Trial Outcomes & Findings for Ablation Verses Anti-arrhythmic Therapy for Reducing All Hospital Episodes From Recurrent Atrial Fibrillation (NCT NCT02459574)

NCT ID: NCT02459574

Last Updated: 2024-10-09

Results Overview

Composite outcome measure - Hospital episodes (Emergency Room or Patient Request for OPD) Related to Treatment for Atrial Arrhythmia

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

NA

Target enrollment

321 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

12 months

Results posted on

2024-10-09

Participant Flow

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Overall Study
STARTED
108
103
110
Overall Study
COMPLETED
101
95
108
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
7
8
2

Reasons for withdrawal

Reasons for withdrawal
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Overall Study
Withdrawal by Subject
6
6
2
Overall Study
Lost to Follow-up
1
1
0
Overall Study
Death
0
1
0

Baseline Characteristics

Missing BMI data for 4nr participants

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=108 Participants
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=103 Participants
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=110 Participants
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Total
n=321 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Age, Continuous
59.7 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 12.22 • n=108 Participants
60.5 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 10.34 • n=103 Participants
60.1 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.00 • n=110 Participants
60.1 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 10.57 • n=321 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
42 Participants
n=108 Participants
46 Participants
n=103 Participants
46 Participants
n=110 Participants
134 Participants
n=321 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
66 Participants
n=108 Participants
57 Participants
n=103 Participants
64 Participants
n=110 Participants
187 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · Asian
3 Participants
n=108 Participants
1 Participants
n=103 Participants
0 Participants
n=110 Participants
4 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · Black
1 Participants
n=108 Participants
0 Participants
n=103 Participants
0 Participants
n=110 Participants
1 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · Chinese
0 Participants
n=108 Participants
1 Participants
n=103 Participants
0 Participants
n=110 Participants
1 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · Mixed
0 Participants
n=108 Participants
0 Participants
n=103 Participants
2 Participants
n=110 Participants
2 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · White
104 Participants
n=108 Participants
100 Participants
n=103 Participants
108 Participants
n=110 Participants
312 Participants
n=321 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ethnicity · Other
0 Participants
n=108 Participants
1 Participants
n=103 Participants
0 Participants
n=110 Participants
1 Participants
n=321 Participants
BMI (Body Mass Index)
28.88 kg/m^2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.670 • n=107 Participants • Missing BMI data for 4nr participants
27.98 kg/m^2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.830 • n=100 Participants • Missing BMI data for 4nr participants
29.12 kg/m^2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.040 • n=110 Participants • Missing BMI data for 4nr participants
28.68 kg/m^2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.860 • n=317 Participants • Missing BMI data for 4nr participants
No. with Hypertension
Non-Hypertensive
79 Participants
n=108 Participants
67 Participants
n=103 Participants
72 Participants
n=110 Participants
218 Participants
n=321 Participants
No. with Hypertension
Hypertensive
29 Participants
n=108 Participants
36 Participants
n=103 Participants
38 Participants
n=110 Participants
103 Participants
n=321 Participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
0
43 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
36 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
35 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
114 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
1
22 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
24 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
30 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
76 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
5
1 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
1 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
0 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
2 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
2
23 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
19 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
28 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
70 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
3
10 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
17 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
12 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
39 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
4
6 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
4 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
4 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
14 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
CHADSVASc Score (congestive heart failure, hypertension)
6
2 Participants
n=107 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
1 Participants
n=102 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
0 Participants
n=109 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
3 Participants
n=318 Participants • The full name for CHADSVASc is Congestive Heart Failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 (Doubled), Diabetes Mellitus, Prior Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack (Doubled), Vascular Disease, Age 65-74, Sex category. CHADSVASc missing for 3nr participants
Ejection Fraction
58.3 %
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.00 • n=93 Participants • 44 participants EJF missing at BL
57.9 %
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.60 • n=93 Participants • 44 participants EJF missing at BL
57.1 %
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.88 • n=91 Participants • 44 participants EJF missing at BL
57.8 %
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.18 • n=277 Participants • 44 participants EJF missing at BL

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 12 months

Population: All randomized participants are eligible for ITT analysis - however, any patients that withdraw prior to first intervention cannot be assessed for the time-to-event based analysis

Composite outcome measure - Hospital episodes (Emergency Room or Patient Request for OPD) Related to Treatment for Atrial Arrhythmia

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=106 Participants
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=100 Participants
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=109 Participants
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
All Hospital Episodes (Emergency Room or Patient Request for OPD) Related to Treatment for Atrial Arrhythmia
19 Participants
76 Participants
23 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 12 months

Population: Full ITT Population

Composite outcome measure

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=108 Participants
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=103 Participants
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=110 Participants
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Death or Stroke From Any Cause
0 Participants
1 Participants
0 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 12 months

Population: ITT Population

Composite outcome measure - Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding \>2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=108 Participants
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=103 Participants
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=110 Participants
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
All Events
3 participants
19 participants
7 participants
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
Drug Side Effect/Allergic Reaction
1 participants
18 participants
2 participants
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
Vascular Complication
1 participants
0 participants
3 participants
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
Cardiac Tamponade
0 participants
0 participants
2 participants
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
Phrenic Nerve Palsy
0 participants
0 participants
0 participants
Any Complications Caused by the Procedure (Pericardial Effusion, Bleeding >2 Units, Phrenic Nerve Palsy and Other) or the Anti-arrhythmic Drug (GI Disturbance, Skin Irritation and Other)
TIA
1 participants
1 participants
0 participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 12 months

Composite outcome measure - All hospital episodes which result in a change in therapy for atrial arrhythmia

Outcome measures

Outcome data not reported

Adverse Events

Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation

Serious events: 16 serious events
Other events: 43 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy

Serious events: 12 serious events
Other events: 50 other events
Deaths: 1 deaths

Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol

Serious events: 13 serious events
Other events: 57 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Serious adverse events
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=108 participants at risk
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=103 participants at risk
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=110 participants at risk
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Cardiac disorders
Death
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Atrial Fibrillation/Flutter
1.9%
2/108 • Number of events 3 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
4.9%
5/103 • Number of events 5 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
4.5%
5/110 • Number of events 6 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Atrial Tachycardia
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Tamponade
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
1.8%
2/110 • Number of events 2 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Mass In Left Atrium
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Chest Pain
1.9%
2/108 • Number of events 2 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
2.9%
3/103 • Number of events 3 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Eye disorders
Bilateral Papilledema.
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Palpitation
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Nervous system disorders
Right Arm And Face Numbness
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.91%
1/110 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Injury To Right Hand
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Pneumonia & Bronchospasm.
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Vascular disorders
Haemoptysis
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Investigations
Nose Surgery
0.00%
0/108 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.97%
1/103 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Bleeding From Groin
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Pelvic Floor Repair
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Rheumatoid Arthritis
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Psychiatric disorders
Anxiety
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Gastrointestinal disorders
Diverticulitis
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Fractured Ribs, Cuts And Bruises.
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Strand Of Likely Thrombus Attached To Septum
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Surgical and medical procedures
Hip Replacement.
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders
Femoral Entry Wound
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Nervous system disorders
Sciatica
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Surgical and medical procedures
Knee Replacement
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Bradycardia
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
TIA
0.93%
1/108 • Number of events 1 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/103 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
0.00%
0/110 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)

Other adverse events

Other adverse events
Measure
Group 3-Conventional AF Ablation
n=108 participants at risk
This will involve an ablation procedure carried out in the usual manner. The patient will have three sheaths placed in the leg veins. Catheters will be passed up to the patient's heart from these veins. Two crossing are required into the left atrium. The ablation will involve freeze technology using the Advance Cryoballoon. It will include measuring the electrical signals and may also involve radiofrequency or 'burning' technology in addition. Conventional AF ablation: Conventional ablation procedure
Group 2-Anti-arrhythmic Therapy
n=103 participants at risk
Anti-arrhythmic drugs: On the treatment start date the patient will have a new tablet prescribed or a change in the dosage of the medication. The patient will be reviewed at 8wks (visit 1) later to see if the medication is working. If the tablets are working, the patients medication will be left unchanged. If not, an alternative tablet or a higher dose will be used. Anti-Arrhythmic therapy: Group 2 will be prescribed medication listed below: Amiodarone; Dronaderone; Sotalol Beta blockers; Calcium channel blockers; Flecainide; or Propafenone. You will then be discharged from clinic. A research nurse will contact you by phone to make sure there are no problems and can make hospital appointments if needed.
Group 1-AVATAR-AF Ablation Protocol
n=110 participants at risk
AF ablation with pulmonary vein isolation. The patient will have two sheaths in their leg veins instead of the usual three sheaths. Catheters will be passed up to the heart from these leg veins. The single crossing into the left atrium will be by the usual method. Veins will be ablated using freeze technology known as the Advance Cryoballoon. After the ablation is completed the patient will have scans on their heart and checks of the leg veins. If all the checks are satisfactory at six hours after the procedure the patient will be allowed to go home on the same day. The patient will be reviewed in clinic in 8 weeks (visit 1) after the procedure and if it has been successful, will be reviewed again a month later (visit 2) and if all is well, the patient will be discharged from clinic. AVATAR-AF ablation: Experimental ablation protocol
Cardiac disorders
Atrial Fibrillation
5.6%
6/108 • Number of events 7 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
10.7%
11/103 • Number of events 11 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
10.0%
11/110 • Number of events 16 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Cardiac disorders
Palpitations
3.7%
4/108 • Number of events 7 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
3.9%
4/103 • Number of events 4 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
5.5%
6/110 • Number of events 6 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
Investigations
All other events < 5% Freq
30.6%
33/108 • Number of events 57 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
40.8%
42/103 • Number of events 67 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)
43.6%
48/110 • Number of events 75 • AE's are collected from Randomization up to 1-year end-of-Study Visit
All SAE's were reviewed by an independent Data Monitoring and Safety Board (DSMB)

Additional Information

Prof. Prapa Kanagaratnam

Imperial College London

Phone: 02033123783

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place