Reliability and Validity of a Shoulder Fatigue Test

NCT ID: NCT03072355

Last Updated: 2017-11-09

Basic Information

• Recruitment Status: COMPLETED
• Clinical Phase: NA
• Total Enrollment: 30 participants
• Study Classification: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Start Date: 2017-05-01
• Study Completion Date: 2017-08-30

Brief Summary

Introduction: The exercise performed with elastic tools has been appearing in the current scenario as a clinical tool because it presents advantages such as easy handling, low cost and safety. However, its use as an assessment tool, specifically for localized muscular resistance, is reduced and not standardized. In addition, there are no records of the physiological / neurofunctional effects of tests that use such a tool, since it allows a differentiated degree of prescription. Objective: To determine the reliability and reproducibility of a shoulder abduction resistance test in two tools, elastic tube and isokinetic dynamometer. In addition to analyzing the metabolic profile of both comparative order and targeting subsequent training prescription. Method: The study will consist of a sample of 30 participants and will be carried out in 2 stages, 15 participants will perform step 1 and the other 15 will perform step 2. The difference between the steps is the order of the tools used to perform the test . Each stage will consist of 5 sessions (Orientation, Familiarization 1 and 2, Test and Retest). During the test and retest sessions the physiological response of the test will be analyzed. In order to observe the response, will be analyzed the lactic anaerobic parameter (lactate concentration), allelic anaerobic (post-exercise oxygen uptake analysis - EPOC), aerobic parameter (VO2 values) and electromyographic measurements. Will be used the statistical package SPSS Statistics 22.0, Pearson's correlation and their respective confidence intervals will indicate the relationship between the numerical variables and multivariate models will be constructed by means of linear regression. The significance level of 5% will be adopted.

Detailed Description

Tests applied

1RM test The 1 RM test in the elastic band is based on the study by ANDERSEN et al. (2016). Elastic bands of the brand Theraband® CLX (Hygienic, Corporation, Akron, Ohio, USA) with a standard length of 1.47m, ranging from very low to very high strength (yellow, red, green, blue, black, silver, gold). Due to possible changes in the mechanical properties of elastic bands during the initial stretching cycles, all elastics will be pre-stretched 100 times.

Initially the research assistant will instruct the participants to sit on a chair, and place their feet together on the elastic band without shoes. Starting with the least elastic resistance (yellow), the research assistant will instruct the participants to perform a shoulder abduction of a unilateral (dominant) shoulder up to 90 ° and hold such a position for 3 seconds (statically). Thus, participants will have to perform the concentric contraction phase without the help of the research assistant before reaching the static test position. Through visual inspection, the search assistant will control the correct positioning of the movement. Two-minute intervals will be taught between resistance levels until it is not possible for the participant to reach and / or hold the position for 3 seconds. When there is a failure, two more attempts to reach and maintain the desired position will be accomplished. During the essay, the research assistant will provide verbal encouragement. The obtained torque will be calculated by a formula based on the study of ANDERSEN et al. (2016).

Isokinetic muscle strength test For the MVIC test, the participant will be seated with the dominant upper limb on the Biodex System Pro 4 isokinetic dynamometer (Biodex Medical System, Shirley-NY, USA). Prior to the test, the participant will undergo a warm-up consisting of 10 repetitions of concentric contraction of abduction-adduction of the shoulder at 180º / s throughout the range of motion. After the warm-up will be given a two-minute rest break to the start of the MVIC. The CIVM will be considered as the Of torque obtained between three 5 second repetitions of abduction, with the dominant upper limb positioned at 90º horizontal abduction of the shoulder. A two-minute interval between replicates will be administered in order to minimize possible fatigue effects. The participant will be instructed to perform their maximum power performance and will be verbally encouraged by the evaluator in each attempt made. Such protocol is based on the one used by BARONI et al., (2010) for lower limb.

Fatigue Resistance Test (TRF) TRF - Elastic Tube: To perform the fatigue resistance test on the elastic tube the participant will initially be positioned sitting on a chair with their feet together stepping on the elastic band without shoes. He will then perform a 20-second abduction-adduction heating of the shoulder from the neutral position to 90 °. The interval of 2 minutes will then be given to start the TRF. This will consist of performing the maximum of the possible repetition with a load of 50% of the 1RM (1½ second in the concentric phase and 1½ second in the eccentric phase).

TRF - Isokinetic Dynamometer: In order to perform the fatigue resistance test in the isokinetic dynamometer, the participant will initially be positioned with the dominant upper limb attached to the dynamometer by means of the apparatus itself. He will then perform a warm-up of 10 concentric contractions of abduction-adduction of the shoulder at 180º / s throughout the range of movement (0º to 90º). The interval of 2 minutes will then be given to start the TRF. This will consist of performing the maximum possible repetition at 50% of the MVIC at the rate of 60º / s for abduction and 500º / s at the return of the movement.

Conditions

Healthy Volunteers

Keywords

fatigue; resistance test

Study Design

• Allocation Method: RANDOMIZED
• Intervention Model: PARALLEL
• Primary Study Purpose: DIAGNOSTIC
• Blinding Strategy: NONE

Study Groups

Elastic Band

Perform the maximum of the possible repetition with a load of 50% of the 1RM (performing 1½ seconds in the concentric phase and 1½ seconds in the eccentric phase).

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Elastic Band

Intervention Type: OTHER

Localized muscle resistance test for shoulder

Isokinetic dynamometer

Realization of the maximum of the possible repetition to 50% of the MIVM in the speed of 60º / s for abduction and 500º / s in the return of the movement.

Group Type: ACTIVE_COMPARATOR

Isokinetic dynamometer

Intervention Type: OTHER

Localized muscle resistance test for shoulder

Interventions

Elastic Band

Localized muscle resistance test for shoulder

Intervention Type: OTHER

Isokinetic dynamometer

Localized muscle resistance test for shoulder

Intervention Type: OTHER

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria

• Healthy
• Male gender
• Aged between 18 and 30 years
• Agreement to participate through signed statement of informed consent

Exclusion Criteria

• Be an alcoholic,
• Consume drugs,
• Consuming tobacco or anti-inflammatory medications in a chronic way,
• Anemia, an inflammatory process, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and
• an episode of muscle-tendon or osteoarticular injury in the lower limbs and / or spine in the last six months.

• Minimum Eligible Age: 18 Years
• Maximum Eligible Age: 30 Years
• Eligible Sex: MALE
• Accepts Healthy Volunteers: Yes

Sponsors

Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel

OTHER

Sponsor Role: collaborator

São Paulo State University

OTHER

Sponsor Role: lead

Responsible Party

Jaqueline Santos Silva

Master's Degree student

Responsibility Role: PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATOR

Locations

Carlos Pastre, PhD

Presidente Prudente, , Brazil

Countries

Brazil

Other Identifiers

PP1

Identifier Type: -

Identifier Source: org_study_id