Trial Outcomes & Findings for In-vivo Efficacy Study of Patient Pre-operative Preps (NCT NCT01968707)

NCT ID: NCT01968707

Last Updated: 2024-10-02

Results Overview

On the abdominal region a responder was a subject with a 2 log10/cm2 bacterial reduction at 10 minutes and for whom the skin flora did not return to baseline. On the inguinal region a responder was a subject with a 3 log10/cm2 bacterial reduction at 10 minutes and for whom the skin flora did not return to baseline.

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

PHASE3

Target enrollment

426 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

baseline, 10 minutes post-product application and 6 hour post-product application

Results posted on

2024-10-02

Participant Flow

This is a randomized, paired comparison design where each subject received 2 of the planned treatments, 1 on the left side \& 1 on the right. Each subject provided 2 abdomen test sites, left \& right and/or 2 inguen test sites, left \& right. 406 subjects were randomized for the abdomen region \& 391 subjects randomized for the inguen region resulting in 426 subjects providing 1594 applications of test products on 2 anatomical regions.

Unit of analysis: test sites on skin

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
Normal Saline - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
Overall Study
STARTED
247 247
74 74
246 246
245 245
236 236
70 70
238 238
238 238
Overall Study
COMPLETED
198 198
62 62
205 205
201 201
200 200
59 59
204 204
203 203
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
49 49
12 12
41 41
44 44
36 36
11 11
34 34
35 35

Reasons for withdrawal

Reasons for withdrawal
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
Normal Saline - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
Overall Study
Did not meet treatment day baseline
49
12
41
44
36
11
34
35

Baseline Characteristics

In-vivo Efficacy Study of Patient Pre-operative Preps

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=247 Test sites on skin
ChloraPrep 2% CHG/70% IPA 26-mL applicator applied topically for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=74 Test sites on skin
Normal Saline with applicator applied topically for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=246 Test sites on skin
3M CHG/IPA 2% CHG/70% IPA 10.5-mL applicator applied topically for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=245 Test sites on skin
3M CHG/IPA 2% CHG/70% IPA 26-mL applicator applied topically for 30 seconds.
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=236 Test sites on skin
ChloraPrep 2% CHG/70% IPA 26-mL applicator applied topically for 2 minutes.
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=70 Test sites on skin
Normal Saline with applicator applied topically for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=238 Test sites on skin
3M CHG/IPA 2% CHG/70% IPA 10.5-mL applicator applied topically for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep 26-mL - Inguinal
n=238 Test sites on skin
3M CHG/IPA 2% CHG/70% IPA 26-mL applicator applied topically for 2 minutes.
Total
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Total of all reporting groups
Age, Customized
<=18 years
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=236 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
0 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Age, Customized
Between 18 and 65 years
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=236 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
409 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Age, Customized
>=65 years
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
17 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Sex/Gender, Customized
Female
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
213 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Sex/Gender, Customized
Male
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=23 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
213 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
American Indian or Alaska Native
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
2 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Asian
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
136 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Black or African American
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Hispanic/Latino
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=236 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
49 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Native Hawiian or Other Pacific Islander
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=23 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
2 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
White
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
237 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
160 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Other
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
7 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin
Region of Enrollment
United States
247 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
74 participants
n=135 Test sites on skin
246 participants
n=38 Test sites on skin
245 participants
n=308 Test sites on skin
236 participants
n=96 Test sites on skin
70 participants
n=70 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
238 participants
n=238 Test sites on skin
426 participants
n=1594 Test sites on skin

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: baseline, 10 minutes post-product application and 6 hour post-product application

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

On the abdominal region a responder was a subject with a 2 log10/cm2 bacterial reduction at 10 minutes and for whom the skin flora did not return to baseline. On the inguinal region a responder was a subject with a 3 log10/cm2 bacterial reduction at 10 minutes and for whom the skin flora did not return to baseline.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Responder Rate
178 Participants
167 Participants
175 Participants
0 Participants
168 Participants
168 Participants
162 Participants
4 Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 6 hours

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

log10/cm2 reduction of skin flora, relative to treatment day baseline (log10/cm2), at 6 hours post-treatment

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Reduction of Skin Flora 6 Hours Post-treatment
1.77 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.899
0.47 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.651
1.48 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.866
1.64 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.864
2.64 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 1.047
1.08 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.833
2.24 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 1.103
2.35 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 1.045

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 10 minutes

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

log10/cm2 reduction of skin flora, relative to treatment day baseline (log10/cm2), at 10 minutes post-treatment

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Reduction of Skin Flora 10 Minutes Post-treatment
2.79 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.565
0.64 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.488
2.66 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.706
2.74 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.644
4.04 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.964
1.34 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 1.096
3.98 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 1.034
3.89 log10/cm2
Standard Deviation 0.929

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 6 hours post-treatment

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

Log10/cm2 recovery of skin flora at 6 hours following application of study treatment

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Skin Flora Recovery 6-hours Post-treatment
1.54 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.808
2.80 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.726
1.87 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.804
1.66 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.803
2.81 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.008
4.31 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.941
3.20 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.037
3.07 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.032

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 10 minutes post-treatment

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

Log10/cm2 recovery of skin flora at 10 minutes following application of study treatments

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Skin Flora Recovery 10 Minutes Post-treatment
0.52 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.500
2.63 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.582
0.69 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.604
0.57 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.575
1.41 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.089
4.06 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.211
1.47 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.120
1.53 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 1.039

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Baseline

Population: The primary analysis data set used a Modified Intent to Treat population. Subjects were excluded who did not meet the treatment day baseline requirements of either \> or equal to 3.0 log10 on the abdomen test site or 5.0 log10 on the inguinal test site.

Log10/cm2 baseline skin flora for abdominal and inguinal regions

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=198 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=62 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=205 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=201 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=200 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=59 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=204 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=203 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Skin Flora Baseline for the Abdominal and Inguinal Region.
3.31 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.391
3.27 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.342
3.35 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.427
3.31 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.370
5.44 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.479
5.40 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.448
5.44 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.490
5.42 log10/cm2 skin flora
Standard Deviation 0.469

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Assessed at baseline (pre-treatment) and 10 minute post-treatment and 6 hour post-treatment.

Population: The primary safety analysis data set used an Intent to Treat population.

Skin irritation (dryness, edema, erythema, rash) assessed on the test sites using a 0-3 rating scale: 0=no reaction, 1=mild, 2=moderated, 3=severe

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal
n=247 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal
n=74 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal
n=246 Participants
Applied topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds.
Normal Saline - Abdominal
n=245 Participants
Apply topically to the abdominal region for 30 seconds
ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal
n=236 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal
n=70 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes.
3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal
n=238 Participants
Applied topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Normal Saline - Inguinal
n=238 Participants
Apply topically to the inguinal region for 2 minutes
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Erythema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Erythema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Erythema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Edema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Edema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Dryness-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Dryness-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Dryness-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Dryness-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Edema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Edema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Edema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Edema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Erythema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Rash-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Rash-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Rash-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
Baseline Rash-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Dryness-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Dryness-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Dryness-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Dryness-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Rash-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Edema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Edema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Erythema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Erythema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Erythema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Erythema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Rash-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Rash-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Rash-Mild (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
10 minute Rash-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Dryness-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Dryness-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Dryness-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Dryness-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Edema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Edema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Edema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Edema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Erythema-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Erythema-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Erythema-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Erythema-Severe (3)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Rash-No Reaction (0)
247 test sites on skin
74 test sites on skin
246 test sites on skin
245 test sites on skin
236 test sites on skin
70 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
238 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Rash-Mild (1)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
Safety as Assessed by Skin Irritation (Dryness, Edema, Erythema, Rash) Rating Score
6 hour Rash-Moderate (2)
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin
0 test sites on skin

Adverse Events

ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Abdominal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Normal Saline - Abdominal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Abdominal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Abdominal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

ChloraPrep Hi-Lite Orange - Inguinal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Normal Saline - Inguinal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 10.5-mL - Inguinal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

3M CHG/IPA Prep Tint 26-mL - Inguinal

Serious events: 0 serious events
Other events: 0 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Other adverse events

Adverse event data not reported

Additional Information

Joan Paulson

3M

Phone: 651-736-6583

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee
  • Publication restrictions are in place