The Effect of Commercially Available Footwear Interventions in Meniscectomy Patients

NCT ID: NCT03379415

Last Updated: 2020-11-03

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 20 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2018-02-01
• Study Completion Date: 2020-09-20

Brief Summary

Injuries to the meniscus are common in sport. A meniscectomy is often performed to manage symptoms associated with the meniscal injury. Following a meniscectomy individuals are highly likely to develop knee osteoarthritis (OA). Footwear interventions have demonstrated biomechanical changes during walking and running, in healthy and individuals with osteoarthritis. With the increased risk of developing OA associated with meniscectomy patients, understanding biomechanical changes with footwear when compared to healthy individuals, may provide a conservative approach to delaying or minimising the development of (OA). There is no current literature assessing the effect footwear has post meniscectomy, so this is a very novel approach and can yield important results for the management of future risks. Current evidence supports the use of footwear interventions aiming to minimise OA progression in older adults during walking. Yet, meniscectomy patients who have sustained an injury during sport are likely to continue to participate in sport following treatment in their usual footwear. Further evidence is required to better understand the effect of footwear interventions during dynamic movements often performed in sport. Previous studies have assessed customised footwear interventions, however these interventions are not representative of commercially available interventions that could be widely used by the general population. Therefore assessing commercially available footwear will give a more realistic approach to conservative treatment for meniscectomy patients. This project aims to examine biomechanical differences between commercially available footwear conditions in healthy individuals and individuals who have had a meniscal injury. Three-dimensional kinetic and kinematic measures will be assessed during five tasks (walking, running, 90 degrees side cut, single leg landing, and small knee bend squat), for different footwear conditions.

Detailed Description

Injuries to the meniscus are common in sport, often as a result of a traumatic event. Mitchell et al. (2016) reported 5.1 meniscal injuries per 100 000 athletic exposures, with a greater proportion reported during competition (11.9 injuries per 100 000 athletic exposures), compared to practice (2.7 injuries per 100 000 athletic exposures). Rotation around a planted/ inverted foot has been cited as a common mechanism for meniscal injuries, followed by landing and jumping movements. The meniscus aids in stabilising the knee, acting as a shock absorber and transmitting load. Damage to the meniscus is suggest to lead to altered knee mechanics leading to the initiation or acceleration of osteoarthritis (OA) development. Prior meniscal tears are commonly reported in OA patients, in addition, reports suggest 4 to 14 times increased risk of developing OA following a meniscal injury.

Altered knee mechanics have been reported following a meniscal injury, which have been associated with increased likelihood of developing OA. These changes include reduced contact area within the joint and increased contact pressure, resulting in reduced ability to transmit load. Indirect measures of knee loading, such as external knee adductor moments (EKAM) and knee adduction angular impulses (KAAI), have been associated with increased risk of developing OA. Knee joint loading is also determined by the coordination of muscle activity. Greater and longer co-contractions of the medial muscles at the knee have demonstrated faster development of OA in individuals diagnosed with medial knee OA.

Meniscectomies are widely used to manage the symptoms associated with meniscus injuries. Whilst, non-operative therapies have demonstrated improvements in knee pain three years post intervention. However, following these interventions, alter mechanics of the knee have been observed. For instance, following a medial meniscectomy, increases in contact area and pressure at the knee have been observed and suggested to increase the likelihood of developing OA. Increases in EKAM in meniscectomy patients have been associated with changes in tibia alignment and GRF lever arm. Non-invasive interventions such as footwear, could alter biomechanics to lower EKAM and reduce the progression of OA. Following a meniscectomy procedure, most patients tend to go back to wearing their old trainers. Due to the changes in the biomechanics of the knee, it can be assumed that they support and cushioning they need would change too.

Typical sports movements such as landing and cutting require dynamic control of the knee which is very under-researched. Muscle strength recovery is also considered to be important for young individuals after an arthroscopic surgery in order to regain capacity to participate in sports or other activities as both pre- and post-operative knee extensor strength have been reported to predict better functional outcome of knee surgery. The co-contraction between the quadriceps and hamstrings are also important in this as muscle weakness creates a less stable base. Muscle strength is also essential to control movements such as stair descent which is essential for everyday living. This is closely linked with balance and the risk of falling. Having extra support or cushioning in footwear can help aid this control needed for static and dynamic exercises especially post-surgical intervention.

Different footwear interventions have been used in OA patients to reduce knee loading and pain. Lateral wedges have demonstrated reduced medial knee loading in both affected and contralateral limbs. In addition, mobility shoes and lateral wedges which provide additional medial support have been shown to reduce pain in OA patients. However, it is unclear whether footwear interventions are able to alleviate the risk factors associated with the progression of OA following a meniscal injury. For effective self-management, post operation the appropriate footwear is recommended, however there is little evidence to inform what the appropriate footwear is for patient after surgery or with knee OA.

Current evidence on footwear interventions on minimising OA development relies on assessment of linear movements such as walking and running. Yet, it is likely that athletes who sustain a meniscal injury would return to sport and therefore be required to perform movements that require a greater demand and muscular control then reported during walking. It is unclear whether footwear interventions are able to alleviate the risk factors associated with the progression of OA following a meniscal injury in a younger athletic population. Understanding knee loading during sport-specific movements and between sports footwear can provide a greater insight to the risk of OA development for athletic populations. Therefore understanding the effect of commercially available footwear interventions knee loading during sport-specific movements could provide a greater insight to the use conservative interventions to reducing the risk of OA development for athletic populations.

Conditions

Meniscus Injury; Osteoarthritis, Knee; Footwear

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: TREATMENT
• Blinding Strategy: SINGLE

Study Groups

Meniscus Injured

These meniscus patients will be recruited to participate in a single session to wear 4 different pairs of shoes

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Footwear

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Different types of footwear will be tested to see if these can be used to help slow the progression of osteoarthritis in meniscectomy patients or even stop it from occurring.

Footwear

4 Different types of trainers will be used to see the difference in gait in meniscectomy patients

Group Type: EXPERIMENTAL

Gait analysis

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Gait analysis will be done during several different tasks wear the footwear

Interventions

Footwear

Different types of footwear will be tested to see if these can be used to help slow the progression of osteoarthritis in meniscectomy patients or even stop it from occurring.

Intervention Type: DEVICE

Gait analysis

Gait analysis will be done during several different tasks wear the footwear

Intervention Type: PROCEDURE

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

1. Aged between 18 and 40 years

2. Compete and or play sport a minimum two times a week

3. Able to perform sport specific tasks including running, single leg landing and small knee bend squat

4. Meniscectomy group - has had a meniscectomy surgery following a traumatic meniscal injury during a sporting task.

Exclusion Criteria

1. History of lower extremity surgeries (other than a meniscectomy) e.g. ACL reconstruction

2. Evidence of knee osteoarthritis development either assessed clinically (based on ACR criteria) or radiographically (Kellgren-Lawrence grade >1)

3. Previous history of traumatic (other than the sustained meniscal injury), inflammatory or infectious pathology in the lower extremity

4. Evidence of ligament laxity

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 40 Years
• Eligible Sex: ALL
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: No

Sponsors

University of Salford

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Vanessa Walters

Principal Investigator

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Locations

Manchester Institute of Health and Performance

Manchester, Lancashire, United Kingdom

Countries

United Kingdom

References

Starbuck C, Walters V, Herrington L, Barkatali B, Jones R. Knee Offloading by Patients During Walking and Running After Meniscectomy. Orthop J Sports Med. 2024 Mar 21;12(3):23259671231214766. doi: 10.1177/23259671231214766. eCollection 2024 Mar.

Reference Type: DERIVED

PMID: 38524891 (View on PubMed)

Other Identifiers

HSR1617-140

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id