exposed. To blind the evaluator and therapist, a towel is placed over the volunteer's head every day. Participants were instructed to sit comfortably while electrodes were placed on their scalp and tDCS stimulation was initiated. Following stimulation, participants performed vocal exercises using a flexible tube. The exercise involved producing sustained /u/ vowels in ascending and descending scales, tailored to each participant's vocal range (soprano, mezzo-soprano, contralto, tenor, baritone, or bass). These scales were based on pre-recorded piano accompaniments.

The flexible tube was 35 cm long, 1 cm in diameter, and 2 mm thick. One end of the tube was submerged 3 cm into a 500 ml bottle filled with water. Participants produced four sets of vocal exercises, each lasting 3 minutes, with 2-minute rests between sets, totaling 20 minutes of vocal therapy. This ensured that the vocal exercises concluded simultaneously with the tDCS session. Voice recordings will be take to assess the following vocal parameters: vocal range profile (VRP) at weak and strong intensities; vocal quality (jitter, shimmer, irregularity, glottal-to-noise excitation ratio, and dysphonia acoustic index) at weak, habitual, and strong intensities; laryngeal diadochokinesis, and self-reported vocal effort using the adapted Borg CR10 scale. This research was conducted in accordance with the ethical guidelines established by Brazil's National Health Council (Resolution 466/12). The study was approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee of UFPE's Health Sciences Center (number 5.758.856). Participants provided written informed consent after being fully informed about the study's objectives, procedures, potential risks, and benefits.

While the study posed minimal risks, participants might experience mild side effects from tDCS, such as tingling, itching, or burning sensations at the electrode sites. These side effects were carefully monitored. Additionally, some participants might experience discomfort during videolaryngoscopy or vocal exercises. However, these issues were addressed promptly.

Participants benefited from receiving guidance on vocal health and a personalized flexible tube. Data collected from vocal assessment software will be stored securely for at least 5 years. All data collected using Vocalgrama and VoxMetria software were analyzed using the respective software. In Vocalgrama, the following outcome measures were extracted: minimum and maximum fundamental frequency (f0), f0 range, st range, minimum and maximum intensity, and area of the vocal range profile. In VoxMetria, the following measures were extracted: jitter, shimmer, noise-to-harmonic ratio (NHR), and average perturbation quotient (APQ) from a 6-second sustained /ε/ vowel, excluding the first and last seconds. Audio recordings were made at a sampling rate of 44 kHz and 16-bit resolution. VoxMetria was also used to count the number of peaks in diadochokinetic tasks. Perceived effort was assessed using the Borg CR 10-BR scale adapted for vocal effort.

Data normality will be assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test. The ANOVA repeated mensures will be applied between the times of evaluation. All analyses will be performed using SPSS (version 26.0, SPSS Inc, Chicago, USA) with a significance level of 5%.

Conditions

Voice; Voice Range Profile; Voice Quality

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: QUADRUPLE

Study Groups

M1 and vocal exercise

anodal tDCS over primary motor cortex associated with the vocal exercise using the flexible tube in water.

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

tDCS

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The tDCS is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique. In this study, we used an intensity of 2mA for 20 minutes in two different areas.

M1 group: the anode was over C5 (10-10 EEG system) and the cathode was placed over Fp2. For the Cerebellum group stimulation, the targeted anode area was 2 cm below the inion and the cathode over the deltoid muscle.

Flexible tube in water

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The exercise involved producing sustained /u/ vowels in ascending and descending scales, tailored to each participants vocal range.

The flexible tube was 35 cm long, 1 cm in diameter, and 2 mm thick. One end of the tube was submerged 3 cm into a 500 ml bottle filled with water. Participants produced four sets of vocal exercises, each lasting 3 minutes, with 2-minute rests between sets, totaling 20 minutes of vocal therapy.

Cerebellum and vocal exercise

anodal tDCS over cerebellum associated with the vocal exercise using the flexible tube in water.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

tDCS

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The tDCS is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique. In this study, we used an intensity of 2mA for 20 minutes in two different areas.

M1 group: the anode was over C5 (10-10 EEG system) and the cathode was placed over Fp2. For the Cerebellum group stimulation, the targeted anode area was 2 cm below the inion and the cathode over the deltoid muscle.

Flexible tube in water

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The exercise involved producing sustained /u/ vowels in ascending and descending scales, tailored to each participants vocal range.

The flexible tube was 35 cm long, 1 cm in diameter, and 2 mm thick. One end of the tube was submerged 3 cm into a 500 ml bottle filled with water. Participants produced four sets of vocal exercises, each lasting 3 minutes, with 2-minute rests between sets, totaling 20 minutes of vocal therapy.

Sham and vocal exercise

tDCS sham associated with the vocal exercise using the flexible tube in water.

Group Type: PLACEBO_COMPARATOR

tDCS

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The tDCS is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique. In this study, we used an intensity of 2mA for 20 minutes in two different areas.

M1 group: the anode was over C5 (10-10 EEG system) and the cathode was placed over Fp2. For the Cerebellum group stimulation, the targeted anode area was 2 cm below the inion and the cathode over the deltoid muscle.

Flexible tube in water

Intervention Type: DEVICE

The exercise involved producing sustained /u/ vowels in ascending and descending scales, tailored to each participants vocal range.

The flexible tube was 35 cm long, 1 cm in diameter, and 2 mm thick. One end of the tube was submerged 3 cm into a 500 ml bottle filled with water. Participants produced four sets of vocal exercises, each lasting 3 minutes, with 2-minute rests between sets, totaling 20 minutes of vocal therapy.

Interventions

tDCS

The tDCS is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique. In this study, we used an intensity of 2mA for 20 minutes in two different areas.

M1 group: the anode was over C5 (10-10 EEG system) and the cathode was placed over Fp2. For the Cerebellum group stimulation, the targeted anode area was 2 cm below the inion and the cathode over the deltoid muscle.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Flexible tube in water

The exercise involved producing sustained /u/ vowels in ascending and descending scales, tailored to each participants vocal range.

The flexible tube was 35 cm long, 1 cm in diameter, and 2 mm thick. One end of the tube was submerged 3 cm into a 500 ml bottle filled with water. Participants produced four sets of vocal exercises, each lasting 3 minutes, with 2-minute rests between sets, totaling 20 minutes of vocal therapy.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Other Intervention Names

transcranial direct current stimulation; Lax vox; Flexible tube

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Vocally healthy singers without formal singing education

Exclusion Criteria

• Participants will be excluded from the sample if they were smokers, had abnormalities in previous otorhinolaryngological examination, or exhibited signs and symptoms of laryngeal, pharyngeal, or respiratory diseases at the time of collection. Volunteers who regularly used neuroactive medications, had metallic implants in the cervical region or above, or had any history of seizures or epilepsy will also be excluded.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 45 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico

OTHER_GOV

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

Universidade Federal de Pernambuco

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Kátia Monte-Silva

Phd

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Locations

Universidade Federal de Pernambuco

Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil

Countries

Brazil

Other Identifiers

5.758.856

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id