Trial Outcomes & Findings for Universal vs. Targeted School Screening for Adolescent Major Depressive Disorder (NCT NCT03716869)

NCT ID: NCT03716869

Last Updated: 2024-01-11

Results Overview

Universal 1) Adolescents with PHQ-9 score \>10 or who at any point in the year exhibit behavior concerning for MDD prompting a SAP triage request (PHQ-9 score: min 0, max 27, higher scores=greater depression symptoms), 2) Adolescents identified with MDD by SAP triage, and 3) Adolescents who successfully engage with at least one SAP recommendation. Prior Sept-Nov screening adjusted per school preference. Targeted 1\) Adolescents with behavior concerning for MDD prompting a SAP triage request, 2) Adolescents identified with MDD by SAP triage, and 3) Adolescents who successfully engage with at least one SAP recommendation Concern for MDD based on a primary or secondary potentially MDD related SAP "incoming referral reason" SAP triage is not diagnostic, so MDD identified based on recommendations for MDD related school or community services (e.g. mental health treatment services) HRSA funds mostly rural schools (all rural but one school) and PCORI funds urban schools

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

NA

Target enrollment

12909 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

up to 9 months

Results posted on

2024-01-11

Participant Flow

Letters sent to parents or guardians before screening detailed the project and screening instrument, the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), and offered the opportunity to opt their student out of the study. Out of 13,171 students, 262 opted out.

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for major depressive disorder (MDD; raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to Student Assistance Program (SAP) triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive major depressive disorder (MDD) screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Overall Study
STARTED
6436
6473
Overall Study
COMPLETED
6436
6473
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
0
0

Reasons for withdrawal

Withdrawal data not reported

Baseline Characteristics

Universal vs. Targeted School Screening for Adolescent Major Depressive Disorder

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Total
n=12909 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Age, Continuous
16 years
n=93 Participants
16 years
n=4 Participants
16 years
n=27 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
2941 Participants
n=93 Participants
3005 Participants
n=4 Participants
5946 Participants
n=27 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
3495 Participants
n=93 Participants
3468 Participants
n=4 Participants
6963 Participants
n=27 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Hispanic (any race)
1266 Participants
n=93 Participants
1421 Participants
n=4 Participants
2687 Participants
n=27 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Non-Hispanic Black
1571 Participants
n=93 Participants
1320 Participants
n=4 Participants
2891 Participants
n=27 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Non-Hispanic White
2857 Participants
n=93 Participants
2985 Participants
n=4 Participants
5842 Participants
n=27 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Other or multiple races
742 Participants
n=93 Participants
747 Participants
n=4 Participants
1489 Participants
n=27 Participants
Region of Enrollment
United States
6436 participants
n=93 Participants
6473 participants
n=4 Participants
12909 participants
n=27 Participants
Grade
9th
2430 Participants
n=93 Participants
1531 Participants
n=4 Participants
3961 Participants
n=27 Participants
Grade
10th
1048 Participants
n=93 Participants
2106 Participants
n=4 Participants
3154 Participants
n=27 Participants
Grade
11th
1932 Participants
n=93 Participants
1051 Participants
n=4 Participants
2983 Participants
n=27 Participants
Grade
12th
1026 Participants
n=93 Participants
1785 Participants
n=4 Participants
2811 Participants
n=27 Participants
Urban/rural
Urban
5728 Participants
n=93 Participants
5735 Participants
n=4 Participants
11463 Participants
n=27 Participants
Urban/rural
Rural
708 Participants
n=93 Participants
738 Participants
n=4 Participants
1446 Participants
n=27 Participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Universal 1) Adolescents with PHQ-9 score \>10 or who at any point in the year exhibit behavior concerning for MDD prompting a SAP triage request (PHQ-9 score: min 0, max 27, higher scores=greater depression symptoms), 2) Adolescents identified with MDD by SAP triage, and 3) Adolescents who successfully engage with at least one SAP recommendation. Prior Sept-Nov screening adjusted per school preference. Targeted 1\) Adolescents with behavior concerning for MDD prompting a SAP triage request, 2) Adolescents identified with MDD by SAP triage, and 3) Adolescents who successfully engage with at least one SAP recommendation Concern for MDD based on a primary or secondary potentially MDD related SAP "incoming referral reason" SAP triage is not diagnostic, so MDD identified based on recommendations for MDD related school or community services (e.g. mental health treatment services) HRSA funds mostly rural schools (all rural but one school) and PCORI funds urban schools

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) Composite: Positive Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9; Universal Arm) or MDD Concern Prompting Student Assistance Program (SAP) Referral, Confirmed MDD Symptoms by SAP, Engage With One SAP Recommended Service/Treatment
35 Participants
80 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Universal screening arm: Adolescents with PHQ-9 score \>10 or who at any point in the year exhibit behavior concerning for MDD prompting a self or collateral request for SAP triage (PHQ-9 score: min 0, max 27, higher scores=greater depression symptoms) Targeted screening arm: Adolescents with behavior concerning for MDD which prompts self or collateral request for SAP triage at any point during the school year. Concern for MDD is based on a primary or secondary potentially MDD related SAP "incoming referral reason".

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
MDD Screen Positive/Concern: Adolescents Who Screen Positive for MDD Either by PHQ-9 (Universal Screening Arm Only) or by Concern for MDD Prompting a Request for SAP Triage
200 Participants
1026 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Universal screening arm: PHQ-9 positive response to question #9 re: suicidal thoughts, which requires management by the state-mandated school crisis plan or student self or collateral report of suicidal thoughts, which requires management by the state-mandated school crisis plan (source school district). Targeted screening arm: Student self or collateral report of suicidal thoughts, which requires management by the state-mandated school crisis plan (source school district). Any student suicide attempts or completed suicides shared with the school district will also be included.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Suicidal Adolescent
96 Participants
622 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Universal and targeted screening arms: Adolescents who are identified as having MDD symptoms in need of follow-up based on triage by the school SAP team. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identified will be based on SAP recommendations for school or community services which are MDD related (e.g. mental health treatment services).

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
MDD Identification: Adolescents Confirmed With MDD Symptoms in Need of Follow-up Based on Triage by the School SAP Team
64 Participants
233 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Universal and targeted screening arms: Adolescents who successfully engage with at least one SAP recommendation. This may be fulfilled by parental report that an appointment was successfully scheduled.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6436 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=6473 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
MDD Treatment Engagement: Successful Engagement With at Least One SAP Recommendation
35 Participants
80 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Population: Information was obtained from one of the participating schools in the 2018-2019 school year. The following year saw the start of the COVID-19 pandemic (2019-2020). It was ultimately decided obtaining this secondary, grade level information was a lower priority compared to the primary outcome. Data from this one school is reported, but no further analysis was conducted.

data aggregate by grade level only schools currently track the number of student policy violations (e.g. for drug and alcohol, violence) and student suspensions

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=36 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=33 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Student School Policy Violations and Suspensions Based on School District Data
3 Participants
1 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Population: Information was obtained from one of the participating schools in the 2018-2019 school year. The following year saw the start of the COVID-19 pandemic (2019-2020). It was ultimately decided obtaining this secondary, grade level information was a lower priority compared to the primary outcome. Data from this one school is reported, but no further analysis was conducted.

data aggregate by grade level only

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=6480 Eligible days=180 school days x #student
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=5940 Eligible days=180 school days x #student
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Missed School Days
495 absences
358 absences

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Population: Information was obtained from one of the participating schools in the 2018-2019 school year. The following year saw the start of the COVID-19 pandemic (2019-2020). It was ultimately decided obtaining this secondary, grade level information was a lower priority compared to the primary outcome. Data from this one school is reported as summed gpa by grades randomized to each arm, but no further analysis was conducted.

data aggregate by grade level only

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=8 summed max gpa (4.0) per grade/arm
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=8 summed max gpa (4.0) per grade/arm
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Grade Point Average (Gpa)
6.2 total summed gpa per grade in each arm
5.2 total summed gpa per grade in each arm

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Population: Information obtained from one school in the 2018-2019 school year. The following year was the COVID-19 pandemic (2019-2020). It was decided obtaining this secondary, grade level information was a lower priority versus the primary outcome. For this single school all students advanced to the next grade level. Cell counts are low and reporting raw numbers would allow identification of the school, so the information is provided as a percentage.

data aggregate by grade level only Note: The clinical trials record previously included additional secondary outcome measures for the Keystone testing and SAT/ACT testing. However, as these data were only received from one school, and these tests are only given in specific grades, reporting these outcomes would require disclosure of the number of students in specific grades at this school. This level of detail could allow specific school identification, and the variables were removed.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=36 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=33 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Grade Advancement/Graduation: This Measure Represents the Percent of Students Promoted in Each Grade for the School (Grades 9-12, School District Data)
100 % of students
100 % of students

OTHER_PRE_SPECIFIED outcome

Timeframe: up to 9 months

Sex (Male, Female), Ethnicity, Race, Rural/Urban

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)
n=2941 Participants
Students randomized to the targeted screening arm will complete their routine school-based health screenings. Students will be followed through the academic year for referrals to the Student Assistance Program (SAP). SAP currently exists in all Pennsylvania (PA) schools and functions like a triage service. If a student exhibits behavior concerning for MDD (raised by any contact, e.g. teachers, nurse, parent, peer, or even self-referral), SAP will triage the student and based on the initial assessment provide recommendations for school or community-based services.
Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)
n=3005 Participants
Students randomized to the universal screening arm will complete the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) during the academic year. This screening tool includes nine close-ended questions with a scoring system ranging from 0 to 27. Scores \>10 are considered a "positive" screen. Students with a positive PHQ-9 result will then proceed to SAP triage as per the current process for those referred via the targeted screening arm. Universal Screening Arm: Students with PHQ-9 score \>10, corresponding to a positive MDD screen, will proceed through the same SAP triage process as students referred by traditional means. SAP triage will determine MDD identification. As SAP triage is not diagnostic, MDD identification is based on SAP recommendations for MDD related school or community services. Treatment engagement will be tracked per current SAP processes. To immediately identify and address suicidal intent, the survey will flag a positive response to PHQ-9 question 9 in real time. A suicidal student would proceed directly to management through the school crisis plan. Students in the intervention arm will also be tracked for behavior concerning for MDD at any point in the school year prompting SAP triage referral.
Male (Targeted Screening)
n=3495 Participants
Male students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Male (Universal Screening)
n=3468 Participants
Male students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic White (Targeted Screening)
n=2857 Participants
Non-Hispanic white students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic White (Universal Screening)
n=2985 Participants
Non-Hispanic white students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Non-Hispanic Black (Targeted Screening)
n=1571 Participants
Non-Hispanic Black students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Non-Hispanic Black (Universal Screening)
n=1320 Participants
Non-Hispanic Black students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Hispanic (Targeted Screening)
n=1266 Participants
Hispanic students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Hispanic (Universal Screening)
n=1421 Participants
Hispanic students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Other (Targeted Screening)
n=742 Participants
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Other (Universal Screening)
n=747 Participants
Students classified as "other" for race/ethnicity who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms.
Urban (Targeted Screening)
n=5728 Participants
Urban students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Urban (Universal Screening)
n=5735 Participants
Urban students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Rural (Targeted Screening)
n=708 Participants
Rural students who were in the control arm, identification of depressive symptoms based on observable behaviors of concern.
Rural (Universal Screening)
n=738 Participants
Rural students who completed the PHQ-9 for identification of depressive symptoms
Subgroup Analyses Based on School District Demographic Data
Initiated treatment
20 Participants
52 Participants
15 Participants
28 Participants
27 Participants
42 Participants
6 Participants
13 Participants
2 Participants
16 Participants
0 Participants
9 Participants
28 Participants
69 Participants
7 Participants
11 Participants
Subgroup Analyses Based on School District Demographic Data
SAP confirmed depressive symptoms in need of follow-up
31 Participants
153 Participants
33 Participants
80 Participants
48 Participants
115 Participants
10 Participants
37 Participants
5 Participants
67 Participants
1 Participants
14 Participants
55 Participants
212 Participants
9 Participants
21 Participants
Subgroup Analyses Based on School District Demographic Data
Identified via PHQ-9 or behaviors of concern
90 Participants
626 Participants
110 Participants
400 Participants
61 Participants
474 Participants
95 Participants
187 Participants
28 Participants
204 Participants
16 Participants
161 Participants
189 Participants
893 Participants
11 Participants
133 Participants

Adverse Events

Targeted Screening Arm (Current Process)

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Universal Screening Arm (Intervention)

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Other adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Additional Information

Deepa Sekhar, Associate Professor of Pediatrics, Executive Director Penn State PRO Wellness

MS Hershey MC

Phone: 7175310003

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place