Trial Outcomes & Findings for A Study Evaluating the Gastrointestinal (GI) Safety and Tolerability of Aliskiren Compared to Ramipril in Essential Hypertension (NCT NCT00631917)

NCT ID: NCT00631917

Last Updated: 2011-07-12

Results Overview

The primary analysis variable was the occurrence of an abnormal colonoscopy finding (defined as hyper-plastic polyps, inflammatory polyps, adenomatous polyps or carcinoma) at or prior to the planned one year visit. The occurrence of colonic pathology was identified during colonoscopy and histopathologic examination of biopsy. The composite endpoint was evaluated after one year of treatment with an aliskiren-based regimen compared to a ramipril-based regimen.

Recruitment status

COMPLETED

Study phase

PHASE4

Target enrollment

774 participants

Primary outcome timeframe

54 weeks

Results posted on

2011-07-12

Participant Flow

Participant milestones

Participant milestones
Measure
Aliskiren
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Overall Study
STARTED
375
399
Overall Study
COMPLETED
287
291
Overall Study
NOT COMPLETED
88
108

Reasons for withdrawal

Reasons for withdrawal
Measure
Aliskiren
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Overall Study
Adverse Event
34
45
Overall Study
Abnormal laboratory value(s)
2
1
Overall Study
Abnormal test procedure result(s)
3
2
Overall Study
Unsatisfactory therapeutic effect
8
14
Overall Study
No longer required study drug
0
1
Overall Study
Protocol deviation
6
5
Overall Study
Subject withdrew consent
25
33
Overall Study
Lost to Follow-up
7
7
Overall Study
Administrative problems
2
0
Overall Study
Death
1
0

Baseline Characteristics

A Study Evaluating the Gastrointestinal (GI) Safety and Tolerability of Aliskiren Compared to Ramipril in Essential Hypertension

Baseline characteristics by cohort

Baseline characteristics by cohort
Measure
Aliskiren
n=375 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=399 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Total
n=774 Participants
Total of all reporting groups
Age Continuous
59.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.99 • n=5 Participants
59.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.65 • n=7 Participants
59.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.81 • n=5 Participants
Age, Customized
< 65 years
299 Participants
n=5 Participants
313 Participants
n=7 Participants
612 Participants
n=5 Participants
Age, Customized
65 years and greater
76 Participants
n=5 Participants
86 Participants
n=7 Participants
162 Participants
n=5 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
194 Participants
n=5 Participants
194 Participants
n=7 Participants
388 Participants
n=5 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
181 Participants
n=5 Participants
205 Participants
n=7 Participants
386 Participants
n=5 Participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 54 weeks

Population: Primary Analysis Set, consisting of all randomized patients that had post-baseline colonoscopy procedure performed.

The primary analysis variable was the occurrence of an abnormal colonoscopy finding (defined as hyper-plastic polyps, inflammatory polyps, adenomatous polyps or carcinoma) at or prior to the planned one year visit. The occurrence of colonic pathology was identified during colonoscopy and histopathologic examination of biopsy. The composite endpoint was evaluated after one year of treatment with an aliskiren-based regimen compared to a ramipril-based regimen.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Aliskiren
n=314 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=325 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Percentage of Participants With Colonic Pathology
25.5 Percentage of participants
25.1 Percentage of participants

PRIMARY outcome

Timeframe: 54 weeks

Population: Primary Analysis Set, consisting of all randomized patients that had post-baseline colonoscopy procedure performed.

During each colonoscopy procedure, random biopsy samples were taken from normal appearing mucosa in both the cecum and rectum in addition to obvious endoscopically atypical areas. The mucosal biopsy samples were evaluated for mucosal hyperplasia, dysplasia, and inflammation. Anything noted as a distinct visual abnormality from cecum to rectum such as ulcers, erythematous mucosa, or polyps, was photographed and biopsied for histopathology evaluation. Colonic lesions were categorized according to location in the colon, size, number, and morphology.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Aliskiren
n=314 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=325 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Inflammation for any biopsy samples-Missing
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Complete colonoscopy performed
100 Percentage of Participants
100 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Was cecum reached in procedure
99.7 Percentage of Participants
100 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Photos obtained
99.4 Percentage of Participants
99.7 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Took drug affecting bowel function
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Took low dose aspirin during wk prior to procedure
4.8 Percentage of Participants
5.2 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Adequacy of bowel preparation - Optimal
72.3 Percentage of Participants
73.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Adequacy of bowel preparation - Suboptimal
27.4 Percentage of Participants
25.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Adequacy of bowel preparation - Inadequate
0.3 Percentage of Participants
0.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Colonoscopy prep given- PEG containing solution
96.8 Percentage of Participants
97.2 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Colonoscopy prep given - Other
3.2 Percentage of Participants
2.8 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Occurrence of colon polyps
29.6 Percentage of Participants
26.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with polyps-Cecum/ascending
11.8 Percentage of Participants
11.4 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with polyps-Transverse
6.1 Percentage of Participants
5.2 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with polyps-Descending/sigmoid
12.1 Percentage of Participants
11.7 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with polyps-Rectum
8.0 Percentage of Participants
6.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of polyps-Cecum/ascending
1.3 Percentage of Participants
1.2 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of polyps-Transverse
1.2 Percentage of Participants
1.4 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of polyps-Descending/sigmoid
1.5 Percentage of Participants
1.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of polyps-Rectum
1.6 Percentage of Participants
1.3 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Polyps were completely resected-Cecum/ascending
11.8 Percentage of Participants
11.1 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Polyps were completely resected-Transverse
6.1 Percentage of Participants
4.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Polyps were completely resected-Descending/sigmoid
12.1 Percentage of Participants
11.7 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Polyps were completely resected-Rectum
7.6 Percentage of Participants
6.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Photo taken for polyps-Cecum/ascending
11.8 Percentage of Participants
11.1 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Photo taken for polyps-Transverse
5.7 Percentage of Participants
4.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Photo taken for polyps-Descending/sigmoid
10.8 Percentage of Participants
10.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Photo taken for polyps-Rectum
7.6 Percentage of Participants
6.2 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mucosal abnormalities for colitis
1.3 Percentage of Participants
1.5 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with colitis-Cecum/ascending
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with colitis-Transverse
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with colitis-Descending/sigmoid
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Patients with colitis-Rectum
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis biopsied-Cecum/ascending
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis biopsied-Transverse
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis biopsied-Descending/sigmoid
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis biopsied-Rectum
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis photographed-Cecum/ascending
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis photographed-Transverse
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis photographed-Descending/sigmoid
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Area of colitis photographed-Rectum
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Normal mucosal biopsies collected-Cecum
99.4 Percentage of Participants
99.7 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of normal mucosal biopsies-Cecum
3.0 Percentage of Participants
3.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Mean number of normal mucosal biopsies-Rectum
3.0 Percentage of Participants
3.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Malignance for any biopsy samples-Yes
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Malignance for any biopsy samples-No
99.4 Percentage of Participants
98.8 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Malignance for any biopsy samples-Missing
0.6 Percentage of Participants
0.9 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Inflammation for any biopsy samples-Yes
1.0 Percentage of Participants
0.6 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Inflammation for any biopsy samples-No
98.4 Percentage of Participants
98.8 Percentage of Participants
Summary of the End of Study Colonoscopy Results
Normal mucosal biopsies collected-Rectum
99.7 Percentage of Participants
99.7 Percentage of Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 54 weeks

Population: Primary analysis set

Assessment of the occurrence of the individual components (hyperplastic polyps, inflammatory polyps, adenomatous polyps or carcinomas) of the composite endpoint (colonic pathology) following one-year of treatment with an aliskiren-based regimen compared to a ramipril-based regimen.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Aliskiren
n=314 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=325 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Percentage of Participants With Each of the Individual Components of Colonic Pathology
Hyperplastic polyps
13.1 Percentage of Participants
10.2 Percentage of Participants
Percentage of Participants With Each of the Individual Components of Colonic Pathology
Inflammatory polyps
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.3 Percentage of Participants
Percentage of Participants With Each of the Individual Components of Colonic Pathology
Adenomatous polyps
15.0 Percentage of Participants
17.3 Percentage of Participants
Percentage of Participants With Each of the Individual Components of Colonic Pathology
Carcinoma
0.0 Percentage of Participants
0.0 Percentage of Participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: 54 weeks

Population: Primary analysis set

Maximum hyperplasia score at end of study across rectal and cecal mucosa biopsy specimens. Score of 0 is no change from baseline, the minimum possible score. Score \> 0 is worsening from baseline in which the maximum possible score is 3.

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Aliskiren
n=314 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=325 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Mucosal Hyperplasia Score in Rectal and Cecal Mucosal Biopsy Specimens After One Year of Treatment
Score = 1
17 participants
19 participants
Mucosal Hyperplasia Score in Rectal and Cecal Mucosal Biopsy Specimens After One Year of Treatment
Score = 2
0 participants
0 participants
Mucosal Hyperplasia Score in Rectal and Cecal Mucosal Biopsy Specimens After One Year of Treatment
Score is Missing
2 participants
2 participants
Mucosal Hyperplasia Score in Rectal and Cecal Mucosal Biopsy Specimens After One Year of Treatment
Score = 0
295 participants
304 participants
Mucosal Hyperplasia Score in Rectal and Cecal Mucosal Biopsy Specimens After One Year of Treatment
Score = 3
0 participants
0 participants

SECONDARY outcome

Timeframe: Weeks 8, 30 and End of Study (54 weeks)

Population: Full analysis set

The mean sitting blood pressure control target is defined as less than 140/90 mmHg (or 130/80 mmHg for diabetic patients)

Outcome measures

Outcome measures
Measure
Aliskiren
n=374 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=394 Participants
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Percentage of Participants Achieving the Mean Sitting Blood Pressure Control Target
Week 8
50.8 Percentage of Participants
44.9 Percentage of Participants
Percentage of Participants Achieving the Mean Sitting Blood Pressure Control Target
Week 30
60.2 Percentage of Participants
54.1 Percentage of Participants
Percentage of Participants Achieving the Mean Sitting Blood Pressure Control Target
End of Study
65.0 Percentage of Participants
56.1 Percentage of Participants

Adverse Events

Aliskiren

Serious events: 28 serious events
Other events: 163 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Ramipril

Serious events: 22 serious events
Other events: 176 other events
Deaths: 0 deaths

Serious adverse events

Serious adverse events
Measure
Aliskiren
n=375 participants at risk
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=399 participants at risk
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Cardiac disorders
Atrioventricular block complete
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Cardiac disorders
Coronary artery disease
0.80%
3/375
0.25%
1/399
Cardiac disorders
Myocardial infarction
0.80%
3/375
0.50%
2/399
Cardiac disorders
Tachycardia
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Endocrine disorders
Hyperparathyroidism primary
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Gastrointestinal disorders
Abdominal pain upper
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Gastrointestinal disorders
Diarrhoea haemorrhagic
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Gastrointestinal disorders
Inguinal hernia
0.00%
0/375
0.50%
2/399
Gastrointestinal disorders
Lower gastrointestinal haemorrhage
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
General disorders
Non-cardiac chest pain
0.53%
2/375
0.00%
0/399
Hepatobiliary disorders
Bile duct stone
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Hepatobiliary disorders
Cholecystitis acute
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Hepatobiliary disorders
Cholelithiasis
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Immune system disorders
Type III immune complex mediated reaction
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Infections and infestations
Appendicitis
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Infections and infestations
Arthritis bacterial
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Infections and infestations
Bronchitis
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Infections and infestations
Staphylococcal infection
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Femur fracture
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
In-stent arterial restenosis
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Meniscus lesion
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Post procedural haemorrhage
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Costochondritis
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Spinal osteoarthritis
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)
Basal cell carcinoma
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)
Prostate cancer
0.53%
2/375
0.00%
0/399
Nervous system disorders
Cerebrovascular accident
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Nervous system disorders
Facial palsy
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Nervous system disorders
Occipital neuralgia
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Nervous system disorders
Subarachnoid haemorrhage
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Nervous system disorders
Syncope
0.53%
2/375
0.00%
0/399
Nervous system disorders
Transient ischaemic attack
0.27%
1/375
0.50%
2/399
Renal and urinary disorders
Calculus ureteric
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Renal and urinary disorders
Cystitis haemorrhagic
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Renal and urinary disorders
Nephrolithiasis
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Renal and urinary disorders
Renal failure acute
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Laryngeal oedema
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Pulmonary embolism
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Vascular disorders
Aortic dissection
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399
Vascular disorders
Arteritis
0.00%
0/375
0.25%
1/399
Vascular disorders
Hypertension
0.80%
3/375
0.00%
0/399
Vascular disorders
Hypertensive crisis
0.53%
2/375
0.00%
0/399
Vascular disorders
Hypertensive emergency
0.27%
1/375
0.00%
0/399

Other adverse events

Other adverse events
Measure
Aliskiren
n=375 participants at risk
For the first 2 weeks of the study, participants received aliskiren 150 mg once a day and were then forced titrated to aliskiren 300 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received a placebo capsule to match ramipril once a day for the study duration.
Ramipril
n=399 participants at risk
For the first 2 weeks of the study participants received 5 mg ramipril orally once a day and were then forced titrated to ramipril 10 mg once a day for 52 weeks. Participants also received placebo to aliskiren for the duration of the study.
Gastrointestinal disorders
Diarrhoea
7.5%
28/375
6.0%
24/399
Gastrointestinal disorders
Nausea
5.1%
19/375
3.8%
15/399
General disorders
Oedema peripheral
7.5%
28/375
5.0%
20/399
Infections and infestations
Nasopharyngitis
5.1%
19/375
5.3%
21/399
Infections and infestations
Upper respiratory tract infection
7.2%
27/375
6.5%
26/399
Infections and infestations
Urinary tract infection
5.6%
21/375
2.5%
10/399
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Back pain
4.5%
17/375
5.5%
22/399
Nervous system disorders
Dizziness
6.1%
23/375
7.3%
29/399
Nervous system disorders
Headache
10.9%
41/375
13.5%
54/399
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Cough
3.7%
14/375
12.0%
48/399

Additional Information

Study Director

Novartis Pharmaceuticals

Phone: 862-778-8300

Results disclosure agreements

  • Principal investigator is a sponsor employee The terms and conditions of Novartis' agreements with its investigators may vary. However, Novartis does not prohibit any investigator from publishing. Any publications from a single-site are postponed until the publication of the pooled data (i.e., data from all sites) in the clinical trial.
  • Publication restrictions are in place

Restriction type: OTHER